UPDATE: Indian Manitou Bust find !

Pa.Billy

Full Member
May 10, 2008
161
12
Indiana Co. Pa......... finds include,confedera
Detector(s) used
Garrett 2500
UPDATE: I took a trip down to Fort Ligonier Museum today, it's only about an half hour from my place. Beforehand I arranged by
phone to meet with the museum curator there, Brad Mooney, he also works part time as historical restoration specialist of
Heritage Restorations in Ligonier, he's the owner of this company. He told me he has 35 years of experience in local
archeology. He looked at the stone and said within 10 seconds that the groove that continued almost 3/4 of the way around
the stone was shaped by man and not naturally occurring. He could not say that any other part of the stone was shaped by man
nor could he say it wasn't, his focus for the 10 minute inspection was on grooved section. He could not say who shaped it
but when I told him exactly where I found it (cairn, a man made pile of rocks)and I suggested the groove was the neck he
shook his head and said most likely the best scenario. You connect the dots, worked stone on top of a cairn pile, looks
like it could be a native American,plenty of other stone placement in the area characteristic of indian activity.....
I asked him if he would make a YouTube video on the spot there and he said "yes I would mind" I then asked him if I could
quote him and he said why? I told him some internet forums was dismissing the post because it was without very
much merit because it did not appear to be worked, he said "get used to it"
Within 200 yards of this cairn is numerous rock piles, most with unmistakable tell tale signs of
native American stone placement such as videos below which show a probable non-worked
Manitou stone (left) in the first video with a unmistakable niche (rock propping up another rock)
right beside it, all this on a 15 ft wide cairn or rock pile.
The second video is more Indian rock structure building, note what looks like a headstone
almost in the first part of the video and then a series of large rocks placed in a row.
BradMooneyFortLigonier.jpg


ManitouBustVerticleBBB7-10-11.jpg


This is one of 2 large 4-5 ft high
"Standing Stones" found on opposite hillsides facing a burial ground. The closet one to
the manitou bust is only about 2 tenth of a mile away as the crow flies. I point these large standing to show
that these cairns don't exist in a vacuum

StandingStone_Bill5-22-11.jpg


unworked manitou stone (left) and niche (right)






I've been searching this area behind my uncles place since I found rock piles there on April 24th. I've been exploring the place 3-4 times a week to try and stay ahead of loggers who look ready to descend on the land in a matter of weeks or months. This was found laying on top of a cairn, sort of upside down. It weighs in at 35 pounds (looks like there's some iron ore in it) and stands 11 1/2 inches high.
Here is the video below of the initial find 2 days ago,at the time I mistook the flatter back side to be the front but it obviously is not.

ManitouBustFound7-6-11.jpg


 

Upvote 0
Re: Indian Manitou Bust find !

hikeinmts said:
I wouldn't know an Indian Manitou if it jumped out of the bushes and bit me.
ALL THE SAME, that looks like an interesting piece of rock.......and the weight might be being made by the vein of
whatever ore is going from top to bottom.
I am interested in knowing what an Indian manitou is......
Good hunting, and way to keep your eyes open. :thumbsup:

The Manitou is of the Spirit. ALL of the Creators creations have a Manitou. It is the Spirit of the tree, the rock, fire, clouds and the storm. And of course, man.

I agree that the rock looks like it was formed by intention. It was probalby made and placed there to honor a particular Spirit (Manitou) either asking for the Spirits help or in thanks for help already recieved. It was also found in an area that would make it likely to be intentional.

If you want to know more about Manitou, go to Wikipedia and type "Manitou" into the search bar.

Great find, though I wouldn't have been inclined to move it myself. :laughing7: Sometimes, it's better to take pictures of finds of a Spiritual nature and leave the artifact there. But...........

Eagle
 

Re: Indian Manitou Bust find !

Pa. Billy can you explain to me what a native American prayer niche is? Also do you have any reference to another stone on the internet or in books you could show us to compare to? The only examples I can find have pictographs or petroglyphs on them. It seems you are very convinced of what this is but I can not find any reference to this type of artifact. Thanks
 

Re: Indian Manitou Bust find !

ynpto804 said:
Pa. Billy can you explain to me what a native American prayer niche is? Also do you have any reference to another stone on the internet or in books you could show us to compare to? The only examples I can find have pictographs or petroglyphs on them. It seems you are very convinced of what this is but I can not find any reference to this type of artifact. Thanks

here's a couple of sites below to explore. I have some experts helping me evaluate this area I'm exploring. It's been described to me a very sophisticated and a rare site. Here is a video I made of what they call a prayer niche,their words. I'm actually marginally on the naturally occurring side in this instance but I'm not sure by any means. A prayer niche was used to make offerings to the gods,whether it be tobacco,corn water,acorns,water etc. The higher the value the higher up it would be placed on the prayer niche stones.
http://www.stonestructures.org/index.html

http://rockpiles.blogspot.com/

 

Re: Indian Manitou Bust find !

I've never even seen the word manitou before. I'm not really in an area that I would find indian rocks though.

I mean it's pretty neat though? :dontknow:
 

Re: Indian Manitou Bust find !

I'll give Billy an A+ on imagination. I must admit tho that that is an unusually shaped rock.
 

Re: Indian Manitou Bust find !

The Manitou is of the Spirit. ALL of the Creators creations have a Manitou. It is the Spirit of the tree, the rock, fire, clouds and the storm. And of course, man.

I agree that the rock looks like it was formed by intention. It was probalby made and placed there to honor a particular Spirit (Manitou) either asking for the Spirits help or in thanks for help already recieved. It was also found in an area that would make it likely to be intentional.

If you want to know more about Manitou, go to Wikipedia and type "Manitou" into the search bar.

Great find, though I wouldn't have been inclined to move it myself. :laughing7: Sometimes, it's better to take pictures of finds of a Spiritual nature and leave the artifact there. But...........

Eagle
[/quote]

This is a really Great Man!!! :notworthy: :notworthy: :notworthy: :notworthy: I believe him 100% :notworthy: :notworthy: :notworthy:
 

Re: Indian Manitou Bust find !

UPDATE: I took a trip down to Fort Ligonier Museum today, it's only about an half hour from my place. Beforehand I arranged by
phone to meet with the museum curator there, Brad Mooney, he also works part time as historical restoration specialist of
Heritage Restorations in Ligonier, he's the owner of this company. He told me he has 35 years of experience in local
archeology. He looked at the stone and said within 10 seconds that the groove that continued almost 3/4 of the way around
the stone was shaped by man and not naturally occurring. He could not say that any other part of the stone was shaped by man
nor could he say it wasn't, his focus for the 10 minute inspection was on grooved section. He could not say who shaped it
but when I told him exactly where I found it (cairn, a man made pile of rocks)and I suggested the groove was the neck he
shook his head and said most likely the best scenario. You connect the dots, worked stone on top of a cairn pile, looks
like it could be a native American,plenty of other stone placement in the area characteristic of indian activity.....
I asked him if he would make a YouTube video on the spot there and he said "yes I would mind" I then asked him if I could
quote him and he said why? I told him some internet forums was dismissing the post because it was without very
much merit because it did not appear to be worked, he said "get used to it"
Within 200 yards of this cairn is numerous rock piles, most with unmistakable tell tale signs of
native American stone placement such as videos below which show a probable non-worked
Manitou stone (left) in the first video with a unmistakable niche (rock propping up another rock)
right beside it, all this on a 15 ft wide cairn or rock pile.
The second video is more Indian rock structure building, note what looks like a headstone
almost in the first part of the video and then a series of large rocks placed in a row.
BradMooneyFortLigonier.jpg


ManitouBustVerticleBBB7-10-11.jpg


This is one of 2 large 4-5 ft high
"Standing Stones" found on opposite hillsides facing a burial ground. The closet one to
the manitou bust is only about 2 tenth of a mile away as the crow flies. I point these large standing to show
that these cairns don't exist in a vacuum

StandingStone_Bill5-22-11.jpg


unworked manitou stone (left) and niche (right)


 

Re: Indian Manitou Bust find !

I need to say this, IMO this is clearly worthy of the banner,how many worked 35 pound, foot high native American artifacts in the profile image of a native American are left to be found in the northeast ? The only thing standing in the way of that is a lack of knowledge on the subject and a lack of understanding of the environment it was found in. I'm not speaking a foreign language when I say prayer niches,standing stones,manitou stones and cairns. I could say maybe I failed to show the evidence but the video does it justice,you don't need to look real closely to see a groove almost 3/4 of the way around the stone. It may be very crudely done as the museum curator mentioned but the important thing it was done. On the other hand about 80% of the people who saw it in person feels it's been worked and the other 20% had no opinion so maybe the video didn't illustrate it well to some extent.
 

If the curator had confirmed it was a manitou you would have made the banner.......but he didn't. :dontknow:
 

Most people here are looking for metal and not so much rocks. IMO. Most but not all.
Its just a cool rock to me whether it was created by mother nature or man or aliens?
Maybe its better that some people don't know what it is (me included) because then if they did start finding them they would just become paperweights on joe blows desk instead of being behind glass in a museum.

Is it banner… probably.
Especially if its rare and real and such. I mean it seems to be confusing enough people so that would confirm its rarity in a way.
Treasure Net is not the end all be all of great finds my friend . I'm sure some native american experts would love to put you in an article if this is as important as you say it is… maybe we'll see you in National Geographic who knows right?

I mean I could come on here and say I had the holy grail and everyone would just laugh no matter how many pictures i showed or videos.
The problem of being super rare!

I'm intrigued. Your making a lot of people feel dumb and thats good. You've inspired me to brush up on native american culture and customs/artifacts etc. and for that I thank you.

I wish you the best with this one.
 

lookindown said:
If the curator had confirmed it was a manitou you would have made the banner.......but he didn't. :dontknow:

i didn't tell him I found it in a cairn,i used the generic "woods" at first,i started to tell him in detail but by that time we had reached my car and that line of the conversation ended You can't connect the dots ? You think it was made by someone other then native American ? What are the odds ? No,I don't think I would have made it anyways......
 

underarock said:
Most people here are looking for metal and not so much rocks. IMO. Most but not all.
Its just a cool rock to me whether it was created by mother nature or man or aliens?
Maybe its better that some people don't know what it is (me included) because then if they did start finding them they would just become paperweights on joe blows desk instead of being behind glass in a museum.

Is it banner… probably.
Especially if its rare and real and such. I mean it seems to be confusing enough people so that would confirm its rarity in a way.
Treasure Net is not the end all be all of great finds my friend . I'm sure some native american experts would love to put you in an article if this is as important as you say it is… maybe we'll see you in National Geographic who knows right?

I mean I could come on here and say I had the holy grail and everyone would just laugh no matter how many pictures i showed or videos.
The problem of being super rare!

I'm intrigued. Your making a lot of people feel dumb and thats good. You've inspired me to brush up on native american culture and customs/artifacts etc. and for that I thank you.

I wish you the best with this one.

thanks,I feel really stoked this evening,it is a rare find I believe.
 

I have read all the responses to this thread. I have to agree with some. I don't see anything, but beauty is in the eye of the beholder.

My problem is with this. From reading the thread these were sacred for some reason or another. Whether for prayer, recognition of the dead or otherwise. Why not leave them alone?

Just as ethical metal detectorists do not dig in graveyards, or pull icons off churches, I think we should extend those courtesies to other cultures. You wouldn't want people taking parts of your local church or temple home would you?

We have plenty of other opportunities for "treasure" elsewhere.

My 2¢

J~
 

upstatejay said:
I have read all the responses to this thread. I have to agree with some. I don't see anything, but beauty is in the eye of the beholder.

My problem is with this. From reading the thread these were sacred for some reason or another. Whether for prayer, recognition of the dead or otherwise. Why not leave them alone?

Just as ethical metal detectorists do not dig in graveyards, or pull icons off churches, I think we should extend those courtesies to other cultures. You wouldn't want people taking parts of your local church or temple home would you?

We have plenty of other opportunities for "treasure" elsewhere.

My 2¢

I plan on returning the item to the place I found it in a few days,when this heat wave is over. There are many cairns here,hard to tell what is a burial one and what is simply a marker of some sort, be it possibly a boundary marker. I think the great majority are not burial ones though.

I plan on returning the item to the place I found it in a few days,when this heat wave is over. There are many cairns here,hard to tell what is a burial one and what is simply a marker of some sort, be it possibly a boundary marker. I think the great majority are not burial ones though.
 

Top Member Reactions

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top