Found this token with the nox-800 today, came in at a 16-18, anyone able to help me identify it or any advice on how to clean it up? Thanks in advance!!! The IHPS are 1865, 1867 and 1870 (holed)
Congrats on the finds! I have a copy of U.S. Civil War Store Cards (Fuld) and I was able to look up this token based on the star in wreath design. That led me to the identify the issuer as J.S. Queeby of Peru, Indiana.
There are a few different varieties of his token. I think yours is the 23310/1384 and looks as if it is the one most commonly seen.