Where I say "ten years" I mean "six years" (2004).
trinidad said:Curious. A lot of money, officials and stuff to survey the same area that six years ago surveyed RPM Nautical for a month and a half with the compromise of giving to the Junta de Andalucia the results of this survey. After so long time, no news about the RPM Nautical survey. And no news means no media news, academic news, archaeological news or any other news you can imagine.
Jeff K said:Don... According to Graham Moore's letter to Cornwallis the Mercedes carried 590,000 silver pesos for the merchants, and 221,000 for the king. For arguments sake lets assume this is an accurate account, and that Odyssey recovered exactly 500,000 silver coins. If I were the judge, here's how I would settle this. First, Odyssey gets 100% of the gold coins and jewelry, because they belonged to the merchants and passengers, not the king. There was a shipment of 811,000 silver coins in total, of which 73% belonged to the merchants and 27% belonged to the king. Therefore, Spain could have a claim on 27% of the 500,000 coins recovered, or 135,000 coins. I would then award Odyssey an 80% salvage fee, which would leave Spain with 27,000 coins. I use the 80% figure, because that's what is awarded to the salvors by Florida. This seems like a fair split to me, and in accordance with the Law of the Sea Convention.
P.S. Graham Moore was the commander of the British ships that engaged the four Spanish frigates.
diggerww said:There was no need to bring that up at this point in time.
The entire argument to date has been FSIA and positive identification that the vessel is the Mercedes.
The information will be made available if it is necessary, which given the rulings to date, wont likely be necessary.
Jeff K said:"EXCEPT..that after the war, the admiralty court settled all the claims and Britain paid off the merchants for their loss. This settlement is well documented, especially for the Alvears. Spain also settled with the merchants.
So, as in the case where an insurance company pays off, and then becomes the legal owner, would that be Britain or Spain?"
IT NEVER HAPPENED! SPAIN NEVER PAID ONE CENT TO THE MERCHANTS!
Don't you think if Spain had paid the merchants that James Goold would have submitted the documents to the court, but he did not submit one document showing Spain paid any of the merchants. Instead he tried to fool the court into thinking that Spain had done so. I see he fooled you, but I'm not surprised. Spain tried to get the Brits to pay the merchants, but they never did. Alvear was the only one to receive compensation from the Brits.
diggerww said:Why arent any of these 'papers' subject to peer review? The only place they are 'published' is on the Odyssey website...