Big silver almost went in the trash

mr_larry

Hero Member
Jun 22, 2010
504
169
Northern California
🏆 Honorable Mentions:
1
Detector(s) used
Minelab Explorer SE Pro
Primary Interest:
Metal Detecting
Yesterday morning I was up early to join Jim (Time4Me) for a hunt. After feeding my cats I was waiting for the coffee to finish brewing. While I was standing at my kitchen counter I thought to myself, "I really need to clean up the counter and sort through this mess."
kitchen.JPG
Yes, I am single! Is it that obvious?

I grabbed this rusty looking hunk of metal and I'm wondering why it has been sitting on my counter for the last two weeks. I had pulled it out of a sidewalk tear-out. I remember digging it up and it being a good signal. When I pulled it out of the hole I thought maybe it was one of those brass snap valve covers due to its shape. I also remember wondering what it was doing under a sidewalk, but I realized it was rather pointless to try to figure that out.
Blob.JPG

I figured I would toss it in the trash. As I picked it up and looked at the edge, something caught my eye.
edge.JPG

Is that silver?
As it had dried out for the last two weeks the crust had become very brittle and I cracked open the cookie.
cracked open.JPG

Remember it is just after 5:00 AM and I haven't had any coffee and the light is poor. I was thinking it must be some sort of half dollar at first, but then I grabbed a nearby clad half dollar and realized it was a dollar sized coin.

Last night I rubbed it out with some baking soda to clean off the gray crust.
cleaned1.JPG cleaned2.JPG

It's a 1922-S Peace Dollar!, and my first one. I found a Morgan dollar in January, but I will save that for another post. So this is my second silver dollar this year!

I have a new rule: Before throwing away random blobs, I should hit them with my Sunray probe to listen again and try to figure out what it might be before throwing it away. It makes me wonder if I have thrown away any other crusted up coins...

Thanks for reading and happy hunting!
 

Upvote 23
Good thing you caught that! Nice find :)
 

One mans' almost trash is a new found treasure. Nice Oreo :)
 

Boy you did bout mess up.great looking piece dollar.way to go.
 

Thanks for the heads up, I never thought a silver coin could crust up that bad. Oh yeah, great find, still on my wish list.
 

Thanks for the heads up, I never thought a silver coin could crust up that bad. Oh yeah, great find, still on my wish list.

This was found in San Francisco which was built mostly on sand dunes. There is sand under all of the sidewalks. Judging by the color of the concretion, it appears that there was a piece of iron nearby that slowly dissolved into rust and fused the sand together. It was hard when I found it, but quite brittle after it had dried out.
 

Last edited:
that was a close call. awesome peace dollar. been waiting nearly 4 decades for my first. I just know it has to be awesome to dig one
 

Congratulations :icon_thumright:
 

I love this post! I'm so glad you didn't throw that puppy out.
 

Wow-never saw any dry land coin that crusted. Saltwater coins-yes. Nice catch.
 

Now THAT is an amazing story and a beautiful coin! The pics tell the tale. Great save!
 

Holy cow! That would have been a tragedy to throw that away. Congrats on the GREAT find, and then discovering that find again.
 

Hmmm, I have some crusty stuff that went Beep. Better investigate that. Though I'm pretty sure it will turn out to be a bolt or a washer. LOL. I haven't thrown away any rusty stuff from last year. Great save.
 

Top Member Reactions

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top