My Finds Since Starting Detecting in November, and a poll question...

What Machine do you think has produced the most keeper finds for me in my soil conditions?

  • My DFX (Used for 5 Months)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • My Minelab SE (Used for 5 Months)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I am going to Vote for Whites anyway, regardless of the fact presented.

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    0
Stormtrooper154 said:
KirkPA said:
That is pretty cheap! You took the SE to virign sites. Come on, dude, uhhhh, let me take a cheap Radio Shack datector to my virgin sites, then compare it to my Pro XL finds. The Radio Shack is BETTER! That is funny!

Your DFX could compete just as much! Don't give me that load of cheese and crackas. >:( :D

Why do you Indian Heads in those protective things? They are bronze, not wilver. Heck, I don't even protect my wilver. If I found a Capped, I would want to feel it in my hand. :D

3 coins in the picture came from that "Virgin Site" LOL

Just like I presented Mr. Snuffy's Colonial coppa find to you and you didn't believe him, I ain't believing you only found 3 on voygin sites. You are just out to start a war. Dudes, you thought I was bad, I think Storm has surpassed my "so-called" belittling.
 

KirkPA said:
Once again Storm dude, you have started a thread to cause havoc. Do you always need to troll? >:(

Actually I started this thread to see if the facts of my finds could get a fair vote from you "Whites Brand" guys. Like I said, I already have my answer. Kirk, if you posted the same thread as I have...I would give you a honest vote, not a Brand Loyalty Vote. I have no loyalty to one machine or another...I just use what works and the fact that people have voted for the whites DFX when the evidence is overwhelming for the other machine just proves you will never get a honest answer here on T-net.

Just my opinion, sorry if you don't agree, but I think I have proved it!
 

KirkPA said:
Once again Storm dude, you have started a thread to cause havoc. Do you always need to troll? >:(

I appreciate the post and the information. I have owned Garrett's for the last 15 years and have found about 18,000 coins in that time frame detecting off and on in that time. I now have the 2500 GTI and love it, but in the last few months of being on tnet I am becoming more open minded. I have been loyal to Garrett to a fault, but have been wanting to try an SE and at least compare it. I can't afford both at the moment and don't want to be without my Garrett, but I think in the next month I will be able to afford both. For the times when I am out clad stacking locally I know I can't beat the Garrett with the GTI and the pinpointing capabilities. A true hunter would never have just one type of gun, so why limit yourself to 1 detector brand? Has anyone been duck hunting with a 30-06? Thanks for the posts, I for one like to see the posts comparing brands. Besides, can't we all just get along ;)...Ryan
 

KirkPA said:
Stormtrooper154 said:
KirkPA said:
That is pretty cheap! You took the SE to virign sites. Come on, dude, uhhhh, let me take a cheap Radio Shack datector to my virgin sites, then compare it to my Pro XL finds. The Radio Shack is BETTER! That is funny!

Your DFX could compete just as much! Don't give me that load of cheese and crackas. >:( :D

Why do you Indian Heads in those protective things? They are bronze, not wilver. Heck, I don't even protect my wilver. If I found a Capped, I would want to feel it in my hand. :D

3 coins in the picture came from that "Virgin Site" LOL

Just like I presented Mr. Snuffy's Colonial coppa find to you and you didn't believe him, I ain't believing you only found 3 on voygin sites. You are just out to start a war. Dudes, you thought I was bad, I think Storm has surpassed my "so-called" belittling.

Take a look at the pictures Kurt....You see the little 2x2's that have Lee's Place written on them...There are 3 of them!
 

Stormtrooper154 said:
KirkPA said:
Once again Storm dude, you have started a thread to cause havoc. Do you always need to troll? >:(

Actually I started this thread to see if the facts of my finds could get a fair vote from you "Whites Brand" guys. Like I said, I already have my answer. Kirk, if you posted the same thread as I have...I would give you a honest vote, not a Brand Loyalty Vote. I have no loyalty to one machine or another...I just use what works and the fact that people have voted for the whites DFX when the evidence is overwhelming for the other machine just proves you will never get a honest answer here on T-net.

Just my opinion, sorry if you don't agree, but I think I have proved it!

Storm - the only thing you've proven is that people who've watch you spar with Kirk know what to say to get under your skin and get a rise out of you - THAT'S what you proven.

I think you've done tremendous research and have really learned how to use your detector (I couldn't care less what brand it is). Get back out there and find some more - stop wasting time arguing :)
 

Stormtrooper154 said:
KirkPA said:
Stormtrooper154 said:
KirkPA said:
That is pretty cheap! You took the SE to virign sites. Come on, dude, uhhhh, let me take a cheap Radio Shack datector to my virgin sites, then compare it to my Pro XL finds. The Radio Shack is BETTER! That is funny!

Your DFX could compete just as much! Don't give me that load of cheese and crackas. >:( :D

Why do you Indian Heads in those protective things? They are bronze, not wilver. Heck, I don't even protect my wilver. If I found a Capped, I would want to feel it in my hand. :D

3 coins in the picture came from that "Virgin Site" LOL

Just like I presented Mr. Snuffy's Colonial coppa find to you and you didn't believe him, I ain't believing you only found 3 on voygin sites. You are just out to start a war. Dudes, you thought I was bad, I think Storm has surpassed my "so-called" belittling.

Take a look at the pictures Kurt....You see the little 2x2's that have Lee's Place written on them...There are 3 of them!

Ethan, you want a brouhaha to begin! You are a zoyboy!
 

Hey Storm,

Did you spend an equal amount of time with each detector?

Did each detector go to the same sites and hit the same signals?

I own 2 minelabs, but I don't think this post will accomplish anything, except make people defensive.

Nice finds...
 

Cubfan64 said:
Stormtrooper154 said:
KirkPA said:
Once again Storm dude, you have started a thread to cause havoc. Do you always need to troll? >:(

Actually I started this thread to see if the facts of my finds could get a fair vote from you "Whites Brand" guys. Like I said, I already have my answer. Kirk, if you posted the same thread as I have...I would give you a honest vote, not a Brand Loyalty Vote. I have no loyalty to one machine or another...I just use what works and the fact that people have voted for the whites DFX when the evidence is overwhelming for the other machine just proves you will never get a honest answer here on T-net.

Just my opinion, sorry if you don't agree, but I think I have proved it!

Storm - the only thing you've proven is that people who've watch you spar with Kirk know what to say to get under your skin and get a rise out of you - THAT'S what you proven.

I think you've done tremendous research and have really learned how to use your detector (I couldn't care less what brand it is). Get back out there and find some more - stop wasting time arguing :)

Now, do you see why I like to get at him? It is entertainment to see him :'( over not being able to find a Colonial coppa.
 

Hey Storm, I think you'd get alot of honest answers from people on TNet, but also brand loyal people as well and from both sides. Personally I enjoyed the pics and would have wished you said if you had "tweaked" the DFX to see how it did, as well as the Minelab. I own two Minelabs now and have sold two others(why have four??) and I play with the settings somewhat, more a couple years ago. I don't think you knocked the DFX, but if you just used the preset settings then I believe you would not have gotten most of those coins that you recovered with the Minelab. I think its easier with the Minelab(learning curve) than the DFX (and I have owned both) and you do get deeper targets with fewer adjustments with the Minelab, but once tweaked the DFX is a bear too! Still like the post and the pics!
 

That's a lot of great finds but I think I will need another day to think about the poll question, tough choice ;D

Keep the goodies coming Storm!

Smiles!
BDoo
 

I would say by info given that you have had better luck with the minelab, But is it better?? I couldn't say. I would use the best detector you could afford and leave it at that .
I have 2 fishing poles and they are exactly alike but one has caught more fish?? Is it better??
 

Cubfan64 said:
Stormtrooper154 said:
KirkPA said:
Once again Storm dude, you have started a thread to cause havoc. Do you always need to troll? >:(

Actually I started this thread to see if the facts of my finds could get a fair vote from you "Whites Brand" guys. Like I said, I already have my answer. Kirk, if you posted the same thread as I have...I would give you a honest vote, not a Brand Loyalty Vote. I have no loyalty to one machine or another...I just use what works and the fact that people have voted for the whites DFX when the evidence is overwhelming for the other machine just proves you will never get a honest answer here on T-net.

Just my opinion, sorry if you don't agree, but I think I have proved it!

Storm - the only thing you've proven is that people who've watch you spar with Kirk know what to say to get under your skin and get a rise out of you - THAT'S what you proven.

I think you've done tremendous research and have really learned how to use your detector (I couldn't care less what brand it is). Get back out there and find some more - stop wasting time arguing :)

Kurk was not the reason for this experiment. But you are right, he does get under my and others skin. I just cant believe there are so many Brand Loyal Detectorist that will try to make an argument even with the facts presented in front of them.
 

Jack(IN) said:
Hey Storm, I think you'd get alot of honest answers from people on TNet, but also brand loyal people as well and from both sides. Personally I enjoyed the pics and would have wished you said if you had "tweaked" the DFX to see how it did, as well as the Minelab. I own two Minelabs now and have sold two others(why have four??) and I play with the settings somewhat, more a couple years ago. I don't think you knocked the DFX, but if you just used the preset settings then I believe you would not have gotten most of those coins that you recovered with the Minelab. I think its easier with the Minelab(learning curve) than the DFX (and I have owned both) and you do get deeper targets with fewer adjustments with the Minelab, but once tweaked the DFX is a bear too! Still like the post and the pics!

Amen, Brotha!
 

Minelab is one of the few brands of detectors that I have not owned mainly because of the price but it looks like a winner to me. They have always been known to dig deep but you also have to dig deep in your pocket but most brands higher end machines are that way. Great finds and congrats.
 

Stormtrooper154 said:
Cubfan64 said:
Stormtrooper154 said:
KirkPA said:
Once again Storm dude, you have started a thread to cause havoc. Do you always need to troll? >:(

Actually I started this thread to see if the facts of my finds could get a fair vote from you "Whites Brand" guys. Like I said, I already have my answer. Kirk, if you posted the same thread as I have...I would give you a honest vote, not a Brand Loyalty Vote. I have no loyalty to one machine or another...I just use what works and the fact that people have voted for the whites DFX when the evidence is overwhelming for the other machine just proves you will never get a honest answer here on T-net.

Just my opinion, sorry if you don't agree, but I think I have proved it!

Storm - the only thing you've proven is that people who've watch you spar with Kirk know what to say to get under your skin and get a rise out of you - THAT'S what you proven.

I think you've done tremendous research and have really learned how to use your detector (I couldn't care less what brand it is). Get back out there and find some more - stop wasting time arguing :)

Kurk was not the reason for this experiment. But you are right, he does get under my and others skin. I just cant believe there are so many Brand Loyal Detectorist that will try to make an argument even with the facts presented in front of them.

Neythin, it is funny to see you :'( over trivial issues. Keep it up! I enjoy :D at your tirades.
 

You got some nice finds there Storm. I bought a DFX a couple of weeks ago and I am not convinced that its all that is cracked up to be. Ive used a White's Spectrum eagle for years and I think I prefer it at this point. Don't get me wrong I wont be switching anytime soon because i think it has great potential. I just have to learn it like I learned my Eagle. However if I bump into some where in Portland and your pockets are bulging with silver I might switch LOL.
 

KirkPA said:
Cubfan64 said:
Stormtrooper154 said:
KirkPA said:
Once again Storm dude, you have started a thread to cause havoc. Do you always need to troll? >:(

Actually I started this thread to see if the facts of my finds could get a fair vote from you "Whites Brand" guys. Like I said, I already have my answer. Kirk, if you posted the same thread as I have...I would give you a honest vote, not a Brand Loyalty Vote. I have no loyalty to one machine or another...I just use what works and the fact that people have voted for the whites DFX when the evidence is overwhelming for the other machine just proves you will never get a honest answer here on T-net.

Just my opinion, sorry if you don't agree, but I think I have proved it!

Storm - the only thing you've proven is that people who've watch you spar with Kirk know what to say to get under your skin and get a rise out of you - THAT'S what you proven.

I think you've done tremendous research and have really learned how to use your detector (I couldn't care less what brand it is). Get back out there and find some more - stop wasting time arguing :)

Now, do you see why I like to get at him? It is entertainment to see him :'( over not being able to find a Colonial coppa.

I think the only thing your have proven with your Colonial Coppa therory is that you need to take some history classes at the local college my man! I like you, but god damn dude!!! get a clue!
 

Stormtrooper154 said:
KirkPA said:
Cubfan64 said:
Stormtrooper154 said:
KirkPA said:
Once again Storm dude, you have started a thread to cause havoc. Do you always need to troll? >:(

Actually I started this thread to see if the facts of my finds could get a fair vote from you "Whites Brand" guys. Like I said, I already have my answer. Kirk, if you posted the same thread as I have...I would give you a honest vote, not a Brand Loyalty Vote. I have no loyalty to one machine or another...I just use what works and the fact that people have voted for the whites DFX when the evidence is overwhelming for the other machine just proves you will never get a honest answer here on T-net.

Just my opinion, sorry if you don't agree, but I think I have proved it!

Storm - the only thing you've proven is that people who've watch you spar with Kirk know what to say to get under your skin and get a rise out of you - THAT'S what you proven.

I think you've done tremendous research and have really learned how to use your detector (I couldn't care less what brand it is). Get back out there and find some more - stop wasting time arguing :)

Now, do you see why I like to get at him? It is entertainment to see him :'( over not being able to find a Colonial coppa.

I think the only thing your have proven with your Colonial Coppa therory is that you need to take some history classes at the local college my man! I like you, but god damn dude!!! get a clue!

True dat, but I wouldn't mind datectin' along the Oregon riverbanks. There are Colonials to be found.
 

Fish-Gate said:
Hey Storm,

Did you spend an equal amount of time with each detector?

Did each detector go to the same sites and hit the same signals?

I own 2 minelabs, but I don't think this post will accomplish anything, except make people defensive.

Nice finds...

Yes, There were some signals compared using my hunting partners SE vs. My DFX.
 

True dat, but I wouldn't mind datectin' along the Oregon riverbanks. There are Colonials to be found.

Yes Kirk, you are right.  There are so many Colonial Coppa's Here in Oregon that we need you to come out here and find them because no one else is good enough to locate them.
 

Top Member Reactions

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top