What's new
By:

Season 12

n2mini said:
As we all know, there is no way to prove there isn't or never was a treasure vault on the island.. The whole island has never been dug down to water or bedrock and never will be of course. So anything is still possible. However unlikely it might be.. For instance if Samuel Ball did find a treasure of gold coins on the island and he dug a hole in the basement of his house and buried "some" of it and never told anyone before he died, it could still be there and they are not allowed (I don't) think to dig at the site of his old house..
Click to expand...
Samuel Ball was paid both salary and spoils shares for his service in the British army.

That's where his income came from and not from a fictional treasure.
 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

Upgraded Night Vision Monocular Digital Infrared Monocular Telescope for 100% Darkness with 8X Zoom - Grab it through Amazon!
Everybody says that about his British Army money. From my understanding it was a 1 time payout at the end of the war. Do you really think they gave him and all the others enough money to live on nicely for the rest of their lives!! It might have helped him get started buying land and building a house on OI but that is it, and I highly doubt he got well off from farming cabbage there after.. Not sure how well off he was but enough that he had a Butler who he left his estate to once his last wife died, the butler got everything that was left.. We need to look into the butler and see how he faired there after..
 

To be honest I got involved with this argument / discussion a yr ago and got no where - Now I tune in every once in awhile to view / read the entertainment .
If people dont want to believe , power to them , If people do want to believe who the heck are we to tell them their wrong .
Jesus ! Some folks just want to argue about anything .....
 

treasureguy56 said:
To be honest I got involved with this argument / discussion a yr ago and got no where - Now I tune in every once in awhile to view / read the entertainment .
If people dont want to believe , power to them , If people do want to believe who the heck are we to tell them their wrong .
Jesus ! Some folks just want to argue about anything .....
Click to expand...
There's nothing to argue about with this topic. Who's ever been wrong...? Who's ever been right...? All we know is that after 200+ years and all the numerous efforts nobody knows if anything of value is still or was ever in the ground.

The only known fact is that nobody has seen or knows if anything of value was ever on O.I. And still the search continues for something that nobody knows anything about.

treasureguy56: "If people do want to believe who the heck are we to tell them their wrong." What could they possibly be wrong about...? What's to argue about...?
 

FreeBirdTim said:
Calling non-believers trolls should never be allowed here. You have your opinion and we have our opinions. Nothing wrong with debating the merits of the show and the possibilty that treasure is or isn't buried on Oak Island.

The reason I post here is to call out bogus treasure claims. We all work way too hard finding our valuable coins and relics to sit back and watch two clowns claiming to know where this massive treasure is every week, but never finding anything to substantiate those wild claims. I find more on a bad day detecting than these guys have found in 12 years of the show! They need to stop this nonsense until they actually find something.

Why keep airing a show about nothing? It worked for Seinfeld, but it doesn't work for treasure hunting shows. Put up or shut up, Laginas. You're starting to look like con artists collecting a fat paycheck every week by coming up with more and more outlandish tales every week. Have some self-respect and shut the show down until you find the good stuff...
Click to expand...
I have 4 gold claims plus work on public claims and every year people tell me I will never find gold there, its a waste of time. I ignore them and dig anyway, then I find gold and continue digging to find more gold. The "know it alls" don't know squat and the best part is they are not in my holes getting the gold I find in public prospecting areas :headbang:

The same is true for this show, as long as they keep digging they could find something. And with everything they found so far, roads, tunnels, precious metals in water samples, artifacts from all over the world, etc... is evidence to me that something there inspired a LOT of activity, manual labor and construction far beyond what is needed for a few families living on the island 100's of years ago.
 

I have 4 gold claims plus work on public claims and every year people tell me I will never find gold there, its a waste of time. I ignore them and dig anyway, then I find gold and continue digging to find more gold. The "know it alls" don't know squat and the best part is they are not in my holes getting the gold I find in public prospecting areas
Click to expand...

But did you look for gold for 12 years before you actually found some gold? I seriously doubt it. What they've found in 12 years on Oak Island is jack squat. I've been detecting for 12 years and I've found dozens of coins from the 1700's, Rev War era stirrup, flintlock plate, flintlock trigger guard, 1700's trade ax, a dozen colonial era shoe buckles, hundreds of 1700's and 1800's flat buttons and on and on. Their paltry finds are a joke compared to anyone who is a serious metal detectorist.
 

FreeBirdTim said:
But did you look for gold for 12 years before you actually found some gold? I seriously doubt it. What they've found in 12 years on Oak Island is jack squat. I've been detecting for 12 years and I've found dozens of coins from the 1700's, Rev War era stirrup, flintlock plate, flintlock trigger guard, 1700's trade ax, a dozen colonial era shoe buckles, hundreds of 1700's and 1800's flat buttons and on and on. Their paltry finds are a joke compared to anyone who is a serious metal detectorist.
Click to expand...
I've been detecting for years and never found anything of value but still go out. Whats you point, you give up easily where others dont?
 

My point is any decent metal detectorist has found way more than the Oak Island clowns have found. And, no, I'm stubborn and don't give up easily. That's why I recently found these two gold relics when most people were taking a winter break from detecting.

clean case.webp
10k gold medallion.webp
 

Grizz12 said:
I've been detecting for years and never found anything of value but still go out. Whats you point, you give up easily where others dont?
Click to expand...
That's what probably 99% of metal detectorists do. We all go out to "see" if we can find something of value. We all have a small amount of money invested and it's fun to just see what we might find. But we don't proclaim to be looking only for something of great value or we wouldn't go out. It's actually news when we do find something of value and a lot of us share it with other like minded folks.

And on your claims you'd never keep looking for gold for 12 years in the same spot or area if you continued to fail. If you have some success than naturally you continue to look. If you can actually see and hold what your looking for who cares what others think or say...? Your level of "success" is only gauged by you. Good job if your happy with it..!

But the brothers have repeated the same thing over and over and over and have not found a single thing in the same area for over 12 years. Nor have the folks before them shared any positive results. Finding "proof" of human activity on the island in no way leads one to believe something of value was buried. Why would it...? In fact nobody is surprised of this known fact (human activity).

Do you think the brothers will announce they quit on last episode or just fade away silently...?
 

As every episode and season follows the same script, on the last episode this season the laginas will be just on the precipice of uncovering the greatest treasure ever found in history BUT it will have to wait until next season. 😂
 

TruthbeTold said:
As every episode and season follows the same script, on the last episode this season the laginas will be just on the precipice of uncovering the greatest treasure ever found in history BUT it will have to wait until next season. 😂
Click to expand...
The next episode is it for season 12 or how much longer... anyone know?
 

Limitool said:
There's nothing to argue about with this topic. Who's ever been wrong...? Who's ever been right...? All we know is that after 200+ years and all the numerous efforts nobody knows if anything of value is still or was ever in the ground.

The only known fact is that nobody has seen or knows if anything of value was ever on O.I. And still the search continues for something that nobody knows anything about.

treasureguy56: "If people do want to believe who the heck are we to tell them their wrong." What could they possibly be wrong about...? What's to argue about...?
Click to expand...
So who really cares , if it doesnt effect you or your family who the heck cares - most things in our media or entertainment are based on falsity .
 

Curse of Oak Islamd Season 12, Episode 18 Recap

Episode followed long running script in show sequence.

Yet another silly theory.

More wood and other junk from previous diggers as well as island residents found.

More proof that there was never a treasure on the island other than the bilking of folks out of money to support the ongoing scam.
 

Huh...so funny the back and forth here. If this show generates such visceral back and forth here then it is absolutely a smashing success. It's obvious that everyone here has seen some of this series at the very least. And for so many threads and pages related to oak island can only mean that it has generated emotional responses from both the believers, and the non-believers. The Guage of success for a movie, series, or documentary is the emotional response that it generates !! If you cry, laugh, or your heart rate increases then the directors, and producers are delighted by these emotional reactions, and this usually equates to a successful project. So say what you will on this thread, and other oak Island threads, but keep in mind it's your own emotional responses that keep this whole narrative foward. So what I'm saying is that if you can't resist responding here then you have been captured as an audience 😉 I find it incredibly difficult to understand how the people who hate this show so much are absolutely inclined to carry on this back and forth. The people who love it are obviously as passionate about there beliefs as the non believers, so obviously this show is a smashing success Whether anybody wants to admit it !! This back and forth dialog is exactly what the producers wanted !! So let's see how many more pages of dialog this thread will generate? Carry on folks, but remember you, and me, and everyone who comments here are actually sustaining the buzz that surrounds the show !!
 

Blak bart said:
Huh...so funny the back and forth here. If this show generates such visceral back and forth here then it is absolutely a smashing success. It's obvious that everyone here has seen some of this series at the very least. And for so many threads and pages related to oak island can only mean that it has generated emotional responses from both the believers, and the non-believers. The Guage of success for a movie, series, or documentary is the emotional response that it generates !! If you cry, laugh, or your heart rate increases then the directors, and producers are delighted by these emotional reactions, and this usually equates to a successful project. So say what you will on this thread, and other oak Island threads, but keep in mind it's your own emotional responses that keep this whole narrative foward. So what I'm saying is that if you can't resist responding here then you have been captured as an audience 😉 I find it incredibly difficult to understand how the people who hate this show so much are absolutely inclined to carry on this back and forth. The people who love it are obviously as passionate about there beliefs as the non believers, so obviously this show is a smashing success Whether anybody wants to admit it !! This back and forth dialog is exactly what the producers wanted !! So let's see how many more pages of dialog this thread will generate? Carry on folks, but remember you, and me, and everyone who comments here are actually sustaining the buzz that surrounds the show !!
Click to expand...
Well said my friend.
 

The great thing about the episode recap videos I post is that they accurately detail what is going on in the show thus exposing the laginas’ scam.
 

Neglected to mention that the laginas are now saying that there are TWO treasure vaults stacked on top of each other.

The lies continue to grow in proportion to the show’s plummeting ratings,
 

You must log in or register to reply here.

Tree of life, Nolan’s Cross, & ancient cave petroglyphs…

⬅️ Previous Thread

Is Onslow Company a militia?

Next Thread ➡️

Top Member Reactions

Similar threads

Limitool
After 15th Episode of Season 12.... Still any believers...?
8 9 10
Replies
185
Views
5K
Limitool
Limitool
Sand Swinger
I think I saw a Minelab X-Terra Elite on The Curse of Oak Island
Replies
7
Views
818
Sand Swinger
Sand Swinger
SIZZLE ADLER
Knights Templar Cache of Biblical Artifacts Concealed by Stone Cipher
2 3 4
Replies
65
Views
4K
SSR
S

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 0, guests: 1)

Latest Discussions

Back
Top Bottom