What's new
By:

WARD BASED HIS STORY ON ORIGINAL "THE BEALE PAPERS" PUBLISHED 1850

Status
Not open for further replies.
...and I bet that you and/or Laf can not produce one single piece of evidence that anything in the Beale story text ever happened.
 

Cryptography said:
You are way out there on this one. What a JOKE!!!!!!!!!
Click to expand...
You may want to inform Legrand about this, who is basing his theory on E F Beale's 1850 Beale Papers.
PS, I do find your and Laf's lack of knowledge on this subject quite amusing, that is the real joke here.
PSS, We are all laughing with you!
 

Last edited:
ECS said:
This is a prime example of making random facts fit ones theory.
Do you have any evidence to show that Carlos de Grandpre provided maps to his son in law, Thomas Beale, of New Orleans, or is it just fanciful speculation on your part to fit your theory?
An "expedition" the size mentioned in the Beale Papers, would have been noticed and talked about, either by those who provisioned the group, or by those who noticed Beale was not around to run his plantation, or hotel.
You realize, that Celeste Boucher de Grandpre Beale kept a diary- guess what is obvious by its omission.
Click to expand...

Manny fictitious items seem to make up this whole faerie tale you have told here .
 

Gen. Edward F. Beale's G, G, G, Great Grand Father was Thomas Beale 111 Who was Captain Thomas J Beale Sr's G, Great Grand Father .

Small world eh ?
 

Jean Laf said:
Gen. Edward F. Beale His Diary


Edward Fitzgerald Beale diary and journal, 1853-1859. (Archival material, 1853) [WorldCat.org]



Diary, July 1-16, 1853, while pausing in Colorado on overland journey to California.

Journal, Oct. 28, 1858-July 29, 1859, while engaged in second season's work on the Pacific Wagon Road along the 35th Parallel, from Fort Smith to the Colorado River and back to Albuquerque.
Click to expand...
Beale Wagon Road NOW known as Rt. 66, I think... WESTWARD HO!
 

Jean Laf said:
Gen. Edward F. Beale's G, G, G, Great Grand Father was Thomas Beale 111 Who was Captain Thomas J Beale Sr's G, Great Grand Father .

Small world eh ?
Click to expand...

That is quite esthetic!
 

Jean Laf said:
Gen. Edward F. Beale's G, G, G, Great Grand Father was Thomas Beale 111 Who was Captain Thomas J Beale Sr's G, Great Grand Father .

Small world eh ?
Click to expand...
A "small world" with your slip shod method of research with the only goal of making any Beale fit your theory.
The real genealogy of Edward Fitzgerald Beale:
http://www.geni.com/people/Gen-Edward-F-Beale/6000000006598437107
Make note that his father was George Dixon Beale, an 1812 Naval war hero, and his grandfather was GEORGE BEALE III.
 

Last edited:
Jean Laf said:
OOP's, your proof is a bad link like all the others . :laughing7:
Click to expand...

John Beale's Brother was Captain Thomas J Beale's Grand Father Taverner Beale Sr who's son was Col Taverner Beale Jr who's son was Captain Thomas J Beale .
john beale.webpgeorge beale sr.webpgeorge beale iii.webp


See for yourself on the site you chose .

http://www.geni.com/people/John-Beale/6000000002339176482
 

Last edited:
Jean Laf said:
OOP's, your proof is a bad link like all the others . :laughing7:
Click to expand...
Try again, I corrected the error, and you discover that E F Beale is not part of the Chestnut Hill Beale family
 

Last edited:
 

 

And all of this simply establishes that there is no "J" in your suspect's name and that he wasn't Captain Thomas J. Beall. Point is, all of this has been dished out and debated many times over the years with nothing conclusive ever coming of it. No doubt it won't be the last time either. Now toss in all of the usual "time of death" debating that still continues today and everyone is right back to square one, just as always. :thumbsup:

It might also be worth mentioning that a lot of these genealogical sources/results aren't bulletproof.
 

Last edited:
(It might also be worth mentioning that a lot of these genealogical sources/results aren't bulletproof. )

Yep, that is true . Bad info is just Bad info and then there is the people that just make stuff up, like fake diaries .
 

bigscoop said:
And all of this simply establishes that there is no "J" in your suspect's name and that he wasn't Captain Thomas J. Beall. Point is, all of this has been dished out and debated many times over the years with nothing conclusive ever coming of it. No doubt it won't be the last time either. Now toss in all of the usual "time of death" debating that still continues today and everyone is right back to square one, just as always. :thumbsup:

It might also be worth mentioning that a lot of these genealogical sources/results aren't bulletproof.
Click to expand...

All of this information has been around a long time and has been corrected over time most from ancestry.com.
 

Jean Laf said:
... Bad info is just Bad info and then there is the people that just make stuff up, like fake diaries .
Click to expand...
Yes, just like the 1885 Beale Papers.
Instead of searching genealogy sites about Beale, we all know this information, find solid documentation confirming the buffalo hunt expedition, or that Thomas Beale actually knew Robert Morriss.
That evidence is critical to proving that anything in the job pamphlet is real.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Wheres The Beef?

⬅️ Previous Thread

Morriss, Norvell, etc

Next Thread ➡️

Top Member Reactions

Similar threads

Ironwill
My Beale Story and Analysis of Claims and Assertions.
Replies
19
Views
7K
Rebel - KGC
R
Old Bookaroo
The Myth of Padre La Rue
Replies
5
Views
1K
russau
R
E
IN SEARCH OF THE AUTHENTIC ORIGIN OF THE BEALE TREASURE STORY
8 9 10
Replies
182
Views
21K
Rebel - KGC
R

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 0, guests: 1)
Metal Detecting Stuff

Latest Discussions

Back
Top Bottom