Best thrift stores?

Fruitbat

Full Member
Joined
Sep 24, 2006
Messages
100
Reaction score
0
Golden Thread
0
Detector(s) used
ACE 250
I would think it wouldn't matter if it was big city or rural ..what matters is if the person pricing knows what it is an it's value
 

I find all (except one) to be a bad bet. Last year I took a vacation day and hit about 20 thrift stores. Only one would work with me. I went to the manager and offered to buy ALL brass and copper items at a set price per pound and I had a good scale. On the one that worked with me, I left with two big boxes of junk that would probably never sell and they had $40-50 more in their till.

I stopped at big chain stores, local church stores and even two korean mom&pop stores. It was a big chain that worked with me.
 

I find all (except one) to be a bad bet. Last year I took a vacation day and hit about 20 thrift stores. Only one would work with me. I went to the manager and offered to buy ALL brass and copper items at a set price per pound and I had a good scale. On the one that worked with me, I left with two big boxes of junk that would probably never sell and they had $40-50 more in their till.

I stopped at big chain stores, local church stores and even two korean mom&pop stores. It was a big chain that worked with me.

What do you do with the brass/copper?
 

As a lot of us do here, I go to local thrift stores to find items to sell. I'm starting to visit thrift stores when I'm out of my area. Actually got a couple nice finds while at the beach this summer. I'm hoping to get a few days off next month and go search thrifts outside my local area. Which is better big city thrifts or small rural thrifts?

Its very hard to say. As creeper stated, it really depends more upon the knowledge / intention of the person pricing the items than the location of the store. My office is in an urban environment and there is thrift store within walking distance. New product comes into the store everyday and is immediately priced and put our the floor. I visit the store every wednesday morning because the person responsible for pricing on wednesdays only assigns three prices to all items $.50 $1.00 and $5.00. It doesn't matter what the item is, she only uses those three prices. She is a local well-to-do house wife and simply has no interest in trying to get more for the donated items. The other two "pricers" are far more sophisticated and tend to over-price items (e.g. Mikasa crystal bowl for $10.00).

In general, I avoid for-profit thrifts and focus on charity thrifts. Not always, but quite often, the charity thrifts are staffed by individuals associated with the given charity (e.g. retired nurses, lay clergy etc.) and temporary workers who aren't especially skilled in pricing antique / vintage / collectible items. If I was going to your new area I would look for thrifts that are associated with a religious institution / charitable institution (other than Goodwill -- re-sale is, afterall, their business).
 

It really varies store to store. Of the five or six Goodwills near me, only one is good and maybe another is ok to find stuff in. The rest are too picked-over or the prices are too high (for instance a sterling ring set with cubic zirconia for $175). There aren't too many independent thrift stores in my area, but I've had some amazing luck at "vintage" shops and estate shops. I mean the places that are just stacked floor-to-ceiling with junk and are barely organized. They usually only have set prices on some of the more obviously valuable or eye-catching items, and the rest is free for you to sift through.

As for location, the suburban stores seem to be more picked-over than the urban stores.
 

I'd like to see some of the thrift stores that some people shop.

I've been buying and selling for years, but have yet to score anything decent out of a standard thrift shop in our area. I don't know if it is that all the good stuff is gone by the time that I get there, or if it is picked by the employees before it gets to the retail floor.

A friend of mine spends enormous amounts of time in thrift shops, and while he gets excited about his finds, I am less than impressed. "I got this high end tape deck for just $12.99!!!!" he will say. A quick search on ebay will show that it could have been bought for $24.99 with free shipping...saving at least 10 hours of browsing in a stinky and dirty thrift shop.

Maybe it is me, but I simply find no deals in thrift shops.
 

In general, I avoid for-profit thrifts and focus on charity thrifts. Not always, but quite often, the charity thrifts are staffed by individuals associated with the given charity (e.g. retired nurses, lay clergy etc.) and temporary workers who aren't especially skilled in pricing antique / vintage / collectible items. If I was going to your new area I would look for thrifts that are associated with a religious institution / charitable institution (other than Goodwill -- re-sale is, afterall, their business).
Well we have some stores here in NE Ohio called the ....Cancer society...And there prices are off the wall higher than some Goodwills............
 

Goodwill bins, pay buy the pound, its the only way, I spent $40 today, got home listed 2 things on amazon already made my money back. EVERYTHING else is profit, plus found a bunch of clothes for the family!
 

randazzo1 said:
In general, I avoid for-profit thrifts and focus on charity thrifts. Not always, but quite often, the charity thrifts are staffed by individuals associated with the given charity (e.g. retired nurses, lay clergy etc.) and temporary workers who aren't especially skilled in pricing antique / vintage / collectible items. If I was going to your new area I would look for thrifts that are associated with a religious institution / charitable institution (other than Goodwill -- re-sale is, afterall, their business).

I haven't thought of it that way, but that's what I find locally too. Of the 2 thrifts in my town, 1 is a Goodwill. The Goodwill is hit or miss ( mostly miss). The other is for a food charity for low income people in the area. I've gotten lots of good stuff from there. Today was 1/2 price day there. I got an Under Armor shirt that I had planned to give to my son for $1.50. Turns out its way too big for him. I plan to put it on eBay. I'm sure I can get my $ back.
 

There's a Goodwill and a Salvation Army fairly close to me, and both are hit or miss as well, (like someone already said, mostly miss). If you want clothes, they're great. Small stuff like knick knacks, jewelry, bags, etc- they're not so bad. However, if you look at the bigger things like a sofa, dresser, end tables, etc, they're out of their mind. We looked at a little table at GW that was 2x2 tanle about 3' high, one leg mostly broken, the top stripped so the compressed part was showing and some hole that looked like something was attached to it a one time. I'm not handy but figured I could kind-a fix it and use it on the porch. We called someone over ansd we figured we'd give them $5 for it, the lady said they wanted $40 but would take $30. My wife told her she was nuts and we left. At SA, we found a dresser that was real nice and we needed one at the time. It was a name brand but I don't remember the brand, actually my wife had to tell me it was a name brand, we offered $70- they wanted $250 and said no, waited a month, went back offered $50, got same response- showed floor person the add where you could get it brand new for about $100 more than what they're asking, still wouldn't budge so we left. I've been to ther GW's and SA's that were operated way better than these 2. Don't know why these 2 near me are so screwing people over especially when the sales are supposed to be helping those in need.
 

The stores around me are awful for picking. The stuff is either junk (junque) or if it has ANY potential, it is priced about double what I can get for it. I've pretty much given up on shopping there for sale items.
 

at goodwill I've only scored real unique items that most people don't have an eye for, like a set of wooden hand carved decorative wine stoppers
 

I'm almost scared to type this, but I have 2 Salvation Armies around here that sell records for 10 cents each. I'll pick out 50 or so (pretty much anything that is not junk) and as soon as I sell one record, everything else is profit. I make hundreds every time I pick up a lot of records.

If you are going to your thrift and finding absolutely nothing, then sorry to say, you should do some research and find more types of stuff to look for. I live in a rural area, but I never come out empty handed, and there is almost always at least one good item that pays for all of the rest of the stuff that I bought when I list it.
 

I've always had great luck at thrift stores. Goodwills tend to suck, as people before me have said, but I know a few really good and cheap salvation armies. I would say I've had my best luck at either deep city thrifts or very rural thrifts. High traffic suburbs are the worst. Also, living in a city, the thrift stores in bad neighborhoods are excellent. Very cheap, and the best stuff gets completely overlooked because most people in the store are looking for stuff to use, not to sell.
 

Deep city thrifts are the best! the kind most are too scared to go to
 

If you are going to your thrift and finding absolutely nothing, then sorry to say, you should do some research and find more types of stuff to look for. I live in a rural area, but I never come out empty handed, and there is almost always at least one good item that pays for all of the rest of the stuff that I bought when I list it.

Simply not true. A lot of variables are at play here...

I have been going to my local thrift closest to my house for 4 years now (regularly). I can count on one hand the number of time I actually bought something there. Sure, I could easilly pick up stuff and make 50 cents here or a dollar there but as far as I'm concerned I would rather have my money tied up in more liquid items with a better profit margin.
 

Sure, I could easilly pick up stuff and make 50 cents here or a dollar there but as far as I'm concerned I would rather have my money tied up in more liquid items with a better profit margin.

Yeah, I have all my money tied up in hootch, that's as liquid as one could get :icon_thumright: :tongue3:
 

Top Member Reactions

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom