There are some old lead mines(galena) in Pa. Naming the county in which you found it may help.
By the way I have found galena in nearby Ohio in plowed Indian mound locations(does not occur naturally in Ohio).
In addition to streak check hardness- galena has a hardness of 2.5 and will not scratch a COPPER Penny.
copper penny hardness 3
knife blade hardness 5
window glass hardness 5.5
Actually the specimen does not appear to have cubic cleavage which you would expect to see in broken specimens of galena.
Perhaps this is arensopyrite which is also found in Pa. See any twinning(small lines) on the surface of the crystal? hardness 5.5 to 6- will scratch a knive blade and perhaps glass.
http://www.mindat.org/gallery.php?min=305
George