shield nickle cleaning help

[bcs123]

found this at a cw site had to look under a magnifying glass to see what it is, you can see part of the shield on one side and part of the 5 on the other. any ideas on cleaning it would be great. all i have done to it was washed it in water to get the loose dirt off.

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

Cry Of The Eagle: History And Legends Of The Cherokee Indians And Their Buried Treasure - Grab it through Amazon!

[nova]

Depending on how clean you want it use ketchup. smear it all around let it sit
a few hours maybe a day. (Both Sides) Then wash it off It will come out nearly original. However I will say if
the coin has any pitting it will show up with the ketchup cleaning. I have tried this it does work.
Or you can go witha rock tumbler.
Let me know if this works for you and how it turned out. I would appreciate it!
Novaman.

 

[bcs123]

isnt ketchup hard on coins though because of the acid?
i mean this coin will more than likely not be worth much but i still dont wanna destroy it?
and as far as the rock tumbler (never used one) will it smooth out the coin? like completely ware it down smooth?

 

[nova]

I was no sure how clean you was wanting it, that's why I suggested the ketchup method.
A rock tumbler with walnut shell or even sand will show semi results. (No Water) It will not ware it down
unless you run it for days. Try a couple hours then check repeat if necessary. I seen on the coins forum
there is other methods of how other TH. Clean their coins. Check it out you might get more ideas there.
If you decide to go with a tumbler H. Freight has them. Nice coin by the way I have not found a shield
nickle in years. Let me know how it works out. On a last note! You could send it in for professional
cleaning (NGC ) or whoever, but that could be spendy. Good Luck.

 

[BuckleBoy]

As worn is that coin is, any cleaning you do to it will likely make it worse. It is what it is.

Here in my area, the nickels come up really red from the soil, so what I do is scrub with a soft toothbrush all the patina off the coin (dark stuff), revealing the red underneath (this is normally a no-no in terms of other coins, like copper ones). Then I use the oil that is already on my fingers naturally to very lightly highlight the high points in the design. It allows me to see the detail as long as I don't get any oil on the low spots.

I would leave tht one alone. Don't wanna do something drastic to your first Shield. It is what it is.


Best Wishes,



Buckles

 

[skarmajunga]

Interesting topic, I just came home with my first ever shield nickel. Its looking pretty cruddy and I cant tell the date yet but would love to find a safe way to clean it.