CatW,
I am not guilty in the lest of the same thing you did. You made a judgement of them based on nothing but your understanding of the story. I made absolutely ZERO judgements regarding Tumlinson. I said that I was just willing to give them the benefit of the doubt because in the 46 years since the existence of the Stone Maps has been public knowledge, not one person has said Travis Tumlinson was less than honest, and ZERO proof has been shown to that effect.
I have said this many times. I look at people's actions, not what they say. I have also said that I usually go by this: "Based on the best information we have, what is the MOST LIKELY?" Lets examine this through that spectrum; "BASED ON THE BEST INFORMATION WE HAVE, WHAT IS THE MOST LIKELY?"
Based on your THEORY which is drawn from nothing but your imagination Tumlinson was not honest.
OR
Based on several witnesses testimonies that personally knew the Tumlinsons, they were telling the truth.
I think I'll have to pass on your theory.
And the only defense of the discovery story is because you corresponded with two people that knew them. Good enough for you. Fine. Not anywhere close to good enough for me. So be it, eh?
You couldn't be farther fromthe truth. But then again, maybe my sense of smell is a bit more developed than yours. To argue the point I just quoted only shows an amazing lack of knowledge of the subject. Once again, I think Dr Freud says that it shows more about you than the subject you speak of.
All in all, the best thing I can recommend for you to do is to learn more about the subject of the Stone Maps. Read about the people that possessed them. Don't read the popular tripe. I have yet to read a single story that had all the facts straight. It's taken me several years of personal interviews, correspondence, phone calls, museum visits, FOIA Requests, newspaper archives, SEC and Court Records to arrive at my personal opinion.
Maybe you should read my posts a little closer. I said "we" (as in the public record) have interviews of several people that knew the Tumlinsons. Later, I stated that "I" have personally corresponded with two people that knew the Tumlinsons quite well. Only a basic understanding of English is necessary to tell the difference.
Best-Mike