Can anyone help me ID this eagle button?

grasshopper

Bronze Member
Aug 13, 2007
1,866
2,857
Upstate NY
🥇 Banner finds
1
Detector(s) used
XP Deus/Deus 2
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
I haven't had luck finding an exact match. It's a two-piece button, I'm guessing artillery? There is no backmark, just the stars.

I was assuming civil war era, but like I said, could not find an exact match.

Thanks!
 

Attachments

  • 20170524_010959.jpg
    20170524_010959.jpg
    835.7 KB · Views: 123
  • 20170524_011103.jpg
    20170524_011103.jpg
    801 KB · Views: 91
Nice find! I recently posted an ACW button on this forum, entitled "Should Be An Easy One," wherein TheCannonBallGuy describes buttons like the one you have as a lower-level officer's button because of the lettering.
 

Upvote 0
Im not certain, but even lacking a specific name in the backmark it is a raised mark in a depressed channel (RMDC) which I think would be civil war or a bit earlier. As I said, I'm not certain -- I'm hoping that someone more knowledgable than me will answer as to wether this is always true?
 

Upvote 0
Actually, that particular version of eagle-A button is from a lot earlier than the civil war. It's peculiar version of spread-winged eagle, having a skinny neck, long skinny wings, and featherless skinny "shins" above the talons, is one of the 1830s/1840s versions of eagle-button eagle. In general, 1850s and civil war ones had a thicker neck and wings, and feathered fatter shins.

Callicles, I must clarify what I said about eagle-letter buttons being for low-level officers. Before the 1854 advent of the "un-lettered shield" eagle button, just for Enlisted-men's ranks (non-officers), all US Army ranks wore a lettered shield button, except for the Engineer Corps, which had its own distinctive emblem on its buttons.

Grasshopper, congratulations, it's cool to find a version of eagle-A button, especially a 2-piece one, which is not shown in the Albert button-book. ("Record Of American Uniform And Historical Buttons / With Supplement" by Alphaeus H. Albert.) Your button might be shown in the Tice button-book, but the time as I type this is 1:15AM EDST, so checking my Tice book will have to wait until the weekend.
 

Upvote 0
Actually, that particular version of eagle-A button is from a lot earlier than the civil war. It's peculiar version of spread-winged eagle, having a skinny neck, long skinny wings, and featherless skinny "shins" above the talons, is one of the 1830s/1840s versions of eagle-button eagle. In general, 1850s and civil war ones had a thicker neck and wings, and feathered fatter shins.

Callicles, I must clarify what I said about eagle-letter buttons being for low-level officers. Before the 1854 advent of the "un-lettered shield" eagle button, just for Enlisted-men's ranks (non-officers), all US Army ranks wore a lettered shield button, except for the Engineer Corps, which had its own distinctive emblem on its buttons.

Grasshopper, congratulations, it's cool to find a version of eagle-A button, especially a 2-piece one, which is not shown in the Albert button-book. ("Record Of American Uniform And Historical Buttons / With Supplement" by Alphaeus H. Albert.) Your button might be shown in the Tice button-book, but the time as I type this is 1:15AM EDST, so checking my Tice book will have to wait until the weekend.

Thanks for the info!! I knew it looked a bit different than normal CW eagle buttons... I found it at a 1790s site about 300 feet from the foundation. It was right in front of the currently occupied house, circa 1980 .
 

Upvote 0
Sigh. I made a 1AM (very late night) thinking error in my previous post. I meant to say, prior to 1854 all US Army ranks wore eagle-letter buttons, EXCEPT for Colonels and Generals, who wore Staff Officer buttons after that type began being issued in the 1830s. NOT "all ranks" as my previous post mistakenly said.
 

Upvote 0

Top Member Reactions

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top