Season 9

[Singlestack Wonder]

Giving them the benefit of the doubt that the metalurgy science was not "made for TV", lets consider. The lead from a bale seal was found to come from a mine in France and later found on territory formerly called "New France" (now N.E. Canada) and once occupied by the French from 1534 to 1763 is a surprise . . . why?

Seals had unique marks for a purpose. Someone should pretty easily be able to identify who's mark is on the seal and a relative time period. Again, did they consult a "real" archeologist? I doubt it.

Lead Seals | Historic Jamestowne

Visit the real thing at Historic Jamestowne, explore the actual location and active archaeological dig, Jamestown Rediscovery, home of the first successful English settlement.

historicjamestowne.org

Here's one found in Jamestown, VA.

But aren't you going against the standard narrative proposed here by the typical suspects that everything found on the island has to be templar related?

I fear that soon the excavator will fall into the space-time warp tunnel to Mars at the bottom of the money pit that some here said the templars used to travel there to safeguard the treasure.

Then again, the excavator could break thru and fall into Harold Wilkin's hollow earth area that some here believe exists.

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

A Handbook of Civil War Bullets and Cartridges - Grab it through Amazon!

[gazzahk]

Last nights show turned up some interesting test results.The lead bag seal (found last year at oak island) has been Laser Ablation tested.The test show the seal was made from lead mined in the South of France(the Same area the lead cross was tested as coming from).Also the same area of France that was a Templar Stronghold.

You leave out... That this lead found in the "stained glass cabinet" on the grounds of Smiths old cottage was identified as from the same place.... Does this mean the Templar's brought over their stained glass cabinets...

Skowronek concludes his presentation by revealing that “the lead isotope data from [the Lot 21 artifact is] identical to [that] of the cross… That means that both pieces probably come from the same ore deposit…

What they have shown is lead from this source was common on Oak Island and not treasure related.

They conveniently forget to mention that every time they refer to the cross...

 

[freeman]

The look you have when you know nothing is there but have to listen to some BS made up about FDR's boot being handed out to the Boss by the show's researcher.

The look you have as the Boss knowing everyone is watching to see what you do as the researcher hands you BS on camera.

The look you have when the Boss buys into the BS instead of just admitting nothing is there.

 

[Ocean7]

The look you have when you know nothing is there but have to listen to some BS made up about FDR's boot being handed out to the Boss by the show's researcher...

Now that is really funny!

 

[HunterNC]

So what do you make of this taken from the last image of Tuesday's episode? Looks modern but interesting they ended the episode on it without saying anything. Looks kind of like the base of a flood tunnel.

 

[HunterNC]

and yes, the show has gone to completely to crap. The good news is I can watch an episode in about 5 minutes so it is not a complete waste of time.

 

[Charlie P. (NY)]

Looks like the wood pads they lay down for heavy equipment to work on muddy ground - like Dunfield and Trition would have laid down in the 1960's.

 

[MikeN]

The look you have when you know nothing is there but have to listen to some BS made up about FDR's boot being handed out to the Boss by the show's researcher.


View attachment 2010765View attachment 2010766View attachment 2010767View attachment 2010768

The look you have as the Boss knowing everyone is watching to see what you do as the researcher hands you BS on camera.

View attachment 2010769

The look you have when the Boss buys into the BS instead of just admitting nothing is there.

View attachment 2010771View attachment 2010772

It couldn't be FDR's boot because he always wears white tennis shoes in the Oak Island picture.

 

[MikeN]

There's a new Digging Down episode after next week's COI episode. The DD will be a recap.

I needed a review , so I fast forwarded through the digging down episode. But the ender was mildly interesting , where Rick and Marty examined everything on a timeline.

 

[CaptainChance]

For the first time, I find myself fast-forwarding through the recorded episodes. If you watch carefully, you can see the wood has already been ripped / splintered apart, likely when Dunfield tore everything up down to 140 feet and threw the debris back into the pit.

 

[Ocean7]

strange things are afoot and OI. Last week they added 2 more episodes and this week 1 more appeared in numerical count for the season. Could it be this will be the last season?
I'm amazed how they can have a woman tell them that the great bale seal is possibly 'Treasury of England' last week and they all seem to agree knowingly. Then this week they drive a very long distance to see 'two scientists' who tell them lead is from France and they work their favorite depositors, 'The Templars' back into the theory of equations. If they're going to show us another recap of the redundancy of the 'redundancy dept. of IO series' - then at least show us all timeline of all the many theorists who have appeared in the War room and on Zoom, absolutely sure their theory was correct. Then have a contest for the wackiest theory ever spawned by this show. 1st prize will be a squeegee, for the one who seemed closest to foaming at the mouth, when disagreed with over their theory on this forum. LOL

 

[gazzahk]

Zena wins the wackiest for my money with her "theory" their piece of cross shaped lead sinker was an ancient piece of jewelry to the Goddess Tanit...

The Maritime Goddess Tanit on Oak Island

Zena Halpern was mentioned again on the Curse of Oak Island – this time regarding a discovery of a lead “cross.” Zena thinks it’s Tanit.

zenahalpern.com

Actually Zena wins my vote for having the most (by volume) wackiest theories on everything to do with OI.

As for the biggest liars/frauds I would vote for the guy who had the "Roman" Sword (closely followed by the Lagina crew for their claim of finding the 90 foot stone in the old bookshop when it had been widely discussed that they had purchased it from a collector at least 12 months earlier)

For the most stupid/ridiculous assumption of origin it would go to the "expert" that claimed the old Canadian Gigging spear prong was a Roman Phalanx spear point.

 

[Ocean7]

Zena wins the wackiest for my money with her "theory" their piece of cross shaped lead sinker was an ancient piece of jewelry to the Goddess Tanit...

yeah surprised she didn't claim an Egyptian Ankh Cross and the Egyptians. Of course, it couldn't possibly be a Christian cross worn by so many of the Spaniards and other obvious European groups.
Still 'the map' and 'the hatch' might win a prize for the best 'Lovejoy' piece ever seen on the show.

 

[BennyV]

yeah surprised she didn't claim an Egyptian Ankh Cross and the Egyptians. Of course, it couldn't possibly be a Christian cross worn by so many of the Spaniards and other obvious European groups.
Still 'the map' and 'the hatch' might win a prize for the best 'Lovejoy' piece ever seen on the show.

The Hatch. It had me going for a minute then it faded into oblivion like the rest of the “leads”.

Also, I liked the guy that came on and claimed that sandbar of an island next to Oak Island, and which he owned, had a vault underneath it with 50 tons of gold. 🤣🤣🤣

 

[1637]

i think the wackiest part of the show is the people on this site that hates everything about the show and would never watch it, but waste allot of time on this site talking about it.

 

[Singlestack Wonder]

i think the wackiest part of the show is the people on this site that hates everything about the show and would never watch it, but waste allot of time on this site talking about it.

Protecting the unknowing masses from becoming duped like so many others by the long history of oak island hoaxers….

 

[BennyV]

i think the wackiest part of the show is the people on this site that hates everything about the show and would never watch it, but waste allot of time on this site talking about it.

I actually liked the show for a long time lol

 

[Charlie P. (NY)]

i think the wackiest part of the show is the people on this site that hates everything about the show and would never watch it, but waste allot of time on this site talking about it.

My wife won't let me watch it anymore. She's afraid I'll shoot the TV whenever the narrator speaks. She's likely correct.

 

[Kate~ScienceNerd]

Zena wins the wackiest for my money with her "theory" their piece of cross shaped lead sinker was an ancient piece of jewelry to the Goddess Tanit...

The Maritime Goddess Tanit on Oak Island

Zena Halpern was mentioned again on the Curse of Oak Island – this time regarding a discovery of a lead “cross.” Zena thinks it’s Tanit.

zenahalpern.com

Actually Zena wins my vote for having the most (by volume) wackiest theories on everything to do with OI.

As for the biggest liars/frauds I would vote for the guy who had the "Roman" Sword (closely followed by the Lagina crew for their claim of finding the 90 foot stone in the old bookshop when it had been widely discussed that they had purchased it from a collector at least 12 months earlier)

For the most stupid/ridiculous assumption of origin it would go to the "expert" that claimed the old Canadian Gigging spear prong was a Roman Phalanx spear point.

The fraud was that guy Pulitzer. A close second is the "respected antiquities expert" they brought in to evaluate the McGinnis family's gold cross, who in reality is Dr Lori, a television personality and appraiser with her own stage show, "Dr. Lori's Antiques Appraisal Comedy Show." I still don't understand why the Laginas let some of these idiots onto the show.

I'm nominating that GPS expert, Erin, as most delusional. She came with a lot of studies pinpointing boulders and other markers on the island and correlating them with Zena's map, then the second or third time she was on, she started frantically drawing random lines at random angles all over her maps, trying to prove I don't know what, after convincing Marty to blow more money drilling a bunch of pointless holes.

IF there were actually a treasure somewhere on the island, you'd never know it from all the drivel on the show.

 

[MikeN]

I'm nominating that GPS expert, Erin, as most delusional. She came with a lot of studies pinpointing boulders and other markers on the island and correlating them with Zena's map, then the second or third time she was on, she started frantically drawing random lines at random angles all over her maps, trying to prove I don't know what, after convincing Marty to blow more money drilling a bunch of pointless holes.

Erin's star student is on here in another thread continuing the geometry lesson.