The 1835 J.A. McDonald Homestead Gives Up A beautiful key date Indian

crazyjarhead

Gold Member
Sep 10, 2007
10,318
43
N. San Diego County
Detector(s) used
Ace 250
Primary Interest:
Metal Detecting
Good evening everyone,

Many of you probably remember the old JA. McDonald homesite which I pounded 100's of hours last year and found mostly per-1900 coins including 2 LC and 12 IH's, all in the 1860-1880 range. Well today I couldn't resist going back over and pounding it some more before it's gone. The house has been for sale and has just been reduced so who knows how much longer I'll be able to hunt there. This place has become somewhat personal to me. I know the guy who lived there and even found his grave at the cemetery. He was a wealthy man and played a roll in the early days of Woodstock. He was one of the original settlers who moved to Woodstock Ohio from Woodstock Vermont, thus the name was given to this small rural town. I would like to buy it but have a nice house of my own. Besides, it's 175 years old. It was built in 1835.

Enough of my story telling. Anyways, I hunted it for about 2 hours like I always do. Dug every signal. After an hour into the hunt i thought I was going to get skunked. Well, dug a1908 IH. Not in too bad of shape. Then on my way back to my car I stumbled upon a nice Green 1871 at 5 inches. After a rinses under the water and a soft brush and a manicure it came out really nice. Just a little wear but very nice coin indeed. Also dug a National Distillers cap at 8 inches. Any idea on age. The Pat. date is 1875 and ??

This brings the total to 14 IH's at this place and 2 LC's. I was hoping on some more of the big pennies but not today. Just goes to show you that no place ever gets hunted out completely....... believe me. Lot's of hours and dedication and lot's of patience. Dig every signal and swing in every angle possible. Coins will come out if they are there.

Good luck and keep at it. Thanks for looking.....Ron
I just saw a 58 dollar price for one just as good. Any Ideas?? I have had a few PM's stating the coin is a key date. I'm just a dumb jarhead and didn't know that. So, we'll see what happens from here. Thanks for all of the input and comments.




Picture382-2.jpg


Picture394-2.jpg


Picture393.jpg


Picture758.jpg


Picture406.jpg


002-14.jpg


003-14.jpg


004-15.jpg


005-15.jpg


006-14.jpg


017-8.jpg


018-7.jpg


019-7.jpg


020-5.jpg


021-4.jpg


007-15.jpg


008-15.jpg


009-15.jpg


010-16.jpg


011-14.jpg



Just found a link on the National Distilers:

http://www.bottlebooks.com/American Medicinal Spirits Company/national_distillers_products.htm
 

Upvote 0
Re: The 1835 J.A. McDonald Homestead Keeps On Giving Up It's Lost Souls

Very nice "71" you have there. That place has been very good to you! Keep it up as I am sure there is more.


VPR
 

Re: The 1835 J.A. McDonald Homestead Keeps On Giving (1871 IH) 14 IH's So Far

Do you know the 1871 IH is a keydate? I thought it was so I looked it up an it books at 100.00 in G-4 I would say yours is xf with au detail so that is 500.00 or better in a auction maybe a lil lower do to the fact it was dug... DO not clean the GREEN off til a more Knowledgeable person on here tells you what you should do..it may lower the price if you clean it!! that is a awesome Find an a penny worth that much deserves being on banner in my opinion
 

Re: The 1835 J.A. McDonald Homestead Keeps On Giving Up It's Lost Souls

your the man,Did you use your ace 250?Just wondering because that's what I use.(Correction learning to use).WTG.
Kevin
 

Re: The 1835 J.A. McDonald Homestead Keeps On Giving (1871 IH) 14 IH's So Far

creeper71 said:
Do you know the 1871 IH is a keydate? I thought it was so I looked it up an it books at 100.00 in G-4 I would say yours is xf with au detail so that is 500.00 or better in a auction maybe a lil lower do to the fact it was dug... that is a awesome Find an a penny worth that much deserves being on banner in my opinion

WHATTTTTTTTTTTTT :o
 

Re: The 1835 J.A. McDonald Homestead Keeps On Giving Up It's Lost Souls

kevin11 said:
your the man,Did you use your ace 250?Just wondering because that's what I use.(Correction learning to use).WTG.
Kevin

The Ace is the only detector I have
 

Re: The 1835 J.A. McDonald Homestead Gives Up A beautiful 1871 Indian

Very nice key date IH, A big congrats on that one.

I found a 71 earlier this spring almost as nice as yours.
 

Re: The 1835 J.A. McDonald Homestead Gives Up A beautiful 1871 Indian

creeper71 said:
btw I just voted for the banner for ya!

You know more than I do. I don't know if it qualifies, but thanks for your "Banner vote" I'll be shocked if it is that good, but i really don't know :dontknow:
 

Congrates! By the way, did you check the back of that 1908 to see if it's a "S"? (6:00, on the bottom) Amazing how you can find a coin that's 37 years older than your 1871, and it's in crappier condition. Whitman folder, be filled!
Carl
 

Wow very nice IH and a key date too !!! They are always exciting to dig and a little tricky too. WTG.

Tom
 

That is a nice 1871 I.H it is well worth over two digits. I would like to see a banner on that beauty.
 

Very nice 71 IH you found there. Looks like it will go XF......Matt
 

Nice finds.............the I.H. cleaned up very well.................... :thumbsup:

I think that coin should be on the banner........you get 1 vote from me............... :thumbsup:
 

Top Member Reactions

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top