Oroblanco
Gold Member
- Jan 21, 2005
- 7,841
- 9,867
- Detector(s) used
- Tesoro Lobo Supertraq, (95%) Garrett Scorpion (5%)
Roy,
Nice post but, as you know, I have never believed the story of Waltz's big ore shipments. First, Wells Fargo only shipped gold and silver bullion, coins and cash until the railroads came into Arizona. Beyond that, the U.S. Mints only took refined ore for conversion to coins. There was never a U.S. Mint in Sacramento, which is where the story says the "ore" was shipped. No one has ever been able to find the documents that a few people have sworn they saw.
It's now known that Wells Fargo records do exist for the "old west time period". On the other hand, they only started keeping records of gold shipments in Arizona after a certain date.
On the other hand, you could be right.
Take care,
Joe
Well my source for Wells Fargo having NO records of any kind for the 'old west' period was the same fellow you talked to. But on another point, while there is no US mint in Sacramento, this could very easily be a point of error that got into the story by garbling. Unless you insist that every single point must be taken absolutely literally, in which case then of course the story is false, because there was no mint in Sacramento. There were however smelters operating there, and that actually acted as agents for the US mint by buying gold and silver ore and processing it.
As to those "huge" shipments, who said they were huge? It could have been several smaller shipments, could it not? Hence the mention in that letter about "receipts" plural, not a single receipt for one huge shipment. In fact one witnessed sale of ore by Waltz which occurred in Tucson, was only one mule load, which he sold for $600. A fair sum of money for that place and time, but how much ore would be loaded on a single mule? How much ore do you suppose Waltz would have been packing out from the mine, on each visit? Tons? So really unless you want to take the stance that it was impossible for a miner in Arizona to have shipped ore to Sacramento in the 1860-1890 period via stage freight, and that all of the personal papers of the Petrasches have been found and examined, it is not 100% proven that Waltz made no shipments.
Hmm for that matter we do not know that the Petrasches actually had the receipts, just that they saw them, so these receipts (if they still exist) may be in some private collection, and not likely to be made public.
For the record, while these are indeed treasure LEGENDS, nearly all legends have a basis in truth. The truth does not always match the legend on every single point, due to numerous causes, from garbling in the re-telling, to deliberate falsehoods being added to the original story and of course the mixing of different un-related legends. You are certainly free and welcome to believe anything you wish or disbelieve anything you wish, and I was one of those people that certainly believed I had seen a record of Waltz shipping ore but I could have been mistaken by having seen it described in Terry's atlas. On the other hand, how would you feel if someone were to announce tomorrow, that he or she owns the shipping receipts and displays them for the public? Would you announce that you could have been mistaken in making a sweeping statement?
Looking forward to seeing you, HOPE that things will work out so that we can spend a little time with you. I will write you an EM some time soon, try to catch up on all the latest news.