WARD BASED HIS STORY ON ORIGINAL "THE BEALE PAPERS" PUBLISHED 1850

[ECS]

Crypto, have you ever presented any facts on the subject?
Is your petty player role on this stage is to play Laf's amen corner chorus, to lay praise upon him while ineffectually discrediting the opposition?
Instead of your fruitless quips, try presenting a researched rebuttal to my posts.
You can start by proving the buffalo hunt mentioned in the 1885 Beale Papers that instrumental in the gold discovery creating the basis of the tale, ACTUALLY HAPPENED.

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

Minelab PRO-FIND 35 Waterproof Pinpointer Metal Detector for Experts with Tone ID & Adjustable Sensitivity - Grab it through Amazon!

[TN_Guest1523]

Crypto, have you ever presented any facts on the subject?
Is your petty player role on this stage is to play Laf's amen corner chorus, to lay praise upon him while ineffectually discrediting the opposition?
Instead of your fruitless quips, try presenting a researched rebuttal to my posts.
You can start by proving the buffalo hunt mentioned in the 1885 Beale Papers that instrumental in the gold discovery creating the basis of the tale, ACTUALLY HAPPENED.

Actually, he has given me a lot of info, what have you came up with except for just telling people they are wrong ?

 

[ECS]

It seems that you haven't read many of my posts.

 

[Cryptography]

It seems that you haven't read many of my posts.

I have, and you do not give anything helpful to someone working on the Papers at all. No proof of what you say, it does get hard to show proof when you make things up all the time ( Celeste Diary ).

 

[ECS]

You seem to forget, Crypto, I hold the belief that the 1885 Beale Papers is an adventure/treasure dime novel with ciphers added s a parlor entertainment.
As for making things up- Reine Lister and limericks.
Now bring forth evidence of the Beale buffalo hunt.
Can't do it, can you?
You and Laf avoid this very basic question because it is the very foundation of the story, and if it never happened, all claims of solved ciphers become futile.

 

[TN_Guest1523]

You seem to forget, Crypto, I hold the belief that the 1885 Beale Papers is an adventure/treasure dime novel with ciphers added s a parlor entertainment.
As for making things up- Reine Lister and limericks.
Now bring forth evidence of the Beale buffalo hunt.
Can't do it, can you?
You and Laf avoid this very basic question because it is the very foundation of the story, and if it never happened, all claims of solved ciphers become futile.

Crypto, I do not think it will help him . As there were no buffalo hunts that happened without them getting a license from ECS .

 

[ECS]

Crypto, I do not think it will help him . As there were no buffalo hunts that happened without them getting a license from ECS .

Making amusing statements is just another way to avoid the question:"Can you prove the buffalo hunt ever happened, or prove that anything in the 1885 Beale Papers ever happened?
A very simple yes or no will suffice.

 

[TN_Guest1523]

Making amusing statements is just another way to avoid the question:"Can you prove the buffalo hunt ever happened, or prove that anything in the 1885 Beale Papers ever happened?
A very simple yes or no will suffice.

You have me curious now, I will look into that when I have a chance, Thanks

 

[ECS]

... No proof of what you say, it does get hard to show proof when you make things up all the time ( Celeste Diary ).

No proof of what you say.
Neither you or Laf can prove that the Beale buffalo hunt ever happened just as neither of you can disprove the existence of a certain diary.

 

[TN_Guest1523]

No proof of what you say.
Neither you or Laf can prove that the Beale buffalo hunt ever happened just as neither of you can disprove the existence of a certain diary.

 

[TN_Guest1523]

No proof of what you say.
Neither you or Laf can prove that the Beale buffalo hunt ever happened just as neither of you can disprove the existence of a certain diary.

You have said you have this documentation and than you said IF there was documentation .

So what is it, do you have this documentation or are you just saying IF THERE WAS DOCUMENTATION ?

You have not made it clear . And please speak in English so our folks in the US can understand .

 

[Cryptography]

You have said you have this documentation and than you said IF there was documentation .

So what is it, do you have this documentation or are you just saying IF THERE WAS DOCUMENTATION ?

You have not made it clear . And please speak in English so our folks in the US can understand .

He will not answer this question, for his pants are on fire.

 

[ECS]

You have said you have this documentation and than you said IF there was documentation .

So what is it, do you have this documentation or are you just saying IF THERE WAS DOCUMENTATION ?

You have not made it clear . And please speak in English so our folks in the US can understand .

I have presented a chain of evidence that leads to support of the dime novel parlor entertainment ciphers theory.
The exists NO OUTSIDE DOCUMENTATION that can collaborate,confirm, or prove that anything written in the 1885 Beale Papers ever occurred .
One can not document a work of fiction, but one can document influences that inspired that work.

 

[TN_Guest1523]

He will not answer this question, for his pants are on fire.

I see, you are right crypto .

 

[ECS]

As usual, neither one of you are right.
"Same old story, same old song and dance, my friend"

 

[TN_Guest1523]

As usual, neither one of you are right.
"Same old story, same old song and dance, my friend"

You have said you have this documentation and than you said IF there was documentation .

So what is it, do you have this documentation or are you just saying IF THERE WAS DOCUMENTATION ?

You have not made it clear . And please speak in English so our folks in the US can understand .

 

[ECS]

What are you talking about, Laf? It seems you and your sidekick are getting very desperate because you can not prove the Beale expedition buffalo hunt ever happened.
No hunt, no gold, no treasure vault- just a work of fiction based on several sources, rendering the ciphers just an parlor entertaining amusement.

 

[TN_Guest1523]

What are you talking about, Laf? It seems you and your sidekick are getting very desperate because you can not prove the Beale expedition buffalo hunt ever happened.
No hunt, no gold, no treasure vault- just a work of fiction based on several sources, rendering the ciphers just an parlor entertaining amusement.

The Celeste Beale Diary
You have said you have this documentation and than you said IF there was documentation .

So what is it, do you have this documentation or are you just saying IF THERE WAS DOCUMENTATION ?

You have not made it clear . And please speak in English so our folks in the US can understand .

 

[ECS]

Neither you or Laf can prove that the Beale buffalo hunt ever happened just as neither of you can disprove the existence of a certain diary.

This is the statement that I posted.
The word "documentation" is not mentioned.
I am ECS, and I approve this message.

 

[TN_Guest1523]

The Celeste Beale Diary
You have said you have this documentation and than you said IF there was documentation .

So what is it, do you have this documentation or are you just saying IF THERE WAS DOCUMENTATION ?

You have not made it clear . And please speak in English so our folks in the US can understand .