Distinguishing Citrine & Quartz

[BurntBear]

I've struggled a bit with this, but I think I'm catching on; we'll find out, lol.

Although Citrine is a color-variety of Quartz, there always seems to be controversy & speculation as to "what" is "what" and what is real.
I've researched and the only real difference that I can see is how the trace minerals (aluminum, iron oxides, etc.) are placed in, or on the crystal.
So, if the foreign minerals are inclusions; it is technically stained Quartz and if they are actually part of the crystal structure, it would be Citrine.

I took this photo today of one of my specimens of Smoky Quartz with a yellow appearance to it:



Under magnification, you can clearly see that the yellow is from inclusions of foreign minerals:



I tried another specimen:



Under magnification, this one turned out different. The crystal itself is yellow and although there are a few spots that are inclusions; I believe these trace minerals are part of the crystal structure.



Any input and help would be appreciated!

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

A Handbook of Civil War Bullets and Cartridges - Grab it through Amazon!

[Buckshotnc]

I have the same problem distinguishing between quartz with iron stain and citrine or topaz, hope someone could help us out on this.

 

[G Freeman]

I have the same problem distinguishing between quartz with iron stain and citrine or topaz, hope someone could help us out on this.

Quartz and Citrine has specific gravity can be 2.60 to 2.70 because they are both quartz and Topaz has SG 3.5 range. Hope that helps.

 

[G Freeman]

BruntBear I believe that is one of the best questions that you ask, that I have read on Tnet. Someone will really have to know about that and I have noticed a slack in response to that one. I am waiting for a response to find that out too.

 

[hvacker]

Most of the quartz crystals I've found are often stained a orange brown color that usually doesn't affect all the crystals. Citrine was once called "the poor mans topaz" so it would seem citrine would more resemble topaz leaning more to lime yellows. One of my books, The Gemstone Handbook by Arthur Thomas, says citrine is fairly rare in nature and most of the commercial stuff is obtained by heat treatment.

Maybe it's easier to find a topaz.

 

[BurntBear]

Much easier to find Topaz! I probably found 30-40 Topaz specimens to 1 Citrine specimen!

 

[Eu_citzen]

Yellow stained quartz will often have the colour mainly inside cracks and the likes. That's one hint.

Citrine on the other hand is just yellow quartz, quartz without stains. It is coloured by Iron (ions) in the crystal structure. This is what a bi-colour quartz-citrine can look like:


yes, natural untreated citrine is rare!

Topaz has a striation that goes in a different direction then quartz, feel heavier and has cleavage. All good typical signs, the hardness is also a good idea to test if your not certain.
Topaz will scratch quartz.

 

[Buckshotnc]

Thanks to all !!

 

[Mineral54]

I know this is a little bit off the subject but what is that you use to magnify and take the picture?

 

[BurntBear]

I used a 10x loupe placed in front of the lens of a digital camera and used the macro setting.

 

[Mineral54]

Thanks, I'm gonna try that.