Do you mark your coins? Should You?

BigMoses777

BigMoses777

Jr. Member
Apr 4, 2013
65
23
General question for all CRH's out their. I just started in on my first box of halves for the weekend(ordered 4) and most of my coins have had a black sharpie maker taken to the edge of them. This tells me I'm hunting through someones dump. How many of you mark coins? Is this a good thing or bad? Just wanting some opinions. - On a side note, I met another CRH at the bank today and he picked up a box of dimes. He said he quit halves a while ago due to the area drying up. I've never found silver in halves yet but plan on still trying for a while. Have a good weekend!
 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

Upgraded Night Vision Monocular Digital Infrared Monocular Telescope for 100% Darkness with 8X Zoom - Grab it through Amazon!
Upvote 0
SlowSilver said:
Actually, you may want to read that again. Twiasp was in fact, correct. The Code clearly states "fraudulently alters, defaces...". The comma after fraudulently alters, means that anything after that is a new item otherwise it would say fraudulently: Alters, defaces, etc.
Click to expand...

We can argue about the placement of a comma or sentence structure all you like but if you read on to the last two sentences in the paragraph published by the United States treasury. It clearly states that they have no policy against this unless your intent is fraudulently alter the coin or currency to miss represent it for a denomination or rare mint mark or further misrepresent its true value. Marking with color there is no policy while its not condoned.
 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

How to Research for Treasure Hunting and Metal Detecting From Lead Generation to Vetting - Grab it through Amazon!
Bigheed said:
if you have any brains in statistics you will understand how futile marking coins is.

but by all means.....entertain yourselves and me.
Click to expand...

True, in reality you are only marking maybe one coin for every 100,000 or so that were minted (not accurately based on math). On the other hand, if you end up seeing your marks come back to you, it could tell you a lot. By the sound of it, plenty of people have learned a thing or two from marking their coins.
 

drcaulfield said:
We can argue about the placement of a comma or sentence structure all you like but if you read on to the last two sentences in the paragraph published by the United States treasury. It clearly states that they have no policy against this unless your intent is fraudulently alter the coin or currency to miss represent it for a denomination or rare mint mark or further misrepresent its true value. Marking with color there is no policy while its not condoned.
Click to expand...

In the English Language, sentence structure matters. The lack of a colon after the word fraudulently clearly delineates this as an individual item, not a preposition of classification that would cover the entirety of the following dispositions. This is taught in 6th grade English. Additionally if you could please cite your source and the exact quote for the Treasury Statement, you vaguely referred to in your post that would be great, as I was unable to find it anywhere. The only document linked in this thread was 18 USC Sec. 331 as found on the
link provided by twiasp to the US Law Revision Counsel, section of the U.S House of Representatives Website. Thanks.
 

Last edited by a moderator:
SlowSilver said:
In the English Language, sentence structure matters. The lack of a colon after the word fraudulently clearly delineates this as an individual item, not a preposition of classification that would cover the entirety of the following dispositions. This is taught in 6th grade English. Additionally if you could please cite your source and the exact quote for the Treasury Statement, you vaguely referred to in your post that would be great, as I was unable to find it anywhere. The only document linked in this thread was 18 USC Sec. 331 as found on the
link provided by twiasp to the US Law Revision Counsel, section of the U.S House of Representatives Website. Thanks.
Click to expand...

http://www.treasury.gov/resource-center/faqs/Coins/Pages/edu_faq_coins_portraits.aspx

There's the source. I am sure with your excellent grasp of the English language you will be able to understand the fact that your wrong ;). Have a good day and happy reading.
 

SlowSilver said:

In the English Language, sentence structure matters. The lack of a colon after the word fraudulently clearly delineates this as an individual item, not a preposition of classification that would cover the entirety of the following dispositions. This is taught in 6th grade English. Additionally if you could please cite your source and the exact quote for the Treasury Statement, you vaguely referred to in your post that would be great, as I was unable to find it anywhere. The only document linked in this thread was 18 USC Sec. 331 as found on the
link provided by twiasp to the US Law Revision Counsel, section of the U.S House of Representatives Website. Thanks.
Click to expand...

Slowsilver, please take the time to read our rules....... Do not correct someones English unless they ask, do not use large font or bold to shout and emphasize your point, especially when it is used to talk down to or correct someones grammar....

From our rules...................

"Don't "SHOUT" in large type. Use bold, red, or other special type only when necessary. (Exception: birthday greetings, special congratulations, etc.)"

"Don't attack, provoke, insult, or deliberately offend anyone."

"All members are equal, regardless of age, gender, ethnicity, education, or experience. Never take a superior tone with, or "talk down" to, anyone.""
 

Last edited:
drcaulfield said:
Portraits & Designs

There's the source. I am sure with your excellent grasp of the English language you will be able to understand the fact that your wrong ;). Have a good day and happy reading.
Click to expand...


With all due respect drcaulfield, I beg to differ. I shall lay out my position as follows.

1.) The U.S. Treasury link you have provided is a summarization referring to the aforementioned Law 18 USC Sec. 331. The treasury is attempting to clarify that they see no legal problem with the resale of coins altered by silver plating, gold plating, post mint stamping etc. as seen by many after market and Home Shopping Network Channels.

2.) You cited "Treasury Policy". Treasury Policy has no relevance as it is not legally binding, because they are neither a part of the legislative or judicial branches, and therefore have no power to either implement or interpret the law.

3.) There are multiple other laws, such as 18 USC CHAPTER 17 etc.. that can be cited that further clarify these issues.

 

boristhespider88 said:
I like to stop by banks where I know people dump at and then take them to my dump bank, who promptly bags them and ships them out. Less for me to have to deal with later on in my town. :)

I don't see the point of marking either, because taking them to the bank and having another hunter pick them up (like what I do) just messes up the whole point of you marking the coins to begin with.

I just roll them up, mark the wrappers (I line them up and just mark on all of them at once) then dump them off.

To each their own though with marking. I can't stop people from screwing up coins that have value to me or others, so to argue is pointless.

HH
- DS
Click to expand...
Clad is just a pain. Most people open proofs and cash them in. most of the new halfs to. so mark away I might start spraying again.??
 

Treasure_Hunter said:
Slowsilver, please take the time to read our rules....... Do not correct someones English unless they ask, do not use large font or bold to shout and emphasize your point, especially when it is used to talk down to or correct someones grammar....

From our rules...................

"Don't "SHOUT" in large type. Use bold, red, or other special type only when necessary. (Exception: birthday greetings, special congratulations, etc.)"

"Don't attack, provoke, insult, or deliberately offend anyone."

"All members are equal, regardless of age, gender, ethnicity, education, or experience. Never take a superior tone with, or "talk down" to, anyone.""
Click to expand...
And don't find all the silver leave some for me!!
 

SlowSilver said:
With all due respect drcaulfield, I beg to differ. I shall lay out my position as follows.

1.) The U.S. Treasury link you have provided is a summarization referring to the aforementioned Law 18 USC Sec. 331. The treasury is attempting to clarify that they see no legal problem with the resale of coins altered by silver plating, gold plating, post mint stamping etc. as seen by many after market and Home Shopping Network Channels.

2.) You cited "Treasury Policy". Treasury Policy has no relevance as it is not legally binding, because they are neither a part of the legislative or judicial branches, and therefore have no power to either implement or interpret the law.

3.) There are multiple other laws, such as 18 USC CHAPTER 17 etc.. that can be cited that further clarify these issues.
Click to expand...
I have a few trees that need some love would you like to come over this weekend. Am a painter and allways will be. That's how big Poppa rolls...........
 

Who said ENGLISH is the official language of T-net or any of this is relevant on the Internet. dont like seein som1 insult my homeslice TimZim.
 

BigMoses777 said:
None of the bank around me take rolled coin. OK, they take them, but immediately break them open and put them in their machine. I have yet to find on that doesn't and that sucks. No chance to buy those rolls that came from grandpas collection...
Click to expand...

Buy the bag from the machine.
 

50cent said:
Who said ENGLISH is the official language of T-net or any of this is relevant on the Internet. dont like seein som1 insult my homeslice TimZim.
Click to expand...

Dawg I can't believe mods are allowing people to insults us and timzim because of the way we talk... This is madness!
 

You must log in or register to reply here.

2 Rolls 1 Rosie

⬅️ Previous Thread

great score

Next Thread ➡️

Top Member Reactions

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 3 (members: 0, guests: 3)
Metal Detecting Stuff

Latest Discussions

Back
Top