Sorry I'm late to the discussion. I have questions & theories...
1) Dowry issues: In archival & primary source documentation I can find no evidence there was any formal "Queen's Dowry" other than possibly 100,000 doppie (Italian gold coins/ducats) in the form of jewelry. This would be part of the August 1714 marriage contract where the
queen was the giver, not the recipient (dowries of the era & region were always provided
by the bride's family). I can not find independent verification of this 100k doppie, but maybe someone else can?
2) Consummation issues: There is a possible royal intrigue that may have started the
rumor of the withholding of consummation, but it is definitely
not what actually happened. The king & queen absolutely consummated on December 24, 1714, as the queen mistakenly thought she was pregnant as early as January 1715 (& of course she did become pregnant sometime before the flota ever left Havana as she gave birth in January 16). The lore probably came about from Cardinal Alberoni's elaborate machinations to oust the evil Princess Orsins from the Spanish Court. Or just a big fish story.
3) Echeverz's sons: According to Basque documentation Echeverz's son Fermin (who survived & helped salvage for 2 months) was on a Tierra Firme ship named
Nuestra Señora del Carmen, which of course due to duplicate naming could have been the mainland fleet's capitana (aka
Carmen) where most survived or the 2nd patache (aka
Popa) where everyone survived. (Note: Fermin could not have been on the fragatilla aka
Ciervo because there were no survivors.) The eldest son Pedro died on
Rosario and other son Manuel died on
Concepcion. There is some confusion amongst historians about Echeverz's son Miguel, which seems attributable to the fact that so many ships & captains shared that name. By all accounts in my research, Miguel was safe at home in Panama during the disaster.
If Fermin was indeed on
Popa, this might help explain the discrepency constantly brought up about Echeverz's letters from the
Popa's wreckage while calling it his own real. There are so many sites attributed to
Popa's wreck (from Cape Canaveral down to Ft. Pierce) in all the interpretations that there's no way to be sure, but the theory that
Popa wrecked somewhere between Pedro's
Rosario & Echeverz's
Carmen makes the most sense - it was so close that Echeverz could easily run things in the southern wrecks from the
Popa's decks/cabins (washed ashore intact) & still consider it his real. And it would be very much worth his while to immediately go there first thing since his surviving son wrecked there.
4) Wreck positions: Based on all this info, I put together the following Google Earth map (showing all but
San Miguel up by Jacksonville) - I'd love feedback:
View attachment 924207
(just click on image to open in its own window for larger scale)
Because I plan to dramatize the story this year, I hope some of you can offer insights. I'd like it to be as accurate as possible.