Unsure of which new detector to get

twister

Bronze Member
Joined
Mar 5, 2005
Messages
1,129
Reaction score
17
Golden Thread
0
Location
Springfield, MO
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
I am wanting to change things up a little bit but not sure which way to go. I have done some research and have narrowed it down to 3. They are The Fisher F75, the Explorer SE or just getting the new Super12 coil for my MXT. I mostly hunt old homes and Civil War sites. I would love to have any insight or recommendations good or bad to help me in making my decision. Thanks for the help.

HH Twister
 

Upvote 0
The new coil for the MXT is a fine choice if you already have a small sniper coil for the trash. However I expect that you just need (want) an new detector since they're fun to learn too. I'm all for the SE even though it will be different to use after a simple Whites. It is just the ticket for trash areas. I am not into anything Fisher makes anymore since they are not owned by the same service minded people. But time will tell. I have not had the opportunity to "play" with a F75 yet so I can't comment on it.

HH,
Sandman
 

What detector do you swing now? As for the F75, I thought about it and figured that it's waayyy too expensive for what a person is getting. Consider, for close to $1000 your getting a detector that has one available coil and except for a bit more info on the screen doesn't really offer anything groundbreaking. For $699 you can get an XTerra 70 with 3 coils, ground tracking, beach mode, and a notch that works on the high conductors too. As for depth claims.. that and a buck will buy me a cup of coffee. Despite all the hype associated with various VLF detectors (pics of backhoes, claims of being an 'illegal alien') the sad truth of the matter is thatVLF detectors had reached a plateau (depth wise) about 15-20 years ago and all the manufacturers are offering is really just new interpretations/packaging.. kinda like chewing your food; you can do it all day, but it all looks the same in the end. Then there's the MXT; no effective notching or tones, but a ton of coils with a killer all-metal mode at, what.. $630 ? For $1000, I'd get either a GTI 2500 pro pack or an Explorer SE. Even better, I'd just wait a few months till the new crop of discriminating PI's come out. They seem to want to be Minelab PI killers, so they'll have to show depth that will make a person leave his/her VLF's in the closet.. along with sensitivity down to 1 grain (gold nuggets). If you have a decent detector at peasent, I'd say stick with it. At most, buy a used one or something like the Ace 250. That way you won't get nailed as bad in the used market.
It might sound a bit like 'chicken little', but take a look at what happened when ML came out with their new PI; the market is now flooded with cheap ML PI's. Everyone want's the best and brightest. When PI's with disc. (effective to full depth too) come out, who will want a plain old VLF which, in other than mild ground, gets only middling depth with iffy disc.? I foresee a lot of high end VLF detectors being sold reel cheep in the near future.
One other thing to consider, when buying a detector, is why it's for sale. By this, I mean that if a detector is so $hit-hot.. why sell it? White's, Garrett, Minelab, Tesoro, First Texas, Fisher all sell a load of detectors and have been doing so for years. Therefor, there are a lot of detectors from each company out there. Now, despite all the BS being spouted on the various forums about which detector is 'best', which ones are seen the least on the classifieds and which the most? That ought to tell a person something. If someone really likes something, he/she will tend to keep it. If people are hanging onto certain detectors (brands/models) it might be worth looking into getting one of the harder to find, yet popular detectors. ..Willy.
 

If you are willing to be patient with the SE then I would go there . Upgrading a 12" coil on your MXT isn't going to give you as much as the SE will although a 12" coil on an MXT sounds very good to me 8). I have been using the F75 recently since we finally got rid of the snow here , but it is too early to say it is better overall than the SE or any other detector. VLF technology is basically the same when it comes to frequencies and operation but the modern detector has a lot more going for it than its predecessors. What you can get in an Ace250 today was only seen in top of the lines years ago. I've been doing this for 32 years and I have to say , Unless you are using total and true all metal mode todays disciminating VLF's go deeper than their predecessors. User and operator skill also has a lot to do with how successful someone is but dollarwise , the more expensive detector can do a better job at finding the keepers.
TonyinCT
www.tcmetaldetectors.com
 

Mmmm.. I dunno. I've done quite a few in-ground depth tests betwwen old and new detectors and, in my ground, there's not much to choose between. In fact, just this past December I did a head to head between a Fisher Coinstrike and an old X-100 and, in many ways, the X-100 was superior. This was in disc. mode (Forest service campground at oceans edge) and the depths were more or less identical. A few years ago I did another between an Excalibur, Sov. XS2a, GTI 1500, Cobra II (modded), and an Infinium. The Infinium was, by far, the winner for depth with the Cobra II and GTI 1500 tying for second. ...Willy.
 

Now, despite all the BS being spouted on the various forums about which detector is 'best', which ones are seen the least on the classifieds and which the most? That ought to tell a person something.

The best detectors are not necessarily the easiest to figure out or the most convenient to use. Whole bunch of folks who have lots of $ but no patience. Google up White's DFX and see how many threads on various forums concern guys who are utterly lost in adjusting 45 seperate functions.

In any technology driven pursuit last years models will always be for sale because the techno-geeks want the latest and newest, and the rich kids never did get them to work and are bored so they will try what comes along next.
 

You can make a new detector out of the MXT if you buy a 5.3 concentric coil. That's what I would do. Home sites are trashy and the little coil will do much better. You will probably leave it on all the time.
 

Top Member Reactions

Users who are viewing this thread

Latest Discussions

Back
Top Bottom