Cherry Picking Morgans/Peaces

[GEOFF]

I havent hunt for awhile due to a health condition but I never stopped looking.

Today was at a jewelry shop, guy has bags full tubes of silver dollars for $30 a piece.

I checked a couple and saw a semi-key date (only realized it on feebay after I left). After I left and checked feebay, its worth more than $30 on feebay.

The problem is I cant remember the dates without bring me a redbook or a list.

Should I walk in with a list of semi-key and key date or the redbook and ask the guy to let me pick? Is that too obvious for cherrypicking?

What should I say when he askes me about the list? (in additional to my "fill up my dasco album" line)

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

Minelab PRO-FIND 35 Waterproof Pinpointer Metal Detector for Experts with Tone ID & Adjustable Sensitivity - Grab it through Amazon!

[boristhespider88]

I havent hunt for awhile due to a health condition but I never stopped looking.

Today was at a jewelry shop, guy has bags full tubes of silver dollars for $30 a piece.

I checked a couple and saw a semi-key date (only realized it on feebay after I left). After I left and checked feebay, its worth more than $30 on feebay.

The problem is I cant remember the dates without bring me a redbook or a list.

Should I walk in with a list of semi-key and key date or the redbook and ask the guy to let me pick? Is that too obvious for cherrypicking?

What should I say when he askes me about the list? (in additional to my "fill up my dasco album" line)

I would just say you we're trying to fill a coin album. That's what I would do. I don't think you should elaborate any more than that. What coin is it?

 

[GlenDronach]

Here's what I would do:

Bring in your redbook/printed list from online, with some common dates highlighted or crossed off (coins you're definitely not interested in). Then show that, say you're looking to fill out your collection more, and ask to sort. That way you can cherry pick without being obvious, and walk away happy.

Remember eBay's pricing though, expect about 20% loss when all fees from eBay and paypal are done.

 

[GEOFF]

I would just say you we're trying to fill a coin album. That's what I would do. I don't think you should elaborate any more than that. What coin is it?

IF i remembered correctly from 4 hours ago, it was a 1893O

 

[bigscores]

I have most of the keys of other series remembered, but the barbers and morgans I just cannot remember. I have a list on my phone of what I need, I've told my dealer it's just a list of coins I need for my albums (which is true, lol) and he doesn't give a crap.

 

[GEOFF]

Here's what I would do:

Bring in your redbook/printed list from online, with some common dates highlighted or crossed off (coins you're definitely not interested in). Then show that, say you're looking to fill out your collection more, and ask to sort. That way you can cherry pick without being obvious, and walk away happy.

Remember eBay's pricing though, expect about 20% loss when all fees from eBay and paypal are done.

Its about ~14%, shipping exclusive.