Oroblanco
Gold Member
- Jan 21, 2005
- 7,841
- 9,867
- Detector(s) used
- Tesoro Lobo Supertraq, (95%) Garrett Scorpion (5%)
Investigator wrote
Mounted knights? How about a bunch of American prospectors on a mix of horses and mules, traveling at the walk? Would they still make 50 or 60 miles per day, over Arizona wilderness? I have doubts.
That is an interesting spin, to cast the Lost Adams into the Superstitions and tie the Peraltas in with it, however there are a number of flies in the buttermilk with this idea. You say four days from Old Ft Wingate; did you take into account the other verbal description? Ten days from Gila Bend, in a general NE direction. Ten days travel at 50 or 60 miles per day puts them 500 to 600 miles NE of Gila Bend, or into quite another state. Then there is the point where Adams was picked up by the Cavalry after running for his life from the mine; I have heard several different locations proposed but all are in very eastern AZ or very western NM; so for the mine canyon to be in the Superstitions, he would have had quite a run.
I would think that four days travel leading a string of pack horses or mules from Ft Wingate would equate to more like ~ 40 to 80 miles tops, which would not even come close to the Superstition mts. What about those "Piloncillos" mentioned by Gotchear? <piloncillos ="sugar-cones" because sugar was sold in hard cone-shaped pieces in the early days> No mention of a "picacho" as a Spanish speaker would likely describe Weavers Needle or Miners Needle. Also how do Peraltas tie in with Adams? I thought the whole Peralta legend is linked with the Lost Dutchman lode mine, not the Lost Adams placer mine.
I don't mean to be the wet blanket, just there seems to be problems with this theory as you propose it. If you can clarify these points (especially the ten days from Gila Bend problem) I would appreciate it. As it stands I can't see how it would work. Thank you in advance;
Oroblanco
Mounted knights-- all on well-conditioned destriers or palfreys -- would move fairly fast and cover upwards of 50 or 60 miles per day. Four Days From Old Fort Wingate 200 to 240 miles
Mounted knights? How about a bunch of American prospectors on a mix of horses and mules, traveling at the walk? Would they still make 50 or 60 miles per day, over Arizona wilderness? I have doubts.
That is an interesting spin, to cast the Lost Adams into the Superstitions and tie the Peraltas in with it, however there are a number of flies in the buttermilk with this idea. You say four days from Old Ft Wingate; did you take into account the other verbal description? Ten days from Gila Bend, in a general NE direction. Ten days travel at 50 or 60 miles per day puts them 500 to 600 miles NE of Gila Bend, or into quite another state. Then there is the point where Adams was picked up by the Cavalry after running for his life from the mine; I have heard several different locations proposed but all are in very eastern AZ or very western NM; so for the mine canyon to be in the Superstitions, he would have had quite a run.
I would think that four days travel leading a string of pack horses or mules from Ft Wingate would equate to more like ~ 40 to 80 miles tops, which would not even come close to the Superstition mts. What about those "Piloncillos" mentioned by Gotchear? <piloncillos ="sugar-cones" because sugar was sold in hard cone-shaped pieces in the early days> No mention of a "picacho" as a Spanish speaker would likely describe Weavers Needle or Miners Needle. Also how do Peraltas tie in with Adams? I thought the whole Peralta legend is linked with the Lost Dutchman lode mine, not the Lost Adams placer mine.
I don't mean to be the wet blanket, just there seems to be problems with this theory as you propose it. If you can clarify these points (especially the ten days from Gila Bend problem) I would appreciate it. As it stands I can't see how it would work. Thank you in advance;
Oroblanco