The Robert and Sarah Morriss Story

Charles William Button (1822-1894): Lynchburg Daily Virginian. "Addy" not working... BUT! "Google" For good and bad Civil War editor was man of his times. The ORIGINAL newspaper article, News & Advance - Sunday, April 19, 2015 stated: "He (Button) ended his newspaper career with a bizarre interlude in which he sold the Daily Virginian to one of his sub-editors (John W. Sherman) who had earlier written a DIME NOVEL that may have sparked the BEALE TREASURE legend about a hoard of GOLD buried in Bedford. Button bought the paper back." (p. B3).
 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

Minelab PRO-FIND 35 Waterproof Pinpointer Metal Detector for Experts with Tone ID & Adjustable Sensitivity - Grab it through Amazon!
Last edited:
Rebel - KGC said:
Charles William Button (1822-1894): Lynchburg Daily Virginian. "Addy" not working... BUT! "Google" For good and bad Civil War editor was man of his times. The ORIGINAL newspaper article, News & Advance - Sunday, April 19, 2015 stated: "He (Button) ended his newspaper career with a bizarre interlude in which he sold the Daily Virginian to one of his sub-editors (John W. Sherman) who had earlier written a DIME NOVEL that may have sparked the BEALE TREASURE legend about a hoard of GOLD buried in Bedford. Button bought the paper back." (p. B3).
Click to expand...

Just more, he said this and she said that. There's plenty of that for both sides of the issue. It's not proof.
 

Rebel - KGC said:
Charles William Button (1822-1894): Lynchburg Daily Virginian. "Addy" not working... BUT! "Google" For good and bad Civil War editor was man of his times. The ORIGINAL newspaper article, News & Advance - Sunday, April 19, 2015 stated: "He (Button) ended his newspaper career with a bizarre interlude in which he sold the Daily Virginian to one of his sub-editors (John W. Sherman) who had earlier written a DIME NOVEL that may have sparked the BEALE TREASURE legend about a hoard of GOLD buried in Bedford. Button bought the paper back." (p. B3).
Click to expand...

Someone's opinion on what MAY HAVE been. Not proof. But I agree that it MAY HAVE been that.

Besides, that quote doesn't say Sherman wrote the Beale papers, as you earlier claimed.
 

Last edited:
"He ended his newspaper career with a bizarre interlude in which he sold the Daily Virginian to one of his sub-editors who had earlier wntten a dime novel that may have sparked the Beale Treasure legend about a hoard of gold buried in Bedford. Then, Button bought the paper back."

If you'll notice, the above quote is not the words of Button, but rather the person telling the story of Button. Button was not the one who said that one of his sub-editors had earlier written a dime novel that may have sparked the Beale Treasure legend. That was the words of the article writer. Either way, it's only an opinion.

Besides, if Button had said the above, I'm not sure how much stock I would put into it. He was a man who seemed to not know what he believed.:

"Lynchburg editor Charles W. Button was a pro-Unionist and anti-secessionist who despised Abraham Lincoln, a non-aristocrat amid Southern planters, a full-throated slavery supporter who owned no slaves."

Not exactly a single minded man, huh?


And there's this:

The Virginian would have "no sympathy with those who counsel separation," Button wrote.

So much for Mr. Button's opinions.
 

Old Silver said:
Much of genealogy information is wrong. I have actual documents as proof, not just something compiled by other researchers.
Click to expand...
On the subject of he said she said proof, do you possess the actual documents of proof?
What do they prove and how do they relate to the Beale Papers or the story of the Beale Party's perilous adventure?
 

Old Silver said:
Our Robert's mother was named Sarah Garner. His grandmother was Mary Hall (she was formerly married to a Hall).
Our Robert had three sister, and no brothers.
His sisters:
1. Susannah (married Adam Mitchell, probably brother of Sarah Mitchell).
2. Letitia (married George Curtis).
3. Leanna.

Our Robert's father, Thomas was 1/2 brother of Robert Morris, signer of the DOI. Robert's (DOI) mother died in England when he was small. His father, Robert SR. immagrated to Oxford, MD, where he was later joined by his son, Robert. Robert SR remarried (Mary Hall) and had 2 sons, one of which was Thomas, the father of our Robert Morriss.
Confused yet?
Click to expand...

i found 2 docs yesterday that has me wondering about our RM and the doi RM

Robert Morris to George Washington, August 17, 1782, Cipher
download.png


Robert Morris to George Washington, October 16, 1782, Cipher
download (1).png
 

Old Silver said:
Someone's opinion on what MAY HAVE been. Not proof. But I agree that it MAY HAVE been that.

Besides, that quote doesn't say Sherman wrote the Beale papers, as you earlier claimed.
Click to expand...
LOL! John William Sherman WAS his sub-editor!
 

Old Silver said:
"He ended his newspaper career with a bizarre interlude in which he sold the Daily Virginian to one of his sub-editors who had earlier wntten a dime novel that may have sparked the Beale Treasure legend about a hoard of gold buried in Bedford. Then, Button bought the paper back."

If you'll notice, the above quote is not the words of Button, but rather the person telling the story of Button. Button was not the one who said that one of his sub-editors had earlier written a dime novel that may have sparked the Beale Treasure legend. That was the words of the article writer. Either way, it's only an opinion.

Besides, if Button had said the above, I'm not sure how much stock I would put into it. He was a man who seemed to not know what he believed.:

"Lynchburg editor Charles W. Button was a pro-Unionist and anti-secessionist who despised Abraham Lincoln, a non-aristocrat amid Southern planters, a full-throated slavery supporter who owned no slaves."

Not exactly a single minded man, huh?


And there's this:

The Virginian would have "no sympathy with those who counsel separation," Button wrote.

So much for Mr. Button's opinions.
Click to expand...
Take yer issues up with Joe... who wrote the article; Charlie Button is DEAD...
 

Rebel - KGC said:
Take yer issues up with Joe... who wrote the article; Charlie Button is DEAD...
Click to expand...

I don't really have an issue with it.
If Joe believes that a story by Sherman was the inspiration for the Beale story, that's his business. He might be right, we don't know.
 

Rebel - KGC said:
AGAIN, take yer issues up with Joe, who wrote the article...
Click to expand...

No issues here, just stating the facts.
You posted about the article, that's why I'm pointing out to you that the saying you attributed to Mr. Button was actually a statement by someone else. And only an opinion at that.
Again, no issues here, just pointing out the facts.
 

Rebel - KGC said:
LOL! Dunno, YOU tell me...
Click to expand...

I did tell you. I was simply pointing out that the article you posted, purporting it to be the words of Mr. Button, were actually the words of someone else. That's all.
 

You must log in or register to reply here.

Beale's Brewery & BBQ coming to Bedford, VIRGINIA

⬅️ Previous Thread

Happy Holidays!

Next Thread ➡️

Top Member Reactions

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 2 (members: 0, guests: 2)

Latest Discussions

Back
Top