Season 4

marticus said:
Ok full version. Which can be verified and has been.
In 1940 2 men illeagly fishing using a dragnet. Dragged up the sword. Not really a sword more a dagger letter opener. Because what they where doing carried huge fines and jail time. They kept the find to them selves. The man then passed and it went to his wife. She then passed and it went to their daughter. The daughter then passed and it then went on to her partner. The partner took it to rick. Marty and craig.
Who then took it in.
Marty rick and craig then produced the it to JHP before the filming of season 2

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk
Click to expand...

That's one "point of view". There seems to be contradicting information placing THAT sword (same stains - not a similar casting) in the Italian version of ebaY.

Blade Anomalies 99% Bust the Myth of the "Roman Sword from Nova Scotia" - Andy White Anthropology

The Italian eBay Sword - Andy White Anthropology

"Oak Island" Gives Verdict on "Roman" Sword; Plus: Are Fairy Tales Bronze Age Relics? - Jason Colavito

Here is the actual link to the auction site - 75Euro. The image is gone but if you go down the page they are still there. What our English friends call "tourist tat".

http://www.treasurenet.com/forums/oak-island/477949-season-3-curse-oak-island-46.html#post4831547

PARTICOLARE SCULTURA COMMEMORATIVA SPADA BRONZEA ROMANA CON IMPUGNATURA STATUA | eBay


The problem is they have a site and are trying to attach back-stories to it instead of examining the site and forming a conclusion from the evidence. But because the evidence has been trashed by so many prior digs and surface gradings it likely is impossible. I guess that sells TV advertising time. It's getting as embarrassing as "America Unearthed."
 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

Agony and Death on a Gold Rush Steamer: The Disastrous Sinking of the Side-Wheeler Yankee Blade - Grab it through Amazon!
marticus said:
Watch the video it goes for 1.5hrs.
You want to fight over the headlines that portray this guy. Why not listen to it straight from the man him self. Call it like it is. Rather then hate bash on him. He will clearly come out and say. Its not my sword. I did not find or bring it to the island. I did not call it roman.
All you have to do is pay attention

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk
Click to expand...

Startling new report on Oak Island could ?rewrite history? of the Americas - Boston Standard

"Now lead researcher and historic investigator J. Hutton Pulitzer, who also stars in the show, has put a large white paper together with a group of academics from the AAPS (Ancient Artifact Preservation Society).
The main discoveries include a Roman sword found submerged just off Oak Island - and what is believed to be a Roman shipwreck.
Pulitzer says this sword is ‘100 per cent confirmed’ and described it as the ‘smoking gun’ to his theory."
 

"Boston Standard". Boston as in a town of 58,000 people in Lincolnshire, England.
 

The sword has been completely debunked why is anyone still defending it?? The entire back story is completely fictional also. No mysterious fishermen who make the discovery of a lifetime yet not say anything because they might get in trouble for illegal fishing??? BTW - still waiting for the roman shipwreck??
 

Take the time. Watch the video. Let the guy tell it from his side. Not just take it from news and websites and all the other fake crap that goes around every day.
Im sure it will answer all your questions and most likely the next 10 your going to ask.
If you dont want to watch it thats fine.

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk
 

Charlie P. (NY) said:
That's one "point of view". There seems to be contradicting information placing THAT sword (same stains - not a similar casting) in the Italian version of ebaY.

Blade Anomalies 99% Bust the Myth of the "Roman Sword from Nova Scotia" - Andy White Anthropology

The Italian eBay Sword - Andy White Anthropology

"Oak Island" Gives Verdict on "Roman" Sword; Plus: Are Fairy Tales Bronze Age Relics? - Jason Colavito

Here is the actual link to the auction site - 75Euro. The image is gone but if you go down the page they are still there. What our English friends call "tourist tat".

http://www.treasurenet.com/forums/oak-island/477949-season-3-curse-oak-island-46.html#post4831547

PARTICOLARE SCULTURA COMMEMORATIVA SPADA BRONZEA ROMANA CON IMPUGNATURA STATUA | eBay


The problem is they have a site and are trying to attach back-stories to it instead of examining the site and forming a conclusion from the evidence. But because the evidence has been trashed by so many prior digs and surface gradings it likely is impossible. I guess that sells TV advertising time. It's getting as embarrassing as "America Unearthed."
Click to expand...
Well see the problem to is that Hutton does have on paper. True accounts. Discriptions and testing on other artifacts on same origin. Which has all been done and analyised and verified by the British Museum. Which states. The presence of ZINC which the halifax university said anything over 20% is most likely a fake.
However straight from the BRITISH museum said artifacts could have as much as 80% ZINC and that it use to be reffered to as fake silver.

Look its all in the video plus heaps of other stuff.


Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk
 

Raparee said:
Startling new report on Oak Island could ?rewrite history? of the Americas - Boston Standard

"Now lead researcher and historic investigator J. Hutton Pulitzer, who also stars in the show, has put a large white paper together with a group of academics from the AAPS (Ancient Artifact Preservation Society).
The main discoveries include a Roman sword found submerged just off Oak Island - and what is believed to be a Roman shipwreck.
Pulitzer says this sword is ‘100 per cent confirmed’ and described it as the ‘smoking gun’ to his theory."
Click to expand...
Hey your fron NS. Why dont you go down to the archives and look up the bronze bowls and cups that the found around the place. Then you will clearly see hey those cant be bowls. They have small holes in them. Like they where off a sheild. Then wait what kind of sheild had those. Hmmmm

If you do some digging in the archives im sure you find all the same **** he is finding there and just putting it on camera

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk
 

marticus said:
Take the time. Watch the video. Let the guy tell it from his side.
Click to expand...

I heard it from his side when he stated that the sword was 100% confirmed to be a Roman artifact. The man is a con and a shyster.

Fact: The technology required to produce the alloy that the sword is made of didn't exist until the late 1800's.
 

Raparee said:
You mean like the "Roman crossbow bolt" he turned up?
The Blockhouse Blog - The Oak Island Compendium

I say again: he's a con and a shyster.
Click to expand...
Wow people are right about you NS chaps.
Hey its all in your archives. Not made up not invented. Its in your national archives. But yea i guess your right. He just made all this up then some how he got it to make its way into the old records in the National Archives of NS and i have followed huts for over 8 years. Do the math its way before OI.
Im sure a guy who has a fleet of trucks. A helicopter. Hovercraft. Buggies. Boats and well over 100,000$ in metal detection gear alone. But yea his a con man fraud aye.

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk
 

marticus said:
Wow people are right about you NS chaps.
Hey its all in your archives. Not made up not invented. Its in your national archives. But yea i guess your right. He just made all this up then some how he got it to make its way into the old records in the National Archives of NS and i have followed huts for over 8 years. Do the math its way before OI.
Im sure a guy who has a fleet of trucks. A helicopter. Hovercraft. Buggies. Boats and well over 100,000$ in metal detection gear alone. But yea his a con man fraud aye.

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
A peavy point. LMAO are you freaking serious. Man you need better resources.
JHP called the owner of the mill. Live on radio. The owner is a direct decendent of the family. He even laughed and said there is no way that is anything like what we had. **** ill even find that radio interview. Since it does not appear you can navigate the internet outside of any canadian websites

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk
 

Raparee said:
I heard it from his side when he stated that the sword was 100% confirmed to be a Roman artifact. The man is a con and a shyster.

Fact: The technology required to produce the alloy that the sword is made of didn't exist until the late 1800's.
Click to expand...
Best put that fact to the British Museum of London England. They must have the wrong information.
I would love to see their response

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk
 

marticus said:
Wow people are right about you NS chaps.
Hey its all in your archives. Not made up not invented. Its in your national archives. But yea i guess your right. He just made all this up then some how he got it to make its way into the old records in the National Archives of NS and i have followed huts for over 8 years. Do the math its way before OI.
Im sure a guy who has a fleet of trucks. A helicopter. Hovercraft. Buggies. Boats and well over 100,000$ in metal detection gear alone. But yea his a con man fraud aye.

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk
Click to expand...

Following Jovan the Hut for 8 years, and yet you can't see the BS when it's right in front of you. I don't know whether I should laugh at you or pity you.

Tell me, is Philyaw still selling those crystals?
 

Raparee said:
Following Jovan the Hut for 8 years, and yet you can't see the BS when it's right in front of you. I don't know whether I should laugh at you or pity you.

Tell me, is Philyaw still selling those crystals?
Click to expand...
He never sold crystals. He posts images taken from geology sites.

Lol heck this reminds me of the time they boys on OI where investigating the so called HATCH. To which the local hippy archaeologist comes out and goes. I Havnt seen anything like that before. That could be something.

Yea a root cellar derrr

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk
 

marticus said:
Listen to Oak Island Roman Cross Bow Bolts? Are They Real? Interview w Peavy Manufacturing by History Heretic #np on #SoundCloud
https://soundcloud.com/investigatin...are-they-real-interview-w-peavy-manufacturing

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk
Click to expand...

If the source of your information is Hutton, then it is garbage. Hutton has not given me any reason to believe anything he has to say. Quite the opposite. He has gone out of his way to make himself an object of ridicule, with zero credibility.

Just for giggles, find me a verified photo of a cross bow bolt that has a tang, and not a socket.
 

marticus said:
He never sold crystals. He posts images taken from geology sites.

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk
Click to expand...

"Philyaw, the masterful pitchman between the CueCat, a cutely named handheld barcode scanner that was supposed to bridge print media and the Web, apparently now does business under the name J. Hutton Pulitzer — or the one-word moniker "Jovan." Operating J. Hutton Pulitzer and Co. out of Dallas, the inventor of what has been decried as "one of the most ridiculed products of the Internet era," now specializes in the "development of unique intellectual property." Such as? Bottled rainwater. Crystals. And a forthcoming book entitled Generational Curses. Will Jovan be foiled again? Only time will tell."•Text from "J. Jovan Philyaw" from Where Are They Now by Fast Company (accessed 10/24/2015)

"As Central Track tells us, Mr. Philyaw is a rather colorful character. After CueCat, he went on to help ruin Radio Shack. He has also peddled magic crystals, planted fake historical artifacts, and claims Mark Cuban is responsible for his divorce. At some point, he changed his name to J. Hutton Pulitzer, a move which allowed him to dabble in a bit of self-reinvention."•​Text from ​"CueCat Inventor Serves Up Craziest Video You’ll See All Day" by Peter Simek (accessed 8/28/2016)
 

Raparee said:
If the source of your information is Hutton, then it is garbage. Hutton has not given me any reason to believe anything he has to say. Quite the opposite. He has gone out of his way to make himself an object of ridicule, with zero credibility.

Just for giggles, find me a verified photo of a cross bow bolt that has a tang, and not a socket.
Click to expand...
Your so fast to jump on him. With out even considering your wrong. Even with presented with evidence that the manufacturer has dismissed them as being theirs. That screams what type of charater you are. Hell if you bothered to watch the video he even comes out and tells you the place and location that the bolt where tested. To which you can file a freedom of information act to get the results yourself.

Everything is all in my posts its up to you to grip those panities on tight. Stiffen up the bottom lip un squint your eyes and pay attention to what someone else has to say. Until then all we can do is wait for people like you to die out and stop being a hinderence

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk
 

marticus said:
That screams what type of charater you are.
Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk
Click to expand...

No. It screams what kind of character Hutton is. I'm actually a pretty open minded guy, but when it comes to Hutton, after years of cons and BS and shenanigans, I have learned not to trust him. I reject any argument or information that comes from Hutton, because he has proven himself to be somewhat less than honest.
 

Raparee said:
No. It screams what kind of character Hutton is. I'm actually a pretty open minded guy, but when it comes to Hutton, after years of cons and BS and shenanigans, I have learned not to trust him. I reject any argument or information that comes from Hutton, because he has proven himself to be somewhat less than honest.
Click to expand...
Well i personally have found thousands of $$$ listening to him and following his instructions and clues

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk
 

You must log in or register to reply here.

Another season ..is this a joke?

⬅️ Previous Thread

Hunted the local playground today

Next Thread ➡️

Top Member Reactions

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 3 (members: 0, guests: 3)
Metal Detecting Stuff

Latest Discussions

Back
Top