Rishar:
How about listing them so we all know what to watch out for!
Was the story incorrect, or perhaps the map location was a bit off? Frank
Since you asked nicely, I'll play. I'll address the Kitsap entry, as that's where I live and that's what I'm most familiar with.
KITSA COUNTY (Wrong. It's "Kitsap" County, but that's probably just a spelling error. However, getting the name of the county wrong does not bode well for the rest of it.)
92. NEAR GT: Port Gamble, 5 miles NW Kingston, was a bustling lumber and mill town founded in 1853. (Basically correct. There were a few other bustling lumber and mill towns from the same era in the county but he missed those, which tells me that he didn't read the book from the county historical society - never mind the more obscure oral histories.)
93. GT: Vinland, on Hood Canal...(No, Vinland wasn't a ghost town.)
94. GT: Bangor, on Hood Canal...(It was a village at one point, sort of, but the Navy bought it all in WWII, bulldozed it, and built a base there. As this is the sort of base that may or may not store nuclear weapons, and Bangor was located on the lower side where all the security is, it's basically off limits. I have access to the area and I'm reluctant to go wandering around the woods down there due to the security measures in place. I have a few interesting stories about this area that I can share, but they're not treasure-related and this isn't the thread for them. And yes, it was the sort of base that may or may not have stored nuclear weapons in 1985, so this is not a case of the book simply being outdated. It was most likely just very superficial research, which is actually a forgivable sin for a work of this scope.)
95. GT: Port Madison, on Puget Sound...(No, it's not a ghost town. It's very much a live town. I'm pretty sure that the important parts are on the rez as well, so that's a bit of a complication if you don't know any of the natives.)
96. GT: Port Blakely, 2 miles S Winslow...(Again, basically correct, but not feasible to hunt for a variety of reasons. Admittedly things were different in 1985.)
97. GT: Nellita, on Hood Canal...(No.)
98. GT: Reedville, 5 miles E Belfair...(Never heard of it but I'm familiar with the area, and probably no.)
99. GT: Olalia, on S county line...(It's Ollala, and no, it's not a ghost town.)
Treasure tales he missed that are in no way secrets around here, and while I can't prove any of them are true, I haven't been able to disprove them either:
- Ah Fong's gold. It may just be a fairy tale, but it's a fairy tale that's been around for well over a century...not long after Ah Fong disappeared, actually.
- Linda Hazzard's buried loot at Starvation Heights. Google it. It's a fascinating story - Hazzard and her facility, not the loot...the loot is merely speculation, but it's known that she talked people into willing all of their stuff to her before starving them to death, so it's not beyond the realm of possibility that there were more deaths (and more money) than what was written down. It's probably a moot point though. She spent basically everything that she had leading up to her death, and her husband doubtless spent the rest of it on booze (vanilla extract was his weapon of choice) after her death. It was certainly not buried in the gully behind the house, as that's where they threw their trash and it's not a nice climb to get down there. Hell, maybe that is where it was, now that I think about it.)
- Mines in the area, primarily around Gold and Green Mountains. These are poorly documented. You'd need boots on the ground to even know that these exist, so he can be given a pass for missing this. I've located a few of them and I have no idea what the miners were looking for...as I said, they're poorly documented, and none of the old-timers know what they were for either.
- Historical gold strikes. No mention at all. They are documented and the old-timers remember them. The old-timers in 1985 would have had firsthand knowledge. I know where the placers were but not were the lode was; if someone found it, it wasn't written down. The map tells all, but I'll let someone else do the panning. Mr. Terry is not the guy to tell you where to look.
- Not a treasure tale, but definitely a ghost town of sorts: the lumber town that used to be in what's now called Manette, but hell, only someone who researched local history would know about that one. Most of the locals don't even know about that. It was mentioned in the county historical society's book, so it's not completely off the radar.
This isn't really a treasure tale, but it's kind of a ghost town: Mission Lake. It's named as such because back in the middle of the 19th century, there was supposedly a mission nearby that was founded to convert the natives. As the story goes, something (disease is normally mentioned, with smallpox being the disease normally named) wiped out enough of the missionaries that the mission became unsustainable, so they went back east. Local lore has it that the building was used as an informal hunting lodge by the local yokels right up into the early twentieth century before it burned down. I wouldn't expect to find a treasure trove there, but that would be an interesting spot to swing a coil over. Is it even real though? If you know where to look, there are a few properties on the lake that have old plum trees not from this area. Given the stories (both written and oral) and the other circumstantial evidence, I think that it did exist and I'm pretty sure that I know where it was. No mention in the book, of course. Vinland (which was never a town, but merely a place name for an area) was apparently far more interesting.
I've got some other stuff but hell, I've said plenty already. In this particular case, the KITSA...err, Kitsap entry is not even a good starting point for further research in most cases. One would do far better by tracking down a copy of the historical society's book, and possibly the Bremerton and PSNS books as well. There are a few more that are worth reading but they're referenced in the ones that I've mentioned. After that, it's newspapers and diaries.
As for the other counties, I haven't spent enough time on them to comment one way or the other, but a quick glance through the neighboring counties produced some probable errors. The Mason County section lists a number of ghost towns that are not and never were ghost towns, and I slapped my head when I saw the bit about John Turnow in Grays Harbor County. To be fair to Mr. Terry in the latter case, many of the locals will tell you the same damned story if you ask them, as few of the people who repeat treasure tales are inclined to research them at all. The evidence was available in 1985 though, so he doesn't get a complete pass on this.
So yeah, mistakes were made, at least as far as they pertain to my little area of the world. The other stuff may be better.