Back From Cruise; Results are in....

ToastedWheatie

Hero Member
Jun 30, 2013
527
749
Hudson Valley, NY
🥇 Banner finds
1
Detector(s) used
800
Infinium
Whites M6
Primary Interest:
Relic Hunting
Well, got home yesterday with as much as I left with. Murphy Law was in FULL effect this trip.



Not a big cruise ship fan, but I convinced myself to go after allowing myself to purchase a HeadHunter Wader specifically for this. The trip was to be three days in Clearwater with family, then a 5 night cruise to the Bahamas. One of the stops was to be Little Stirrup Cay (AKA Coco Cay), owned by a cruise line. No locals living on the island, no overnight guests. Googling and searching forums provided little info from guys detecting this spot. So I figure it doesn't get hit often, and certainly not everywhere.
Worth the shot, making it worth the trip.

I figure I can practice some on the beach of Clearwater, as I have no salt water experience, and the machine is not PI. The first stop on the cruise is Nassau, home of Atlantis Resorts. Maybe get lucky there, as well as some more practice. Then on to the main spot, that little island that gets three or more cruise ships a day there (thousands of people) and minimal detecting. Getting more excited by the day....

We started on Thursday the 21st. Flying out at 7:30pm. The plane was delayed until 8:30. Boarded at 8:15, and the wife has a claustriphobic induced panic attack as soon as she sits in her seat. We were off the plane by 8:20.

We don't live far from the airport, so we were back home by 9:15. Grabbed some pillows and blankets from the house, gassed up the car, and we were on the road driving by 10pm. New York to Florida. Gonna make this work.
Somewhere around Maryland, I realized I left my scoop along side the garage. Damn.
Then I remembered Kellyco is in Orlando! Maybe I can salvage this trip.
We drive straight through, except for a two hour nap somewhere. I can't let the wife know why, but I need to make it to Orlando before 6pm on Friday.
With some luck and no traffic, we made it to Kellyco 45 minutes before closing ( wish I had more time. Soooo many display machines. Finally could have tried out a bunch!). One scoop left that matches what I need (price, breaks down, size). Woo Hoo. It's all coming together.

Now, you remember that cold front that came through the U.S. last week? It made it to norther Florida that day.
The days in Cleawater were cold (high of 60), windy, with rough surf.
Couldn't get the hang of the machine in the surf. Figured out how to reduce and 'read" the salt mineralization chatter, so something productive came out of it. But the waves kept moving me, and/or any targets. Maybe I need more practice. I'll get it in Nassau.

Ship left out of Jacksonville 3 or 4 hours late, as it arrived late because of rough seas. Sat around outside in shorts and Tshirts in the wind and 55 degree weather. But still psyched about that island, so all is good.

Day three on the ship. Still haven't seen the sun. Kids are motion sick, and no one goes outside on the decks. Waterslide still hasn't opened, as well as all activities up top. Too windy, and unsafe. But I brought on my own Bacardi and Capt. Morgan, so I can endure.

Off the ship to go to the beach near Atlantis. I catch a ride there (note to others: Take the $4 cab ride. As soon as you get off the dock there is a $4 ferry option. Takes 45 min. and leaves you with a 1 mile walk. I learned the hard way. Stick with the cab!)
As I arrived on Paradise Island, and had to walk to the beach,the rains came. With welt inducing hail. At least there was a Dunkin Doughts nearby to wait out the storm.

At the beach, I notice rough surf, but at least I'm there!
DSCN6505.JPG
Made it to the beach about an hour and a half after I left the ship.
The surf here was also more than I can handle. I could stand in chest deep water, only 4 or 5 feet from the breaker and shin deep water. Don't know the air temp, but the water was warmer. That cold front pushed all the way down here!
DSCN6499.JPG
I don't know if it was my inexperience, or it really is difficult in those conditions.Should I be able to detect in this??? But it didn't matter, because after 10 minutes the arm strap came off my handle. It just came unstuck from the metal. I tried another half hour but with the added restistance of the water, and it not being strapped to the forearm, my wrist became fatigued. Any repeatable hits that I had I couldn't relocate after being tossed around.
So I just hit the dry sand for an hour or so. Nothing. Nada. Not even a bottle top. This must get gone over pretty well.

But that's OK. I now some experience with the salt, am comfortable with the machine, and that island I've been looking forward to has a lot of protected coves.
coco cay pic.jpgcoco cay.jpg

Day 4, still no sun or outdoor activities.
Up at 6am (no drinking the night before, plan on a full 8 hours of swinging that day), as the tenders are to deliver us to that island starting at 7:30 am. Early coffee and breakfast, got some duct tape from mainteance to make an arm strap, and then the announcement:
" We are sorry to inform you that because of rough weather, the tenders cannot safely transport you to the island. We will be redirecting to Freeport."

WT*?

Ugh.

So we get to Freeport at noon, and I'm calmed down a bit, determined to "make lemonade" out of this.

Off the ship, find a map, talk to a few taxi drivers, 10 of us to a public beach (at $7 per, each way). Still windy, and not warm. But the surf here is manageable. Put my machine together, calibrate it to the salt, grab my scoop.... where's my scoop? You know, that one I went out of my way to get at Kellyco?
Take a look at my first pic. The one I took with my equipment in front of an Atalntis sign. My scoop was left there. In that position.
I was so peeved about that strap, I never thought to pack the scoop after I broke down the machine into the duffle bag. I'm such an idiot.

So, in the calmer surf, I devise a way to dig a hole and seperate the target with my foot. Each hit would take me three or four minutes. Working in hip deep water still had every third wave coming chest deep, so bending over to find target with my fingers was time consuming.
Oh, did I mention that although the shipped docked at this place at 12, and wasn't leaving 'til 8pm, the taxis do the last pick up at 4pm. So we only had a few hours on the beach.
I was able to do my part in eliminateing that beach of some garbage, but that's it. Here's some:
DSCN6575.JPG

So, after driving 2500 miles round trip ( and the plane tix were not refundable), LOTS of money spent, sick kids (youngest got fever on day four after motion sickness cleared up), hours and hours of research, that was the result of the trip.
But the time spent with family made it all worth it. Sort of........
 

Last edited:
Upvote 0
It looks like I am the first one to share your pain. WOW, what a trip. I don't think I will ever complain again about a bad day of detecting on the beach. It almost sounds like you died and went to detecting Hell..... I wish you MUCH better luck next time...... Have a safe and blessed Christmas holiday. It has to be better than that, I don't think it could get much worse. HH, Beach Papa
 

Wow what a time but many lessons learned, The good is you have two scoops and a headhunter detector, and you will be better prepared next trip. And the next trip stop on Maryland, we can hunt a few days here in the Bay.
 

Oh man, I am so sorry :crybaby2:for your trip from hell. But you all made it home safe and future hunts have to be better. You've paid your dues. Good luck and your picture is in the dictionary next to "tenacious"!!
 

Wow, that's a bad deal. Sorry about your luck. I have made a few 1600 mile road trips to the beach and been skunked before, but your story takes the prize. I know the feeling of anticipation for weeks before a trip and the let down of going home empty handed. It's a total gamble but I'll do it again the next chance I get and hope you do too. Merry Christmas.
 

That stinks. I went on a cruise last spring and was able to hunt only two times. It was a 10 day cruise. My first outing did not do well due to spending way to much time hunting for a lost ring. I found out the ring was deeper then I was able to go later. But at our last stop their private island I scored 5 rings and a bracelet, 1 of the rings is a nice gold with ice, 2 silvers ,1 tungsten and 1 junk. The bracelet is silver also. I learned from some of the employees that no one had every metal detected that island that they know of. Now all I want is to go back. Lol.
 

Well, I'm trying to find something positive to focus on in regards to your trip/adventure. Need to think on it a bit longer as I'm sure something will eventually come to me. :laughing7: How many times did you do this......:BangHead:
 

WOW !!!!!!!!!!
I know the little island your talking about. I lost a ring there many years ago before getting into this hobby. It would cost more to go back and hunt for it but if I did, I would probably find a lot of Gold and Silver there.
 

Sorry to hear about your bad luck. It is difficult to just drop into a new location and be able to hunt effectively. I have learned the hard way many times. Hopefully you have learned valuable lessons that will get you closer to the gold next time!

When I went to the Bahamas I brought a handheld scoop...that a terrible idea.
 

Just so you know, Coco Cay is detected often, every water hunter that takes that cruise hunts there.....

Hope you enjoyed the family time....

We will NOT go quietly into the night!
 

I really feel for you Tidajo, Murphy ran you over with a steam roller!! Wow!
Well it has to go up from there! Maybe you're in for the biggest find of your life!
I usually get nailed by Murphy when "nothing can possible go wrong", I am now a pessimist !
Glad you all are ok. HH! At lest was your old scope still next to the garage ?
 

That story sounds like my cruise from Hell, at least you didn't miss the water taxi back to the boat let me tell you that gets expensive. Better luck next time
 

Sorry to hear that your vacation didn't go as planned. Two of the last 3 cruises I have gone on did not go to the island because of rough seas. The one time I did get on the island I got one junker. I went to a different island and got one silver. I have a feeling that these islands are hunted heavily. I used to go on a cruise and find a few good things but the last 4 or 5 cruises have been poor at best with no gold at all. I used to plan cruises to metal detect but now I plan cruises to have fun with the family and friends and if I get some detecting in it's okay and if I don't well so be it...
 

total bummer.... During my first cruise, we hit 25-30 foot swells that resulted in a trip to the infirmary and a shot that made me sleep for almost 2 full days. No MD'g, no casino, no buffet, no alone time with the Mrs...
 

Thanks for the support guys.
This post may sound like a "whine", but not meant to be that way. I actually laughed at the luck I was having!

@TreasureHunter; I found little references anywhere about cruisers hitting that spot. I know most MDers wouldn't let out a spot that may have worked for them, but I asked around on cruising websites also. Sounded like there was the occassional MDer on the island. One a day at most from the ships.
That can leave enough underwater territory to hit. Better than a beach in a resort area, I would think. Not ideal, but good enough for an inlander like myself.

Oh well, I have a new obsession for the month. I have a friend whose house dates back into late 1700s. Was used as a boarding house for NYC vacationers in the 20s-50s. the property has produced a sword scabbard dated to early 1800s and a number of silver and clad to early 1900s. The house has a hand dug well in front yard. 4' wide. Who know what was dropped down there for what reason in the last 100 plus years. Wishing well for those vacationers? Etc?
Been dry, water level is down to two feet. if i can pump it out faster than the two feet flows in, I might get a chance to clean out what's there.

Now if I can just get one more warm day.....
 

Wow! Now I know that I will never book a cruise! That is exactly what I fear would happen to me! Don't give up on the hobby. I see that you live in ny, come to Long Island in the winter months and hunt the shore line. You can find a lot of neat stuff and it is a lot easier then surf hunting (which you can't do in the winter in ny) I found a ton of stuff the past month, maybe not a gold ring, but, so much fun!
 

Last edited:
I hunted the Cay a few years ago and found mostly broken glass. The deeper areas looked promising. You are not alone in leaving the scoop home. Kellyco saved a vacation for me when they were able to ship next day a scoop directly to the hotel we were staying at. Better luck next time.
 

Sounds like you need your own boat. Head south for the winter. Detect ALL the islands!!

For inspiration, I would suggest viewing 'Capt. Ron.'

Good luck on your next hunt,

your brought tears to my eyes.

tears.gif
 

-
That's what happens when you mix your passion with family pleasure.

I've had the same type of luck mixing my passion for fishing with family vacations.

Stuff Happens!!
 

Top Member Reactions

Users who are viewing this thread

Latest Discussions

Back
Top