ScubaFinder
Bronze Member
- Jul 11, 2006
- 2,220
- 530
- Detector(s) used
- AquaPulse AQ1B - AquaPulse DX-200 Magnetometer
- Primary Interest:
- Shipwrecks
Re: What's going on in the DR?
Thanks Sam, even coming from you. :-) We differ on a few points but that doesn't mean that I don't respect your opinion. I'm way more sick of the widely held opinion that "treasure hunters are nothing more than thiefs", than I am of your rhetoric. You are of the opinion that all treasures of the Spanish Main belong to Spain no matter how or where they were obtained or found, or who mined or found them. On the other hand,I believe an amatuer archaeologist who spends his time, money, and effort to find the treasure deserves his fair reward. Both points have certain merits and certain faults. My point is and has always been that there IS middle ground, and EVERYONE...including Spain....would be better off if we all tried to work together instead acting solely with Greed as our motivator.
The archaeologists are greedy for recognition, treasure hunters are greedy for wealth and the pursuit of of our dreams, and Spain is greedy in the courts. If we could somehow take greed out of the equation, and get everyone to look at it as peers who care about the same things...the whole system could work beautifully. The treasure hunters are trying to help, but I can't say the same for academic archaeology, nor for Spain. The treasure hunters are the only ones who have the boats, funding, and skills nessecary (all in one place) to do this most important work.
What if worldwide we were excavating 60-80 wrecks simultaneously, museums and archies were getting a flood of incredible artifacts and data, Spain, France, Portugal, and Britain were getting a lot of their nautical heritage back that they would otherwise never see, and the workers (treasure hunters) were getting paid well to do what they love, and getting a finders bonus for doing their job well. Can you imagine how quickly our knowledge would advance, how interesting our museums would be, how busy our archaeologists would be. It's so damn simple that it hurts my head to watch large countries and academics who should be smarter, act like greedy children with little or no education. I cannot be the smartest guy on earth...so where are the smart archaeologists, where are the smart diplomats in Spain and elsewhere, where is the spirit that this is HUMAN history, and it belongs to all of us equally?
Jason
Thanks Sam, even coming from you. :-) We differ on a few points but that doesn't mean that I don't respect your opinion. I'm way more sick of the widely held opinion that "treasure hunters are nothing more than thiefs", than I am of your rhetoric. You are of the opinion that all treasures of the Spanish Main belong to Spain no matter how or where they were obtained or found, or who mined or found them. On the other hand,I believe an amatuer archaeologist who spends his time, money, and effort to find the treasure deserves his fair reward. Both points have certain merits and certain faults. My point is and has always been that there IS middle ground, and EVERYONE...including Spain....would be better off if we all tried to work together instead acting solely with Greed as our motivator.
The archaeologists are greedy for recognition, treasure hunters are greedy for wealth and the pursuit of of our dreams, and Spain is greedy in the courts. If we could somehow take greed out of the equation, and get everyone to look at it as peers who care about the same things...the whole system could work beautifully. The treasure hunters are trying to help, but I can't say the same for academic archaeology, nor for Spain. The treasure hunters are the only ones who have the boats, funding, and skills nessecary (all in one place) to do this most important work.
What if worldwide we were excavating 60-80 wrecks simultaneously, museums and archies were getting a flood of incredible artifacts and data, Spain, France, Portugal, and Britain were getting a lot of their nautical heritage back that they would otherwise never see, and the workers (treasure hunters) were getting paid well to do what they love, and getting a finders bonus for doing their job well. Can you imagine how quickly our knowledge would advance, how interesting our museums would be, how busy our archaeologists would be. It's so damn simple that it hurts my head to watch large countries and academics who should be smarter, act like greedy children with little or no education. I cannot be the smartest guy on earth...so where are the smart archaeologists, where are the smart diplomats in Spain and elsewhere, where is the spirit that this is HUMAN history, and it belongs to all of us equally?
Jason