Rudimentry Gold ID

Reanm8er

Bronze Member
Aug 17, 2018
2,283
3,556
Shenandoah Valley Va
Detector(s) used
WW2 Mine Detector, 2 Garrets and an Underwater Fisher (Older Machines)
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
Howdy Friends, I'm so glad I've found this website because it's helping me relieve nearly seventy years of "Information Constipation" (figure of speech). Just being able to tell 60 yr old stories to those who are interested is terrific therapy for my dinosaur carcass. I've spent my whole life walking around looking at the ground and have found some amazing things and observed some amazing practices.
One such practice is the ability to ID gold reliably without a loupe, acid test or other visual enhancements. Once while hunting my fave flea market I came upon an individual of obvious Eastern descent. I thought it wise to observe this individual, because he was obviously looking for gold as was I. I've always had a gift from somewhere that allowed me to interview strangers by just being polite and displaying genuine interest in their actions.
This man was walking along in a row where I'd recovered many, many ounces of damaged gold jewelry. He was picking up pieces of jewelry and after looking them over would smell his fingers. No loupe, no magnification and no cellphone contact to verify his conclusions. So, I ventured to ask him about his method of identification. He chuckled aloud and offered a sheepish grin and said "I don't need to see markings because they're not often accurate and I have a better method.
He explained that by rubbing a piece of genuine gold, he can confirm that by rubbing it and then smelling for the odor of brass on his fingers, he can discern base metal. Makes sense. I tried it and as long as you clean your fingers between tests you'll get the smell. He didn't clean his fingers but then he was equipped with better olfactory equipment than I and his had not been burned out by years of pipe welding.
Finger some plated items in your collection and see if you don't smell it. Of course it won't reveal silver over pewter but the weight and softness will show that.
 

sounds like he had a method similar to the one this guy uses

5660750c210000c9005ac2cf.jpeg
 

Upvote 0
I tried the smelling my fingers technique with two ex-wives. Not reliable.:dontknow:
 

Upvote 0
Haha Funny thread...

I had a friend sniff the gold when people brought it up. They really thought he was checking it that way...No, his eye sight was good enough and quick enough with out a loop to see the markings. So....There are a bunch of people in OH that have witnessed and believe in the "smell test" too!

It may actually work! I just know guys that did it to mess with people. After a while you can tell by sight too, most of the time. Even sort by K that way.
 

Last edited:
Upvote 0
Cut me some slack guys after all he was searching for gold too! Do we tell anyone our methods?
 

Upvote 0
Cut me some slack guys after all he was searching for gold too! Do we tell anyone our methods?

You will also see guys hold it to their face. They can tell if it's solid by how fast it warms up. I've seen that done with pocket watch cases. I haven't ever been able to feel the real difference. But I do believe some guys can and use it as an indicator.

Easier for me to look at the hinges, or the inside. :laughing7:
 

Last edited:
Upvote 0
Thanks Nitric, The guy had an obvious advantage over the average human, re nostril capacity. My father in law was shot down over Hamm Germany in late 44. He couldn't smell anything because of the flames he inhaled in the explosion. I can't smell much because of all the pipe joints I welded right under my nose. Perhaps those who have never been subjected to that kind of trauma can tell the difference between subtle differences in smells.
 

Upvote 0
Thanks Nitric, The guy had an obvious advantage over the average human, re nostril capacity. My father in law was shot down over Hamm Germany in late 44. He couldn't smell anything because of the flames he inhaled in the explosion. I can't smell much because of all the pipe joints I welded right under my nose. Perhaps those who have never been subjected to that kind of trauma can tell the difference between subtle differences in smells.

I was a "swamper" for a pipe welder for a couple years. I was the wire brush, grind guy between welds and passes. So I know what you mean! Some stinky situations! :laughing7:
 

Upvote 0
A hell of a job that you're born for or you're not. The first and only time I ever saw my G Grandmother Kohler she snatched me up from my mother's arms and showed me the inside of the coal stove in all it's glowing beauty. My mother rushed forward in a panic but I was calm and fascinated. I remember as my mother snatched me away GG just smiled at me and nodded. The mark of the smith had been bestowed upon me!
 

Upvote 0
A hell of a job that you're born for or you're not. The first and only time I ever saw my G Grandmother Kohler she snatched me up from my mother's arms and showed me the inside of the coal stove in all it's glowing beauty. My mother rushed forward in a panic but I was calm and fascinated. I remember as my mother snatched me away GG just smiled at me and nodded. The mark of the smith had been bestowed upon me!

There are some tough men out there!!! When I hit mid 30's I realized....I wasn't one of them! haha :laughing7:
 

Upvote 0
Our cats and dog are good at sniffing butts, for what who knows but maybe I can train them to sniff out Gold.

Count yourself lucky!

The only thing my dog can smell is the roast beef sandwich I was planning to have for dinner !! :)
 

Upvote 0

Top Member Reactions

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top