DEEP research and well-organized material sdcfia!
You might put it into a pamphlet or some other comprehensive form someday.
French/Hale/Schade location is compelling, wish I could have been there when Ron was prospecting to lend another eye, but no easy access now. Gold is critical to "prove" a location for the tale. BTW, someone mentioned there's no waterfall in the FHS documentation, but I recall Ron talking about one with logs hung way up the canyon rim that would run like crazy.
In one of my favorite Black Range areas, the fire and flood first wiped out the 2-3 lower waterfalls, and in the past few years has now exposed about 5 *more* higher up. Makes it even more challenging now, but intensely beautiful, especially where the ore is scattered around in the boulder fields among the clear stream. So waterfalls can come and go.
Is the Black Range Tales considered a valid source? It's sort of a biography of McKenna, but told late in his life as dictated to his caretakers, if I recall. Those old Spit and Whittle Club guys sure focused on the northern region a lot, and they hung out in PA area in person (all over 'round there, really). Interesting that they say Adams would get lost once he got to "Cactus Flats". I found a nearby place labeled that way an old map, not sure if that's also the contemporary name or not.
Wish I would have run across this post earlier. Head is spinning now. Coincidentally, I beeped up some good high grade on your hill a while back on the way through. Been there twice, and great luck every time, despite the hot rocks. Hot enough to fool my PI machine, even. Can sweat copper and silver right out of that rock (to get show) without even bothering with flux. Not sure about the gold content. Different sort of ore. Reminds me very much of the better Janos trail / Camino del Cobre material, so I'm pretty sold on the Spanish connection to PA and not just Santa Rita ("El Cobre".)
The ore's not where you'd expect to find it - sheesh, my mission was to find the mine it came from this time, but it's hard not to dig while the digging is still good. Wet soil for a change is nice - that must have been a big storm! Now I guess this post solves where the mines are likely to have been... or not all of them are found yet? (checks tire pressure, cleans windshield, sets out boots)
Saw a couple of faint non-native camp areas on the flats up there. Felt old. Only one scraper and a few flakes the whole day, for that type of sign. Was heading toward the twins when Mr. Blacktail decided to show me just how healthy he was. He got clear up "on his hind legs". I swear it was 10 minutes before he relaxed that last stage and slithered off. Never stared one down like that before. Wanted to see how long I'd have to wait if I did not spot him first and have distance. He was real ornery for a blacktail - more like I'd expect from a western.
Regarding Codebreaker, ever talk to them or happen to know anything about "Lilo" or "lilo" markings? They had a glyph of that sort on their site (is it still up?) that is different from the ones I've found. And I've found them well away from PA and Cooke's.
Again, stupendously meaty work! Thanks for sharing.
(I cut the quote to save space, so if that's bad form then the hard-working and patient moderators can maybe put the whole thing back if that's better)
Unreconciled Pinos Altos gold legends
4. Spanish mines on Twin Sisters Peaks
There are a number of legends indicating Spanish gold mines in the Pinos Altos/Santa Rita del Cobre mineralized zone...