Wow! Beautifully Preserved Pewter Spoon! Was Able to Research it's History!

coinman123

Silver Member
Feb 21, 2013
4,659
5,769
New England, Somewhere Metal Detecting in the Wood
🥇 Banner finds
2
🏆 Honorable Mentions:
1
Detector(s) used
Teknetics T2 SE (DST)
Spare Teknetics T2 SE (backup)
15" T2 coil
Pro-Pointer
Bounty Hunter Pioneer 202
Fisher F2
Fisher F-Point
Primary Interest:
Other
Using my recently made map of every pre-1850 abandoned homestead in my town, and each site's almost exact location on Google Earth, I have been at around 5 cellar holes (out of around 30 or so on my map). I have mainly just scouted them, not really metal detected, and a few have been hunted out for the most part. Today me and a friend went to one on my map, he did not have his pinpointer so I let him use mine, which was sadly out of battery. My friend for some reason won't dig without a pinpointer. I metal detected right next to the foundation and cellar hole. I also dug inside of it. On the side of the foundation I was overloaded with signals, I dug one non-iron signal and found a beautiful pewter spoon. I then dug a big iron signal and found a big bracket and copper spoon (probably once silver plated), in the same hole (along with a ton of window glass everywhere). I then moved to inside the cellar hole and got a high signal in the wall, the signal got worse then went away, making me guess it was a nail. I noticed a bottle one foot into the dirt of the cellar hole wall though, and was able to safely remove a 1963 Pepsi bottle without even chipping it. I am surprised by what it was doing in the dirt wall of the cellar, I am thinking that the disappearing signal may have been the cap of the Pepsi bottle. It was my 4th soda bottle this year (the others were a 1984 Pepsi Bottle, 1968 Coke Bottle, late 1970's bad condition Pepsi bottle (haven't grabbed it yet, found within minutes of the 1968 Coke seen while walking in woods)) I was happy to bring it home to try and clean it out, they look nice in windows. Also on the edge of the cellar hole I found a late 1800's ornate brass compact. Anyways, my friend said he got tons of beautiful high tones, but had trouble digging them without the pinpointer so he gave up on all of them except one signal where he recovered a mid-1800's bullet. We are going back out tomorrow, with pin pointers, wish us luck!

Makers marks on pewter spoon are "JNO" "YA" "TE" "S", "JNO" is short for John I read.
Here is the history of the pewter spoon. I haven't been able to ID the copper one but I saw some place saying the first symbol is an 1842 date mark. I found out that the pewter one was made by a pewter maker by the name of John Yates, of Birmingham England. In 1805 he was registered as a spoon maker, in 1823 he opened his permanent business location. Then in 1829 he partnered with other spoon makers Thomas Rawlins Birch and Lucasta Spooner (hallmark changed to Y B & S). In 1837 his son joined changing the name to John Yates and Son (some hallmarks are "J Y & SON"). John left in 1839, and died in 1876. The name "John Yates and Son stayed until the late 1800's and they became very wellknown in the trade. I am guessing that my spoon would be rather early in his career, at least before 1829. Most of his pre-1829 works say "JO" "HN" "YA" "TE" "S", without "JNO". I am guessing that this spoon would be made very early on, perhaps in his first ten years of work. It is very different than late 1800's electroplated spoons made by "John Yates and Son", my spoon is very heavy and chunky and crudely made. I only found one other spoon online reported to be from him with my spoon's hallmark, without photos or any other information. I would put a date on it circa 1810, please let me know if my guess is correct.

History of John Yates
http://www.pewterbank.com/James_Yates_-_revised_article.pdf
Similar Spoon on Ebay, though less crudely built and and with different handle and strange hallmark.
Great Antique pewter spoon-marked. part of collection John Yates [Y8-W6-A9-E8] | eBay
DSC_0614.JPGDSC_0609.JPGDSC_0597.JPGDSC_0600.JPGDSC_0596.JPGDSC_0607.JPGDSC_0604.JPG

Thanks for Looking, Coinman123
 

As an eBay Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Upvote 18
Congrats. Know nothing about spoons but definitely nicer than your average spoon find
 

Congrats on the location. Nice recovery of spoon. Love the research but it makes me wonder if it might be a relative of mine. I was adopted at six but my birth last name is yates. Interesting.......to say the least.
 

Cool find. Always fun when you can also "dig up" history on the item.
 

Outstanding find! Definitely an early 1800s style, but I've never seen one made from pewter, only silver. Very unique too with all the markings. Nice going!
 

Outstanding find! Definitely an early 1800s style, but I've never seen one made from pewter, only silver. Very unique too with all the markings. Nice going!

Thanks! I was surprised at first too, the fiddle style spoons I see are normally always silver or silver plated. I have found a complete silver fiddle and part of another, but never any pewter fiddles handles (this was my first complete spoon) until this one. To be honest I prefer my pewter one much more than my silver one, much more unique like you said. I'm going back there today, hopefully I will be able to retrieve more cool artifacts.
 

I know that this was posted a long time ago but I believe I found another one of yate's spoons. Very close to yours. I have found what I believe to be an old English Settler camp site. I thought so before I found this spoon and now I'm fairly confident.

Makers marks are "INo" "YA" "TR" "S"

Here are some pictures.
 

Attachments

  • 20230507_172222.jpg
    20230507_172222.jpg
    1.8 MB · Views: 24
  • 20230507_151749.jpg
    20230507_151749.jpg
    2.1 MB · Views: 26
  • 20230507_092107.jpg
    20230507_092107.jpg
    742.3 KB · Views: 25
The only problem that I have with this is that the "o" is a small o.

I found another example of a makers marks like this. The mark is "INe" and the goldsmiths name was John Neville. Which lead me to believe that I was looking for a J_______ No_____ named goldsmith.

Here's a picture of the example I mentioned.
 

Attachments

  • 20230507_181738.jpg
    20230507_181738.jpg
    1.6 MB · Views: 24
Congrats. I always enjoy finding tableware. I guess because it is a daily use item.
 

Using my recently made map of every pre-1850 abandoned homestead in my town, and each site's almost exact location on Google Earth, I have been at around 5 cellar holes (out of around 30 or so on my map). I have mainly just scouted them, not really metal detected, and a few have been hunted out for the most part. Today me and a friend went to one on my map, he did not have his pinpointer so I let him use mine, which was sadly out of battery. My friend for some reason won't dig without a pinpointer. I metal detected right next to the foundation and cellar hole. I also dug inside of it. On the side of the foundation I was overloaded with signals, I dug one non-iron signal and found a beautiful pewter spoon. I then dug a big iron signal and found a big bracket and copper spoon (probably once silver plated), in the same hole (along with a ton of window glass everywhere). I then moved to inside the cellar hole and got a high signal in the wall, the signal got worse then went away, making me guess it was a nail. I noticed a bottle one foot into the dirt of the cellar hole wall though, and was able to safely remove a 1963 Pepsi bottle without even chipping it. I am surprised by what it was doing in the dirt wall of the cellar, I am thinking that the disappearing signal may have been the cap of the Pepsi bottle. It was my 4th soda bottle this year (the others were a 1984 Pepsi Bottle, 1968 Coke Bottle, late 1970's bad condition Pepsi bottle (haven't grabbed it yet, found within minutes of the 1968 Coke seen while walking in woods)) I was happy to bring it home to try and clean it out, they look nice in windows. Also on the edge of the cellar hole I found a late 1800's ornate brass compact. Anyways, my friend said he got tons of beautiful high tones, but had trouble digging them without the pinpointer so he gave up on all of them except one signal where he recovered a mid-1800's bullet. We are going back out tomorrow, with pin pointers, wish us luck!

Makers marks on pewter spoon are "JNO" "YA" "TE" "S", "JNO" is short for John I read.
Here is the history of the pewter spoon. I haven't been able to ID the copper one but I saw some place saying the first symbol is an 1842 date mark. I found out that the pewter one was made by a pewter maker by the name of John Yates, of Birmingham England. In 1805 he was registered as a spoon maker, in 1823 he opened his permanent business location. Then in 1829 he partnered with other spoon makers Thomas Rawlins Birch and Lucasta Spooner (hallmark changed to Y B & S). In 1837 his son joined changing the name to John Yates and Son (some hallmarks are "J Y & SON"). John left in 1839, and died in 1876. The name "John Yates and Son stayed until the late 1800's and they became very wellknown in the trade. I am guessing that my spoon would be rather early in his career, at least before 1829. Most of his pre-1829 works say "JO" "HN" "YA" "TE" "S", without "JNO". I am guessing that this spoon would be made very early on, perhaps in his first ten years of work. It is very different than late 1800's electroplated spoons made by "John Yates and Son", my spoon is very heavy and chunky and crudely made. I only found one other spoon online reported to be from him with my spoon's hallmark, without photos or any other information. I would put a date on it circa 1810, please let me know if my guess is correct.

History of John Yates
http://www.pewterbank.com/James_Yates_-_revised_article.pdf
Similar Spoon on Ebay, though less crudely built and and with different handle and strange hallmark.
Great Antique pewter spoon-marked. part of collection John Yates [Y8-W6-A9-E8] | eBay
View attachment 1442716View attachment 1442717View attachment 1442718View attachment 1442719View attachment 1442720View attachment 1442721View attachment 1442722

Thanks for Looking, Coinman123
Nice!!! Congrats!!!
 

As an eBay Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Top Member Reactions

Users who are viewing this thread

Latest Discussions

Back
Top