Very Nice Large Cent :)

What should I do with the Large Cent?

  • Continue to let it soak?

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Leave it alone?

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Would be worth having cleaned, & slabbed?

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    0

Leon

Silver Member
Jul 2, 2004
3,836
24
Indy
Detector(s) used
Cz3d
Hello all,,,
I snuck back out to the cache site Tuesday evening for about an hour. Only dug one coin, but it was a good one. I had a solid high-tone showing a depth of 7" down on the Cz's meter. So. I cut a plug about that big around and a full knife blade in depth. After pulling the plug, I scanned it and nothing, so I scanned the hole and the signal was still there. I scooped out few more inches of dirt and a small hole opened up on one side of the hole I was digging. Not sure if it was part of a mole hole, or if it was made by a snake but the dirt started pouring down into it. As I was watching the dirt fall down the hole I noticed a pretty good size disc starting to head it's way down into it. I immediately put my fingers below the disc to try and catch it before it slipped down any farther. I caught it just in time. I'm not sure how deep the small hole on the bottom was, but I couldn't see the bottom of it and am not too sure if I could have ever dug deep enough to get the disc once it fell through. The disc turned out to be my 2nd Large Cent ever, an 1852 Braided Hair, and looks to be in great condition under all the black crud still stuck to it.
1852LC2.jpg

The pic shows the coin after soaking it in olive oil for about (45) minutes simply to get all the loose dirt off of it. The coin looks to have some great detail and a small amount of a nice green patina shinning through. The last "Large Cent" I found I rinsed with water, no scrubbing, and a lot of the patina seemed to come off of it, or was already gone, and I don't want to let this happen to this one, which brings me to my question for today...

1) Should I continue to let it soak in olive oil?
2) Should I leave it alone?
3) It would be worth having it professionally cleaned and slabbed?
Please cast your vote by using the poll at the top of the page, or leave a comment about what you think I should do with it. Thank you...

A few other hunts out with the "Indy Digs" at our new site this weekend also produced a few keepers. The first was a "1940 Washington Quarter" found at a depth of only 4" down. It's Pretty worn, but I'll take it. Also found (2) Roosevelt's, a 1946/D, and a 1957. Clarification: The 46/D is a mistake for this hunt. It was from a previous hunt and simply didn't get put away. :P
WashQ1940.jpg
Rosie46D2nd.jpg Rosie57.jpg

I have definitely had my fair share of good luck the last few months and I hope you all have had the same.
Good luck to all, & Happy hunting~
 

yo Leon

From the land of the Bluenose......a very pretty lady. had a date with her last summer on a dig at Fort Ellis. You yanks leave your coins everywhere...lol> Nice find sir.
 

I for one am not a fan of olive oil, but you have already started the process, so let it be. In the future you may wish to try Don of SJ's Hydrogen Peroxide treatment on copper. I have used it on all types of copper (including the large cent in my avatar) and the results are much better than olive oil. The only thing to be aware of when cleaning an old large cent is that the coin my look better with the crud on.

Here is the link to Don's post: http://forum.treasurenet.com/index.php/topic,39135.0.html
 

leave it alone

leave it alone

leave it alone

leave it alone

;)

Very nice find. ;D

have a good un.......
SHERMANVILLE
 

Very nice coin, It is pretty readable now, so I guess you have to be the judge.
 

What you should really do with it is send it to Mirage. He appreciates nice coins like that!
 

Leave it as is, why? Because it won't be worth any more after you clean it. If you clean it you will remove the beautiful patina associated with the years that it spent in hiding. Each old copper we dig will have it's own unique look; personally I think that makes a collection look really neat.
 

Almost all ground found Large Cents should be cleaned of the dirt and grime that coats the coin, if not, the corrosion will continue on and on. Almost all of us who find the Large Cents will keep them in our own personal collection, since most ground found Large Cents,especially the later years are not desired by the "Cigar box find" collectors.
So, make the coins as stable as you can, free from harmful moisture holding dirt, and use a good cleaning method to remove the dirt and protect the coin. There are many reasons to clean a Large Cent properly and not any reason to leave one coated in dirt and grime. Yes, there are Large Cents that will look crappier after cleaning, the reason, it was only the dirt holding the coin together, it was already destroyed by the fertilizer or acidic soil the coin was laying in. That is typical of coins found in heavily fertilized fields and low swampy areas. The coin is what it is, cleaning does not "ruin" the coin, the ground already did.

Again, I will show an old example of one that has been found with the coating of dirt and grime, than cleaned and preserved...............

Also attaching one that I found this spring that once the peroxide loosened up the dirt the coin was beautiful on the Obv and pretty good on the Reverse, althouth some corrosion there, I made sure the coin was thoroughly dried after I was done cleaning and then put a light coat of wax on it. Blue Ribbon Coin Conditioner also works well, if the surface of the coin is not peeling.

Leon, to answer the question of sending away, NO. :)

Don
 

Attachments

  • 1798red.gif
    1798red.gif
    248.3 KB · Views: 428
  • 1845 Coronet Head Large Cent2.jpg
    1845 Coronet Head Large Cent2.jpg
    75 KB · Views: 423
nice finds !! prob not slab worthy, but it's all yours now !! do as you will...... ;D ;D ;D ;D
 

I'll bet that hole was from a dead tree that had been eaten by termites, or just decomposed and disappeared. Those type holes can be way deep!

Congratulations on the last second save!

I hope the olive treatment helps. Remember. Even the non-dug LC's can look really dark in color.


Ridley
 

Thank you all for the great comments, and the participation in the poll... The votes say leave it alone and I know that's what they say about all coins, (Don't Clean Them). I just hate to still see all that dirt/grit left on there...

Don in SJ, You make a very good point and it has me torn between cleaning it, or not. I will probably never sell it, but I do plan on leaving it to my nephew one of these days, and don't want to ruin it for him... I guess any dug coin will have to be cleaned sooner, or later, and I have already started the process, as "Neil in West Jersey" has stated, but...

Ed-NH, makes a very good point as well...
so... I'm still not sure what I'm going to do with this one...

Ridley, I never thought of it being left from a tree, or a root from a tree, but that's a good possibility... I know I was very reluctant to stick my fingers down in there, but I wasn't about to let it get away from me... ;D

Thanks again all, & Happy hunting~
 

Loved the story, Leon! Glad you caught that coin in time! :o I'd probably leave it in oil for another week or so, and see. But just me. :) Awesome finds! You have had a great summer for hunting! 8)

Congrats!!! Nana :)
 

great find Leon! i`ll tell ya how i approach the whole cleaning thing. if i can ID and date the coin i usually just leave it be.rinse it in water for sure, maybe a soak in olive oil if the details are really hard to see, but i save electrolysis and hard scrubbing to those coins that are pretty much slugs. and even then, cleaning them only works sometimes. as was already stated a lot of the time a good cleaning makes them worse. i am curious about the peroxide method because the results look awesome. ill have to give it a try sometime. anyway, great find !!
 

Sweet coin, I'd leave it alone.
 

Hi my name is matt and as stated in a previous message I own a local coin and pawn shop so im not one of those people that will give you false info. An 1852 large cent cent in G4 which is Good goes for about $20 buck that was an awsome find. As far as the whole olive oil or the baking soda and vinager fizzing solution yes they do clean the coin somewhat only to an extent and what people dont realize is that when you think the coin is as clean as it can be and you take it out and wash it off the oil has soaked in the coin and over time will corroed again.
I have such a love for coins that if you will send me your address I will send you a cleaning solution and two coin cleaning brushing along with a magazine on where to order these products from. Just remember that when you ever clean a coin in always decreases the value ;)
please let me know if you want these solutions
 

Top Member Reactions

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top