Michigan Badger, I've studied the results listed by the document MajorBeep posted, and will say, at first look, it would appear that some detectors, not just Minelab, are capable of achieving SLIGHTLY more detection depth in certain scientifically categorized soil. However, after close examination, not just 1 of 100 some pages, of course, ALL the machines in use are military grade mine detectors, specifically for finding land mines, and in nearly all instances, there is a margin of error close to the amount of difference in air vs. soil comparisons. Also, these units were pulse induction units, not the type of discriminator units we detectors generally use on land! However, the most telling part of this analysis, is near the end of the document, which states:
In general, (in-air maximum detection heights, measured with the detectors set-up to a
particular ground, are not equal to the in-soil maximum detection depth in the same
ground). There did not seem to be any simple and direct way to predict in-soil performance
from the in-air measurements.
At the time of writing, it appears that it is necessary to carry out in-soil measurements to
obtain reliable in-soil data. Accordingly, this should be considered during the next CWA
review along with the ground reference height technique described before (section 6.2) pp.103. The parentheses are my own, but take careful note: The units were ground balanced for a specific soil BEFORE the air test was done! So, in closing, not only do I metal detect in North American soil, instead of Mozambique, I use a regular discriminating unit to hunt with, and my air tests are done without ground balancing first, which of course, will effect the depth a given unit will respond to a target in the air! No, other than occasionally salt water beaches, my detectors, (of which I am blessed to own several), have never reached a depth in soil, beyond a specific "air test", nor do I believe this is probable, as if that were the case, then one would logically take this as proof that minerals actually HELP a detector reach greater depths, and, if so, units with ground balance capabilities would actually HINDER detection depth! Great hunting and good luck, all!! Regards, Richard