Since I don't think Every Newspaper is online.
there is still a possibility the story is true but
never picked up by the AP news, or who ever
spread news articles statewide and nationwide back then.
definitely not looking promising though
I was thinking the same thing. Stories are often missed by the media, but once found, are usually at least revisited and researched by the news, and recorded, somehow! No law records? I don't have big access to those, yet. Wouldn't there be some kind of prisoner log information for smethport, somewhere?
Also, Thank you for the pics in above post. led me to a site and an observation:
index.htm (I don't know how to create a link/hyperlink (whatever it may be called), but that is the address. Observation: In one of thier photos, it is either mislabled (1882), or we are mistaken in our theory of all of these "bald" mountaintops around. The photo shows large green trees everywhere. Granted, they don't look like old growth, but they look darn thick and obscuring to me. If the legend is true, then, I don't think the robber was up to 5 miles away. Trees obscure, and moisture from all those trees and the creek below usually creates a 'mist' that obscures vision at a distance...so, he must have been fairly close to the bridge, still, to see it (maybe a mile or two distance, max).
Wish I could get ANY Historically recorded link to the legend. Im going past there this weekend, but my hopes are much dashed from the research experience...Still going though! Plenty of potential MDing sites that WILL hold honey holes of some sort...trash middens, old estates and locations of high traffic volume, etc. Wish me a great time with my wife...I don't need any luck wishes, as luck is based on randomness, and I do not really believe in free destiny and such...