Certain TV Shows Setting The Hobby Back?

Mike(Iowa)

Jr. Member
Dec 18, 2003
46
32
So, I was talking to a coworker today (who owns an old farmhouse and a nice piece of property) about my weekend, and how my Son and I hit a cellar hole in the woods. His first question was, "So how long before you drove in the backhoe like they do on that Savage show?".:BangHead:

It occurs to me, that the last 20 years I have detected, and many more years by some of my friends and fellow club members, is being diminished by certain TV shows. We have struggled with convincing land owners that we aren't there with a pickax or a bulldozer to dig up their yard. This show is doing a few things.

1. It makes land owners think everyone has a 20% split of thousands of dollars just hidden under the soil.
2. Makes the ill-informed think that we are all modern day pirates, ready to scrape off half the yard to find one rifle barrel.
3. Proves that there are people out there who don't care how much damage they do to other artifacts while they roto-till someone's yard up looking for arrow heads. Kind of proves the point archaeologists have been trying to make about us for years.

The reality is much less lucrative than people are seeing on their television, but you would never convince anyone of that now. I look forward to the day these shows go off the air. About the only people who I see benefiting from these shows, are detector manufacturers.

Just my humble opinion, curious to hear yours (even if it is in disagreement with mine). :laughing7:
 

Upvote 0
Not sure about the other shows but diggers is what made me want to start in the first place. I'm sure it would make for interesting tv if they showed an hour of digging pull tabs. IMO they are honest and actually work to find the things they find. I definitely don't agree with using backhoes and ripping people's lawns up but I don't think the "diggers" do. They always say they got permission :-) they are a bit eccentric at times but that's just human nature. I'd be excited too to find what they do!!!
 

Not sure about the other shows but diggers is what made me want to start in the first place. I'm sure it would make for interesting tv if they showed an hour of digging pull tabs. IMO they are honest and actually work to find the things they find. I definitely don't agree with using backhoes and ripping people's lawns up but I don't think the "diggers" do. They always say they got permission :-) they are a bit eccentric at times but that's just human nature. I'd be excited too to find what they do!!!

in all honesty I think they need to work hard at acting so excited :laughing7:

I think the things they are digging are cool, but it isn't their first day out.

in other words, The Digs are real,
but the Excitement is fake :laughing7:
 

I've watched there old videos on you tube before they were ever on TV 4 or 5 years ago. They have always been like that its just who they are.
 

Agree Jeff. My neighbor detected in the hay day so to speak with an old old fisher machine. He got hooked on diggers bought a new machine and is now wanting to go all the time. He says we got to get some roundness in the hole,, I crack up. I guess the show has brought a lot of people into the hobby. I hope they have fun and enjoy themselves.I do not think the show has set the hobby back. If anything it has increased members to it.It may set it back as far as people not knowing what they are doing and stupid things so we loose permission as the hobby is exposed .Everyone needs to take the class or get advice before they dig.

I like Diggers they put together a good video.
 

Last edited:
the show diggers is a LOT better then the savedge show will ever be, like, the saveg show they show them finding a rev. time cannon, WTF? and that is the only thing in the water? and you can fing tell that it hasnt been in fresh water, and them finding a 30 foot deep hole just for 1 or 2 shark teeth? they are not worth no 3-6 thousand dollers, at least the digger show shows their trash and everything they find,!
 

yes, i have a personal friend who is friends with george and he says they have always been like that
 

in all honesty I think they need to work hard at acting so excited :laughing7:

I think the things they are digging are cool, but it isn't their first day out.

in other words, The Digs are real,
but the Excitement is fake :laughing7:

I actually like watching diggers with my kids. The first time they saw it, my older boy saw one of them swinging from a tree after a find and asked, "you don't act like that when you are detecting, do you?". LOL In all honesty,they really need to play a show that depicts the entire story, like digging a hundred chunks of junk before you get anything older than 1986 in your pouch. I think that would go a long ways towards showing people a realistic hunt.

But the real damaging show is not diggers. I just didn't want to point a finger at one show in particular, that is really far fetched, and is really portraying us as idiots.
 

Reality shows like "American Diggers" should be sued for false advertising because they are anything but reality! Seems that the networks today want to shovel this "Bovine Science" down our throats with an excavator! Hundreds of channels on the air now days and only a few have anything worth watching. :( Most of these shows seem to be geared towards showing people how NOT to do something! "Bearing Sea Gold come to mind as a "HOW NOT TO" show." Maybe if they set up something in the show like a "Hunt clock" to show how much time the people actually spent swinging their detectors before they actually found something other than trash is would help but I kind of doubt it.

I for one would much rather be out in the field enjoying myself instead of sitting in front of the T.V. rotting my brain...... Not that I have much brain left to rot mind you... ;)
 

I think it is already taking a toll. Obtaining permissions is like pulling teeth for me lately. I can't say that the shows have something to do with it, but I am sure it does not help.

People see these shows with a bunch of jackass's tearing up the earth, it is safe to say that permission seekers will also be seen in a negative light. Just my two clad cents worth.
 

I agree with many of you about "Diggers" Like the show, could do without the crazy stuff. Boom Baby needs to stop. I saw one show, that is the way to get them off the air is by complaining, not watching or someone sues their ass off..! We could live without them.. No Problem.
 

Top Member Reactions

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top