A quick review of those who knew the truth behind the story in the Beale Papers.
James Beverly Ward-copyright agent and publisher
Harriet Buford Otey Ward- his wife
John William Sherman-Ward's cousin who printed the Beale Papers job shop pamphlet
Max Guggenheimer- businessman and friend of Ward who is mentioned in the Beale Papers
Charles W Button- Owner of print shop and LYNCHBURG VIRGINIAN where Sherman worked and advertised the Beale Papers.
F C Hutter-Ward cousin who some have claimed either wrote the Beale story, or created the some of the ciphers before dying.
All these people existed and can be researched, and that can not be said of the Thomas J Beale of the story, which no one has ever been able to prove existed, which has given rise to all the alternative stories behind the Beale story, like the Thomas Read version, that have been presented.
Either the Beale story as presented in the Beale Papers is true, or it is a work of fiction.
When one presents an alterative behind the Beale story theory, that is an admission that the presented Beale narrative story in the 1885 Beale Papers is a work of fiction.