Fake arrowhead?

[SCpicker]

Normally I don't purchase artifacts but I had to make an exception. Recently I bought part of a lifetime collection of a gentleman that passed away a few years ago. The locations and stories of most of his artifacts went with him. From what I understand he primarily collected in south west Arkansas, east Texas and southeast Oklahoma. Amongst the 70 or so true arrowheads, including the finest Caddo arrowheads I've ever held...there is one, only one, that I think is a fake/repro. It just doesn't look like any type I know. It also wasn't in his frames that had his best points. All the other points are authentic. This reminds me why I don't buy arrowheads! Anyways I wanted a second opinion. Thoughts?

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

A Handbook of Civil War Bullets and Cartridges - Grab it through Amazon!

[kha924]

Im no expert but looks to good to be true to me..

 

[VTColonialDigger]

Hmm... Strange I would agree with you that it does look different/strange, and what would be the purpose of that notch at the bottom? There would be no use for it since it would be concealed by the wood of the arrow shaft. For some reason it just doesn't look right.

 

[joshuaream]

It just doesn't look like any type I know. It also wasn't in his frames that had his best points. All the other points are authentic.

I think you hit the key points here. Type is off, wasn't displayed the same way as the rest, and the rest are authentic.

Someone might have given him the point, it might have been in with a group he purchased, or maybe he just liked it, but it stands out as different from his main collection.

 

[Jon Stewart]

I bet that thing would kill a deer. Not sure if it is an artifact.

 

[The Grim Reaper]

I'd say modern as well. It just doesn't fit any known types.