cleaned my 1877 seated quarter

[mattysee]

cleaned it up good, also a walker I found a few months ago, had no idea the shape it was in. and a kids private eye badge

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

A Handbook of Civil War Bullets and Cartridges - Grab it through Amazon!

[recondigger]

looking good I love clean silver. I can't wait to hear all the people saying how your coins should never ever be cleaned, well if they are your coins and you like them looking good then clean away! unless its a key date then I wouldn't clean them.

 

[jewelerguy]

tell me you didn't polish those coins

 

[WHADIFIND]

well if they are your coins and you like them looking good then clean away! unless its a key date then I wouldn't clean them.

I must disagree. First of all, there is no "if" in the ownership.

And second, I don't care what "date" they are, if one is so inclined, they can clean them to their hearts content! As long as they know that cleaning will devalue their numismatic value, clean them until they look how you wish! I mean, if you don't want the million dollars, that is entirely up to you.

Good job! I'd rather see a bright shiny silver coin myself!

HH!

 

[WHADIFIND]

tell me you didn't polish those coins

Ummmm.....why?

 

[mariposagold]

Silver coins, in my opinion, are beautiful right out of the ground. Other than a light bath in plain water, I have no desire to do anything else to my coins. I've had some rather stubborn copper coins that resisted simply bathing. Though they are not as clean as my silver, they are still beautiful to me. My little silver and copper children. :-)

Mattysee, I don't know what you did to your sliver coins, but they look fabulous.

 

[CASPER-2]

 

[g-olden years]

Beautiful job on your silver -- astounding! I'm about the same vintage as your walker, but I'll never look that good again, lol. Andi

 

[jewelerguy]

Ummmm.....why?

exactly for the reason you stated above,( because polishing them degrades the value ). the owner is welcome to do with as they wish, but too many times I see coins get polished because they didn't know that it actually degrades the value. does it makes them look pretty and shiny? yes, but as a collector it makes me cringe

 

[ynpto804]

I guess I just don't see the point in taking a 20 dollar quarter and making it a 4 dollar one. But that's just me.

 

[BryanM362]

They look good! How did you clean them?

 

[scott9050]

I guess I just don't see the point in taking a 20 dollar quarter and making it a 4 dollar one. But that's just me.

Yep, instant cull and filler piece by doing that.

 

[Argentium]

People definitely get their knickers in a twist about this cleaning business - of course anybody is free to do whatever they want to
with their property , but clearly when you take a seated liberty quarter , like this one , and scour it or buff it - you just reduced it to
the value of the metal . I think what really creeps me out -is seeing people dig a coin on a video , and thumb rubbing the dirt on a
silver coin !

 

[mattysee]

thanx all I love clean silver, I would never do it to a highly valuble key date........the quarter went from 20 to 4 you say? Id bet you 2 early u.s.coppers I get at least 30 for it on ebay, even stating that I cleaned the coin!

 

[recondigger]

thanx all I love clean silver, I would never do it to a highly valuble key date........the quarter went from 20 to 4 you say? Id bet you 2 early u.s.coppers I get at least 30 for it on ebay, even stating that I cleaned the coin!

you sure opened a can of worms on this thread

 

[ggossage]

Nice finds! And shiney!

 

[dutchtoga]

You should take those shiny coins and place them on my eyelids because your killing me.

 

[ynpto804]

thanx all I love clean silver, I would never do it to a highly valuble key date........the quarter went from 20 to 4 you say? Id bet you 2 early u.s.coppers I get at least 30 for it on ebay, even stating that I cleaned the coin!

I would take that bet. I just don't have early us coins to put up.

 

[mr helton]

thanx all I love clean silver, I would never do it to a highly valuble key date........the quarter went from 20 to 4 you say? Id bet you 2 early u.s.coppers I get at least 30 for it on ebay, even stating that I cleaned the coin!

I buy tons of dirty Indian Head pennies for under a buck with free shipping, tumble them, then sell them for $3 each on Ebay. Most people don't seem to care that they are cleaned because they look great.

I'm not saying a high value coin wouldn't take a huge hit, I just felt like sharing because it was related.

 

[WHADIFIND]

thanx all I love clean silver, I would never do it to a highly valuble key date........the quarter went from 20 to 4 you say? Id bet you 2 early u.s.coppers I get at least 30 for it on ebay, even stating that I cleaned the coin!

I really get tired of people who know "all that" telling others' how they should treat their finds. Do we have a responsibility to keep exceptionally rare coins in the best found condition? Sure. But, I saw the dates and knew they weren't especially rare. So, I knew you were cleaning up something for yourself and THAT is your business, and yours alone!

I would disagree on cleaning a very rare coin. But, not because of the so called numismatic value. Rather, I figure to pass that one down for historical purposes. So, I would attempt to keep it as nice as I can without "hurting" how much someone might be able to sell it for, later on.

I have an idea, next time, just tell them about how pretty and pristine your coins look after you gave them a good cleaning and buffing. BUT, by NO means, post ANY pictures of them at all! See how they like them apples! LOL

If I didn't already have one, I'd gladly pay you 30 bucks for that pretty coin!

HH!