The Best Metal Detector

aupro

Newbie
Dec 29, 2008
3
0
Astoria, Oregon
Detector(s) used
Garrett Infinium LS
I have seen on many forums the request for information or recommendation for the "best" metal detector for a particular purpose. Most of the time its for hunting gold, since that's the forums I frequent. I am always amused at the replies because for the most part people recommend what they are using - obviously that was the best choice for them.
I had a few thoughts that were a little different, because I feel that the best detector is the one that suits the user. The first consideration is price. Gold detectors generally run between $500 (used) to $5000.00 Most of us need to throw this into the equation. So I would recommend that someone considering a purchase list the various models in order by price and then figure out what your upper limit is. The next step I would take is to download all the manual from the manufactures web sites and read them. Its funny I've never seen anyone recommend this! For the most part the manuals have the details of the operation of the detections and believe me they can vary quite a bit. I really think, you can get a good feel for a machine and its operation by what the manual has to say. There are features that one unit may have that another does not and the buyer needs to match these up with what he wants. Yes Virginia there is a learning curve.
Lastly try to find someone in the area you want to detect in and find out what the soil conditions are in the area you will be using it. Conditions in a particular field in Arizona may not be good for the California Gold Belt and vice versa. I would also consider talking to a dealer in the area for the most part they should know the condition that particular areas have, if not find another dealer. Also once you've read the manual you will be able to see real models at the various dealers you visit, and you can made some judgements about the quality of one detector over another. Most dealers love to talk about their product and you might learn more that you ever wanted to know.
Well i'm getting off the soapbox now and i'll end with a good luck wish for finding the best detector, and I hope you search was as enjoyable as mine have been.
 

Upvote 0
I have the answer for you . The best metal detector ........ drum roll please .......... is the one you're swinging right now . I have seen so many guys (newbees) agonize over which one to buy . They lose precious time worrying about a ton of stuff . Get one , a cheapie if you must and get out there . As your skill exceeds the machine you will feel justified in upgrading . It is better to outgrow a Bounty Hunter than to be unhappy with the hobby with a Minelab 4500 (and the payments) in your hand .
 

The next step I would take is to download all the manual from the manufactures web sites and read them. Its funny I've never seen anyone recommend this! For the most part the manuals have the details of the operation of the detections and believe me they can vary quite a bit. I really think, you can get a good feel for a machine and its operation by what the manual has to say.

I think this is really good advice. I've been looking at the difference between the Garret and Whites models recently and just reading the BROCHURES has been very enlightening! I can't imagine what reading the manuals would divulge about the differences between the units.

As for everyone recommending their own machine that is probably human nature. People want to affirm their own purchase decisions. I've done the same thing. I'm a complete newbie and I'm swinging a BH Tracker IV. It seems great and I'd definitely recommend one for a beginner who is cost conscious. But I haven't found silver yet (I've only been out three times so far so it's far too early to guage my success) and I can't help but wonder if I ever will. That's the odd thing about metal detecting. You really never know what you are missing. The only way to know is if someone with a different unit walks along behind you and is picking up stuff you didn't detect. And how many of us get that luxury?

Most of us (including myself) are blissfully unaware of all of the great stuff we could be missing.
 

The best detector to have is the one you can afford at the time and are willing to LEARN!

All detectors will find coins, jewelry, relics, and other stuff, some will detect deeper and others will have more bells and whistles.

The main thing is to get started within your budget and then decide from there. I started with a 4th or 5th hand RS special and 12+ years later I'm now using a "toy" Bounty Hunter (Quick Draw II) as some call it. It finds the goods and I have a great time. Is it the best out there, nope, but it works for me.

So, IMO, the best MD you can buy is the one you can go get tomorrow without going into debt so you can start swinging.

Grip
 

I would like to add one more tip in making a decision. I included manual reading in my research. I must have been from Missouri in a past life because I was thoroughly confused by some of them. I needed someone to "show me". I found that videos helped me a lot in choosing the right detector for me. I started with my price range to narrow the field cuz there is a buttload of detectors out there. Once I was down to just a few, I searched for videos that dealt with how to use them and what features they have. Some manufacturers, like White's and Minelab, have some very good ones on their sites.

Disclaimer - I do not mean any offense to our friends in the great state of Missouri. I was just borrowing their state motto.
 

Aupro

The best metal detector is the one that holds up well and works the best for each individual. The best overall for me is my Fisher cz-70, but I'll take my Compass GoldScanner Pro if nugget hunting is also in the plans .

I've been at this game since 1973. Worked in detector design in the early 80's (manufacturer not disclosed), and repaired detectors for 20+ years. Retired 5 years ago. I built my very first two first detectors. I didn't buy them.

I'm an Oregonian too. We have some real nasty soil here and it's even worse on some of the Washington coastal beaches, especially up near the Quilliute and Quinault Indian Reservation. Newberg though has really mild soil where even an old BFO works fairly well.

The most popular and best detector in the entire world for fine gold is the Fisher GoldBug2. It's also the most prefered in Oregon for fine gold. I live in gold country. Even the owners of the local multi-brand detector sales shop here in Sweet Home prefer it to all other brands, both in Oregon and in Arizona too. The old Compass au52 and au2000 are equal to the Fishers in performance and the Compass au2000 utilizes both a 52 Khz (OR) 14.77 Khz at a flip of a switch. They are really hard to find though and bring a normal price of around $350. Keith Wills (best metal detector repairman in the world) of East Texas Metal detectors gets one in now and then.

The deepest and most refined detector for larger nuggets is White's new TDI. It is one mean POWERHOUSE! You can tell Todd at White's home office that I said so too! It has the best discrimination of any hand-held pulse detector ever made. Erik Foster (the Father of PI detector technology) created it for/with White's. How could White's ever go wrong with such a deal?

Hope this helps.

Larry
 

Reading the brochures and manuals does give a lot of information. However, when I was researching for a new detector, I got brochure overload.
One nice feature of the Kellyco web site is that i9t allows you to compare various detectors and their bells and whistles side by side. This helped me a lot
 

Top Member Reactions

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top