old "for prisedent" thingy

[whitesid]

old "for prisedent" thingy

i found this at an extremly old site. on the one side it say for priesident and looks like a picture of someone in a civil war uniform. anyone know what this could be and the value?
-whitesid

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

How to Research for Treasure Hunting and Metal Detecting From Lead Generation to Vetting - Grab it through Amazon!

[Montana Jim]

Re: old "for prisedent" thingy

George McCellen also ran in 1864... maybe??

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

Agony and Death on a Gold Rush Steamer: The Disastrous Sinking of the Side-Wheeler Yankee Blade - Grab it through Amazon!

[Digginman]

Re: old "for prisedent" thingy

Would the shoulder insignia date it any better. Aluminum + Insignia + ??

DM

 

[Gypsy Heart]

Re: old "for prisedent" thingy

Who ever this is ...they have a very distinctive moustache....I dont think men change the shape of their mustaches much ...so need to use that as a clue

Can you make a rubbing of the badge? I would like to see where you are getting 'Castle "

 

[PBK]

Re: old "for prisedent" thingy

Okay, since I mentioned the (probably quite remote) possibility that it might be related to the 1900 "Draft Dewey" presidential nomination fervor, here's Admiral George Dewey, hero of the Spanish-American War, moustache and shoulder straps and all:

(But let's stop before we get to Groucho Marx and Yosemite Sam! )

 

[Digginman]

Re: old "for prisedent" thingy

I think you've nailed it, PBK. I've been looking at pics for an hour, yours is the closest. Kind of hard to tell with the corrosion on the piece.

DM

 

[PBK]

Re: old "for prisedent" thingy

I think you've nailed it, PBK. I've been looking at pics for an hour, yours is the closest. Kind of hard to tell with the corrosion on the piece.

DM

I don't know, DM. I'm not ready to say that's who it is. I just mentioned Dewey as someone who looked similar and was sought as a candidate in 1900. There are, of course, tons of Dewey patriotic badges, medals, etc. from 1898, and those are what led me to make the comparison. Anyway, as you say, there is a definite resemblance.

 

[Montana Jim]

Re: old "for prisedent" thingy

Sorry... could not let it go! I think Dewey is the best candidate yet...

 

[PBK]

Re: old "for prisedent" thingy

Sorry... could not let it go! I think Dewey is the best candidate yet...

Well, to be honest, Jim, neither could I, even though I tried to downplay it earlier— and of course DM said the same after I posted the photo of Dewey. The fact that the badge was made of aluminum and therefore probably not a lot earlier than 1900 was another convincing clue. And you know what? We were right! I just received the following e-mail from Rex Stark, a specialist in political memorabilia:

This was issued to promote Admiral George Dewey (naval hero of the Spanish-American War) for President in 1900. He was never actually a serious candidate. I have had several of these - while it is not rare, it certainly is quite scarce. In excellent condition it would be worth $100-150. Unfortunately, the condition of this one is terrible. I think it would be impossible to sell...

I like it anyway! In fact, I think it's a terrific little piece of history, and it gave us a good chase, too. That's what great finds are all about!

 

[whitesid]

Re: old "for prisedent" thingy

Sorry... could not let it go! I think Dewey is the best candidate yet...

Well, to be honest, Jim, neither could I, even though I tried to downplay it earlier— and of course DM said the same after I posted the photo of Dewey. The fact that the badge was made of aluminum and therefore probably not a lot earlier than 1900 was another convincing clue. And you know what? We were right! I just received the following e-mail from Rex Stark, a specialist in political memorabilia:

This was issued to promote Admiral George Dewey (naval hero of the Spanish-American War) for President in 1900. He was never actually a serious candidate. I have had several of these - while it is not rare, it certainly is quite scarce. In excellent condition it would be worth $100-150. Unfortunately, the condition of this one is terrible. I think it would be Impossible to sell...

I like it anyway! In fact, I think it's a terrific little piece of history, and it gave us a good chase, too. That's what great finds are all about!

can you ask him to post a picture of one of his im just curious to see what it looks like in good condition

 

[bk]

Re: old "for prisedent" thingy

Here is a picture of a metal thing that I posted a couple years ago. The concensus at that time was that it might be Admiral Dewey.
The back of mine said "patent applied for".

 

[PBK]

Re: old "for prisedent" thingy

can you post a picture of one...im just curious to see what it looks like in good condition

Okay, Kevin... here you go!

 

[whitesid]

Re: old "for prisedent" thingy

thank you all

 

[captain Jack]

Re: old "for prisedent" thingy

Nice piece! And good job sniffing that one out guys!