What Have We Really Learned In Recent Weeks?

[ECS]

It's just a bottomless pit of creative thinking and wild speculation......to this very day still no provenance, not even from any of those who claim accurate remedy and solve and solution.
This should speak volumes to anyone who might be considering the true nature of the tale and those existing claims.

Since Pauline Innis's book and magazine articles appeared, others have joined into creating an endless parade of gathering random unrelated information and force fitting them into assumptions and speculations that they pass on as "fact".
Once the feared words "provenance", "evidence", "documentation", "verification" are mentioned the facts are never presented and the one making that request is vehemently attacked for asking for such an "outlandish" thing.
WHY?
What I believe is one takes the time to present information as "fact" one should be able to provide proof by employing one of those feared words, otherwise it is just more of that endless unfounded assumption and speculation that falls apart under scrutiny.

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

A Handbook of Civil War Bullets and Cartridges - Grab it through Amazon!

[franklin]

Sorry but if that is what you are looking for no one in his right mind is going to give it to you on an open forum. If there are any facts the finder of those facts is going to keep it to himself until this mystery is solved one way or the other. Keep asking for provenance all you want but like I told you before when a researcher gets that PROVENANCE your game is over. No more to post about good day.

 

[ECS]

If the game that is worth the candle is over once one posts PROVENANCE for claims made on an open forum, then WHY post the information at all on an open forum?

 

[Rebel - KGC]

LOL! Because we CAN!

 

[ECS]

... If there are any facts the finder of those facts is going to keep it to himself until this mystery is solved one way or the other.
Keep asking for provenance all you want but like I told you before when a researcher gets that PROVENANCE your game is over...

After 132 years since the Beale Papers publication, No facts, evidence, or proof has ever been brought forth that can confirm the events that make up the Beale perilous adventure treasure tale, or if Thomas J Beale was an actual person, which by the merits of that lack of verifiable facts, provides a tacit PROVENANCE that the Beale Papers job print pamphlet is a work of fiction created by this unnamed unknown author.

 

[ECS]

I wish someone would find some type of true provenance to any part of it, put an end to all of this fabrication and creative solution outbreak.

The heart of the matter is NO TRUE PROVENANCE exists due to that fact that the BEALE PAPERS was and always will be, a period adventure treasure dime novel with play along ciphers written for the purpose to be exclusively sold in a limited local market.
If it wasn't for George Hart and Pauline Innis reviving this tale in the 1960's, the BEALE PAPERS and its story would have faded as obscure ephemera, as it had until their involvement.