deducer
Bronze Member
- Jan 7, 2014
- 2,286
- 4,394
- Primary Interest:
- Other
As I recall, there were 27 mission sites in Arizona. Only 3 of them had padres and became missions. The other 24 had a church, a house for the padre, and a storehouse full of grain, fulfilling the requirements to become a mission. They were called 'visitas' until a padre was assigned to them. And these indian rancharias remained visitas for decades waiting for their padre that never came. The only way 1 man (Father Kino) could cause all of that heavy work to be completed is if the indians wanted to do it. Seems to me the indians wanted to be converted.
In my opinion the biggest evil in New Spain was the encomienda system. That's what enslaved the native people. Jesuits didn't own encomiendas. They were opposed to the system. It was the rich colonists, political figures and military officers. They're the ones that owned encomiendas and stood to profit the most by preserving the system. I believe they started many vicious rumors about the Jesuits in an attempt to curtail their power.
If you're looking for evil Jesuits, look at the top, not the bottom were Father Kino came from. The bottom is where the Jesuit saints come from.
I will have to differ with you on both points.
Here are passages from The Letters of the Swiss Jesuit Missionary Philipp Segesser (1689-1762) where Segesser goes on a rant and slips up about how the missionaries actually interact with the Indians in an attempt to get them to come to mass:
And also what he and the other German missionaries really think of the Indians:
supported by a passage from another book, Early History of the Southwest through the Eyes of German-Speaking Jesuit Missionaries: A Transcultural Experience in the Eighteenth Century:
Was Kino any different? Who knows? I think he really tried to do what he thought was right, from an Eurocentric point of view. Was he oblivious to the fact that the Spanish Government used the Catholic Church as an instrument, a rationale for conquest and exploitation? Who knows.
On the second point- I think that it's actually the other way around- the Jesuits had an iron grip and monopoly on the trade system to the far frontier. Their system was by far the most efficient and industrious and that's where their real power lay.
From Conflicts in Colonial Sonora:
Again, my aim is not to smear or cast anyone or any institution in a bad light, but I will not shy away from calling a spade, a spade. I call it as I see it. I am a stickler for accuracy and honesty.
Last edited: