gollum
Gold Member
- Jan 2, 2006
- 6,770
- 7,724
- Detector(s) used
- Minelab SD2200D (Modded)/ Whites GMT 24k / Fisher FX-3 / Fisher Gold Bug II / Fisher Gemini / Schiebel MIMID / Falcon MD-20
- Primary Interest:
- All Treasure Hunting
Finding Swanner's name on the wall with a 1961 date, if he himself even put it there, should not be surprising. Fiege and Berlette claimed to have discovered about 100 bars in an open cave at the base of Victorio Peak in 1958. In 1961, Swanner became a partner in a private business partnership with Fiege and Berlette. They were attempting to recover alleged gold bars that they claimed were hidden behind a cave-in they caused in their 1958 cave site to secure "thousands of more gold bars." When their feet were held to the fire, the group was unable to locate the alleged cave-in site. The Army later began searching for it.
The 100-bar Fiege and Berlette discovery is the subject of the polygraph test that you supplied "results" for on another thread. Most experts have serious doubts about polygraph results, but they are generally given about 50% reliability if administered properly. I note that the copy you provided is neither signed nor certified with document entry stamps. I will ignore these problems for the sake of your argument.
In my judgement, when Fiege and Berlette recovered the 100 bars in 1958, they were very likely Caballo bars previously hidden by Noss sometime prior to his death for the purpose of salting his scam later. This was a scheme to protect the location of his Caballo discovery, the true source of the gold. Swanner apparently wasn't present at the peak in 1958, but may well have conspired in a separate scam with Fiege and Berlette in 1961, basing their false claims of "thousands of gold bars" on Noss's earlier lies. Of course, since there were no more bars in the peak, the claimants were not able to find their hidden entrance. As can be seen by the aerial photos, the Army and others searched high and low for it too. Other than "affidavits", there is no evidence the gold was ever there. Whatever the 1961 group's strategy was for a personal payoff, it never came to fruition.
sdcfia,
Well, you are entirely entitled to your judgement, but both Fiege and Berlette passed a polygraph stating that they did not remove any of the bars they found. In fact, that was the express purpose for the polygraph test. Once they had convinced their commander they had actually found something, they were both charged with removing bars from VP. The polygraph test resulted in the charges not being officially filed against them. It was three years between the time they reported the find to their chain of command (1958), and when they were allowed back to find the cave (1961). In my opinion, the Military did the same thing to them they did to the Noss's. Sometime in that three year period, they went and removed all the gold bars, then caved it in. Which is why neither Fiege nor Berlette were able to find the entrance when they went back. I know me, and if I found a cave full of gold bars, there is no way in heII I would EVER forget where the entrance was.
As far as Doc salting VP, I agree that it is possible. Not as any kind of scam, but since he had been completely screwed over at VP, when he found the second cave in the Caballos (probably around Cleato(sic) Springs area), he took gold from there to VP so he could officially remove it without anyone knowing about the Caballos Cave. I also think he was killed before he ever shared full knowledge of the location of the second cave with anybody.
Mike