Blindbowman
Bronze Member
- Joined
- Aug 15, 2007
- Messages
- 2,068
- Reaction score
- 1,005
- Golden Thread
- 0
- Primary Interest:
- All Treasure Hunting
- #121
Thread Owner
i wish i could come right out and tell you more .. but it would take away the surprize factor .. DR thorne never had a mine . he was givewn a pile of on the ground .. and i know where that locations and why they gave it to him there ..puzzle peice are funny things .they are much like the unknows that suround us all ..Oroblanco said:Blindbowman has been trying to build a case that ties several treasure legends in with the Lost Dutchman for five years now, can't say I am convinced so far. Just proving that one has found the Lost Dutchman gold mine alone would seem to be quite a hurdle (one does have to find it first) but to then make the leap to say it is Tayopa just baffles me. Why does it have to be Tayopa as well as the Lost Dutchman and lost Peralta mines as well? The Peraltas referred to were active in New Mexico, not AZ; the Peraltas active in AZ were working in the Black Canyon and Bradshaws area not the Superstitions. I can't seem to connect the dots so comfortably as some can.
It has been interesting at times but I would be impressed with one aspect being proven, let alone the theory that it is also the Tayopa complex, Peralta mines, Jesuits etc. Others have taken that "all rolled into one" approach before, and to be sure there are interesting parallels but the southwest is a far more complicated place with many lost mines and treasures, which are not related. One would almost have to think that all of the legends are really located in the Superstitions, with nothing anywhere else. If BB is saying that his Tayopa is a second one, it will still take a lot of evidence to prove it up.
Not to say that it is not possible that several different legends can not be directly associated with the Lost Dutchman - I suspect that the lost Doc Thorne mine is quite possibly the same, as is the lost Black Maverick mine. That one in particular had a detail which resonated, about the foot of the bull (or horse, depending on which version) went through a covering on top of the mine shaft; the covering was made up of logs, covered with earth and rocks etc very similar to what is commonly attributed to the Waltz story. Yet Blindbowman does not seem to address this possibility, or Dr Thorne. Just my opinion but I would think these two legends would be a much easier case to build than trying to link Tayopa with the LDM.
Looking forward to seeing you all,
Oroblanco
dose one peice of one part of the puzzle look like all the peice of the puzzle ,,NO and that peice of puzzle may look like it will fit any one of dozen place on the puzzle but it will only fit one place ,and you must ask your self where on the puzzle it belongs we can all see the outer flat peice are there .. its finding the right place for those hard to fit peices that well complete this puzzle ..
i leave tomorrow ,i am coming to finish what i started ..