Can anyone tell me if these are Civil War 3 ringers?

Truth

Truth

Gold Member
Apr 13, 2016
14,332
32,145
Abita Springs La....Born in New Orleans
🥇 Banner finds
2
🏆 Honorable Mentions:
1
Detector(s) used
EQUINOX 800
Primary Interest:
Metal Detecting
They all have basically flat bottoms let me know what you think thank you IMG_1042.JPGIMG_0002.JPG


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

How to Research for Treasure Hunting and Metal Detecting From Lead Generation to Vetting - Grab it through Amazon!
Upvote 0
The one on the left in the group picture looks like it has ridges in the grooves. If so, it would date no earlier than the early 1870s. Can you post sharper pictures of each bullet?
 

Looks like it. Can't really tell from the pictures. If there are little lines in the grooves, they are post Civil War. Knowing the caliber would help.
 

I can not see reeds on the one in your hand (they may be there) , "IMO" the Third bullet form the Right is most likely Post Civil War.

They 'look' to be 54 cal or smaller ???

Also look's to skinny for a .54 Merrill but ???

As you know 'measurements' are needed.

I still keep good condition bullets like that even if post Civil War.
 

Davers said:
I can not see reeds on the one in your hand (they may be there) , "IMO" the Third bullet form the Right is most likely Post Civil War.

They 'look' to be 54 cal or smaller ???

Also look's to skinny for a .54 Merrill but ???

As you know 'measurements' are needed.

I still keep good condition bullets like that even if post Civil War.
Click to expand...

Hey Davers would weighing them help?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

smokeythecat said:
Looks like it. Can't really tell from the pictures. If there are little lines in the grooves, they are post Civil War. Knowing the caliber would help.
Click to expand...

When I get home I'm a take better pictures


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Middle one in last picture is post 1870. Precise diameter and length will help with a correct ID. If you don't already have one a digital caliper is a great addition to a relic hunter's tool chest. You can get a good one at most auto parts stores for about $20.00.
 

Attachments

  • 20170923_225749.jpg
    20170923_225749.jpg
    189.1 KB · Views: 69
fyrffytr1 said:
Middle one in last picture is post 1870. Precise diameter and length will help with a correct ID. If you don't already have one a digital caliper is a great addition to a relic hunter's tool chest. You can get a good one at most auto parts stores for about $20.00.
Click to expand...

I'll be getting one tomorrow. Thanks again

So this one you think?IMG_1066.JPG
 

Last edited:
Harbor freight has digital calipers for a little over $10 and scales for around $10 as well. I got the scale and it works rather well to tenths of a gram. I think I'll grab the calipers next time . I assumed for $10 it would be crap but the scales lasted several months no problems and even came with batteries.
 

What is the 'solid base' telling you?
 

Truth1253 said:
Who me?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Click to expand...

Yes, you and Charlie..

Charlie asked if they were all solid base and you said you were wondering as well. I have a few bullet lead similar so I'm trying to learn something here.
 

Most CW bullets don't have a solid base... there is a cavity in the base. Look at the chart in the second post, Minie balls have a cavity to catch gas, in their base.

T1253... I think you got one that is the real deal, and two bazingas. Clean them with a soft toothbrush, look in the rings, if there are little lines (google: cannelures), then the bullets are post CW. These were added in the 1870s/80s.

After another look, I see cannelures in one of them.

One looks really good, but that solid bottom stumps me...

Maybe Relic Nut will stop by and offer his opinion, as he is the CW bullet guy IMHO.
 

Last edited:
Carolina Tom said:
Most CW bullets don't have a solid base... there is a cavity in the base. Look at the chart in the second post, Minie balls have a cavity to catch gas, in their base.

T1253... I think you got one that is the real deal, and two bazingas. Clean them with a soft toothbrush, look in the rings, if there are little lines (google: cannelures), then the bullets are post CW. These were added in the 1870s/80s.

After another look, I see cannelures in one of them.

One looks really good, but that solid bottom stumps me...

Maybe Relic Nut will stop by and offer his opinion, as he is the CW bullet guy IMHO.
Click to expand...

Thanks, Tom.. Perhaps I'll post mine up soon. I have 4-6 different ones, none of them solid, all found in the same patch of woods.
 

Carolina Tom said:
Most CW bullets don't have a solid base... there is a cavity in the base. Look at the chart in the second post, Minie balls have a cavity to catch gas, in their base.

T1253... I think you got one that is the real deal, and two bazingas. Clean them with a soft toothbrush, look in the rings, if there are little lines (google: cannelures), then the bullets are post CW. These were added in the 1870s/80s.

After another look, I see cannelures in one of them.

One looks really good, but that solid bottom stumps me...

Maybe Relic Nut will stop by and offer his opinion, as he is the CW bullet guy IMHO.
Click to expand...

Thank you Tom I see the little lines you're taking about but like you said the flat bottom has me guessing. Maybe I'll pm Relic Nut.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

You must log in or register to reply here.

CSA Grave Marker

⬅️ Previous Thread

Is this authentic?

Next Thread ➡️

Top Member Reactions

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 3 (members: 0, guests: 3)
Steve's Detector Rods

Latest Discussions

Back
Top