Thursday, 6th January 2011; Gibraltar Chronicle
ODYSSEY PRESS TO HAVE SPAIN’S CASE STRUCK OFF
Odyssey Marine Exploration, the US deep-ocean exploration company, has filed a Motion to Strike a brief filed by the United States government in support of Spain in the ‘Black Swan’ case.
The case is currently pending in the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals in the US, where Odyssey appealing a lower court’s decision to order the company to return the ‘Black Swan’ treasure to Spain.
If the US motion is not struck out, Odyssey has asked the court to direct the US government to amend its statement to accurately reflect its interest in the case.
The latest filing follows a number of revelations about the Black Swan case detailed in leaked diplomatic cables published by the whistleblower website Wikileaks last month.
Odyssey said the released cables suggest that the US State Department offered special assistance to Spanish officials in the ‘Black Swan’ case in exchange for assistance in acquiring, on behalf of a US citizen, a French painting confiscated by the Nazis during World War II and now on display in a museum in Madrid.
“We have brought to the Court’s attention the evidence suggesting that the involvement of the U.S. Executive Branch in the ‘Black Swan’ case goes beyond its interest in interpreting applicable laws,” said Melinda MacConnel, Odyssey vice president and general counsel.
“The US Government’s interest appears to have been related to a promise of support for Spain in exchange for assistance in obtaining this painting for a US citizen.”
“This calls into question whether there may have been any other offers of support in exchange for favours completely unrelated to this case.”
“Any interest in the case of the US beyond those stated in their filing should warrant striking the amicus brief or at the very least, require a full explanation of the motives behind their support of Spain.”
After reviewing the cables that were released, Odyssey chief executive Greg Stemm sent a letter on behalf of the company and its shareholders to US Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton requesting additional information and a review of the position taken by the US in the ‘Black Swan’ legal case.
Neither Odyssey nor Mr Stemm received a response to this request.
http://www.chronicle.gi/headlines_details.php?id=20826
ODYSSEY PRESS TO HAVE SPAIN’S CASE STRUCK OFF
Odyssey Marine Exploration, the US deep-ocean exploration company, has filed a Motion to Strike a brief filed by the United States government in support of Spain in the ‘Black Swan’ case.
The case is currently pending in the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals in the US, where Odyssey appealing a lower court’s decision to order the company to return the ‘Black Swan’ treasure to Spain.
If the US motion is not struck out, Odyssey has asked the court to direct the US government to amend its statement to accurately reflect its interest in the case.
The latest filing follows a number of revelations about the Black Swan case detailed in leaked diplomatic cables published by the whistleblower website Wikileaks last month.
Odyssey said the released cables suggest that the US State Department offered special assistance to Spanish officials in the ‘Black Swan’ case in exchange for assistance in acquiring, on behalf of a US citizen, a French painting confiscated by the Nazis during World War II and now on display in a museum in Madrid.
“We have brought to the Court’s attention the evidence suggesting that the involvement of the U.S. Executive Branch in the ‘Black Swan’ case goes beyond its interest in interpreting applicable laws,” said Melinda MacConnel, Odyssey vice president and general counsel.
“The US Government’s interest appears to have been related to a promise of support for Spain in exchange for assistance in obtaining this painting for a US citizen.”
“This calls into question whether there may have been any other offers of support in exchange for favours completely unrelated to this case.”
“Any interest in the case of the US beyond those stated in their filing should warrant striking the amicus brief or at the very least, require a full explanation of the motives behind their support of Spain.”
After reviewing the cables that were released, Odyssey chief executive Greg Stemm sent a letter on behalf of the company and its shareholders to US Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton requesting additional information and a review of the position taken by the US in the ‘Black Swan’ legal case.
Neither Odyssey nor Mr Stemm received a response to this request.
http://www.chronicle.gi/headlines_details.php?id=20826