READ ALL THE COMMENTS ON SB 657!!!
- Thread starter Hefty1
- Start date
- Thread starter
- #2
Legislation by Gaines Would Repeal Suction Dredge Mining Ban
Another measure I have introduced would repeal the statewide ban on suction dredge mining until a full environmental review has been completed.
It is irresponsible to impose a one-size-fits-all ban on suction dredge mining before we even know what the effects are. There is no scientific evidence that points to suction dredge mining as a cause in the collapse of fish populations. An economic impact report has been started, but there seems to be no urgency in its completion. In the meantime, local economies are suffering and those who depend on the mining to make a living are impacted.
Last year, Senate Bill 670 put a statewide ban in place to protect fish populations. This has significantly impacted small-scale miners in rural communities, where mining is still an important part of the local culture, history and economy. Senate Bill 657 will lift the state-wide ban until the Department of Fish and Game has had time to complete its California Environmental Quality Act review and determine if the small-scale mining in fact harms salmon.
When the ban went into effect, all suction dredge mining permits became immediately invalid, but permit holders were not given refunds for their unusable permits. For the state to pocket people’s money for a service it is no longer providing is incomprehensible. It’s the equivalent of purchasing access to a gym or fitness facility and not being able to use it. It wouldn’t fly in the private sector and it shouldn’t be permitted in government.
My measure will ensure the viability of this industry until there is concrete proof that it does more harm than good. The disruption of an entire way of life for some of my constituents is not something that should be done on a hunch.
Short URL: http://lakesidenews.net/?p=4048
Another measure I have introduced would repeal the statewide ban on suction dredge mining until a full environmental review has been completed.
It is irresponsible to impose a one-size-fits-all ban on suction dredge mining before we even know what the effects are. There is no scientific evidence that points to suction dredge mining as a cause in the collapse of fish populations. An economic impact report has been started, but there seems to be no urgency in its completion. In the meantime, local economies are suffering and those who depend on the mining to make a living are impacted.
Last year, Senate Bill 670 put a statewide ban in place to protect fish populations. This has significantly impacted small-scale miners in rural communities, where mining is still an important part of the local culture, history and economy. Senate Bill 657 will lift the state-wide ban until the Department of Fish and Game has had time to complete its California Environmental Quality Act review and determine if the small-scale mining in fact harms salmon.
When the ban went into effect, all suction dredge mining permits became immediately invalid, but permit holders were not given refunds for their unusable permits. For the state to pocket people’s money for a service it is no longer providing is incomprehensible. It’s the equivalent of purchasing access to a gym or fitness facility and not being able to use it. It wouldn’t fly in the private sector and it shouldn’t be permitted in government.
My measure will ensure the viability of this industry until there is concrete proof that it does more harm than good. The disruption of an entire way of life for some of my constituents is not something that should be done on a hunch.
Short URL: http://lakesidenews.net/?p=4048
russau
Gold Member
i got my thankyou comment in to the Senator.i hope it saved it. my computors been acting not very funny lately!
russau
Gold Member
proff has been gotten by every gubermint agency out there in most of the western states and Alaska. and every one of these agencys have reported that 4 inch suction dredges and under have only a diminumus (sp) effect on the streams. yet now they say it does have a measureable effect and these people wont even read/understand their own scientific studys. and you wonder why California has gone broke!here i go again on a rant! sorry!
Sturgeon Stomper
Newbie
They are broke because it takes 15 of them so called workers to figure out what that measuable amount is, in 3 years.
2cmorau
Bronze Member
- Nov 8, 2010
- 1,608
- 1,294
- Detector(s) used
- GMT&GM3 Whites MXT Pro, Shadow X5, Fisher 1280, OMG and the TDI
- Primary Interest:
- Prospecting
i wonder why states with low taxes do so much better then California and then there is the gun states that have a low crime rate just wondering
Top Member Reactions
-
3531 -
2089 -
2051 -
1158 -
1114 -
927 -
848 -
823 -
818 -
782 -
770 -
543 -
531 -
453 -
452 -
446 -
E
424
-
413 -
410 -
404
