Indianapolis Tokens?

[Butterfield]

Both of these came from different sources in Indiana, and I feel they are probably from Indianapolis, but I can't find them in my directories. Is anyone familiar with either of these? The other one is a Seymour Indiana encased cent (with apparently the wrong date cent added) that's too worn for me to tell the business name (the last three letters seem to be "dle"). Too bad because it's an older Good For encased. View attachment 1207170View attachment 1207171View attachment 1207172View attachment 1207173

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

Cry Of The Eagle: History And Legends Of The Cherokee Indians And Their Buried Treasure - Grab it through Amazon!

[Butterfield]

These are the other tokens I believe might be from Indianapolis.

 

[Mackaydon]

"Keep me and never go broke" horseshoe token;like here:
https://www.etsy.com/listing/71719711/vintage-penny-souvenir-keep-me-and-never
Don.......

 

[idahotokens]

Butter--Louis Wanner is listed in the 1913 & 1914 Indianapolis City Directories as having a saloon at 2522 W. Michigan. Your piece is not listed on tokencatalog.com - how about putting it there? I can with your permission and measurements (height & width). I'll do a bit more looking for the Gary's Tire Center one later.
John in the Great 208

 

[Woodswoman]

Really like the heart shape, first I've seen.

 

[rgreever]

William L. Cole is listed in the 1918 Gary Indiana City Directory, in the Classifieds under Automobiles, at 617 Washington. In the white pages, he is listed as vulcanizing... at this address. I'd like to also request your permission to use your images on the TokenCatalog site... I can load for your, or you can add yourself.

 

[Butterfield]

Thanks John and Richard for the attributions! John, I measured the Wanner token. It's 25mm from inside of the heart to the tip at the bottom (height) and approx 29mm across on the widest part (width). I'm not sure if that's the correct way to measure a shaped token. Richard, I don't have the Gary token with me now, but can get the measurements to you. Either of you are welcome to post them on TokenCatalog if you want.