a chance to buy a couple of halves

[ohdigger]

a guy at work wants me to make him a offer on these a 1825 & 1854

thanks for lookin & any comments will be appreciated

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

Cry Of The Eagle: History And Legends Of The Cherokee Indians And Their Buried Treasure - Grab it through Amazon!

[Charlie P. (NY)]

I'd grade them Very Good on the '25 and About Good on the '54. Maybe $65 for the pair? My very unprofessional and free appraisal.

http://www.pcgs.com/prices/default.aspx

 

[mainer]

I would agree vg on the 1825, but I would call the seated G. 2010 redbook has the 1825 at $85 in VG, and the 1854 at $30. This like Charlie is my unprofessional opinion.

Mainer

 

[Charlie P. (NY)]

Note that the "book" is not close to what you can sell it for and should not be what you pay, either. ;-)

OK, Mainer. I yield to your "Good" on the '54. I checked my more recent Photograde and Mr. Ruddy is easier than the Brown & Dunn Guide to the Grading of United States Coins I pulled the About Good from. I really like the line drawings in the B&D book; but those two are harsh on older silver. A great guidebook, none the less.

Buy with Brown & Dunn and sell with Ruddy.

 

[mainer]

Hey Charlie P, I know not to put all my trust in the book but it was the only reference I have right now. So was the only reference I could give. Its funny I dug out a couple old redbooks from the 60's you could buy these coins and anything else you wanted for nothing be good to have those prices back if only for a day. Thanks for your reference on the books you use going to look into them.

Mainer

 

[stefen]

The value is when the seller and buyer are satisfied with the offer and acceptance...

Use the book as a reference only then make an offer...

The coins are not rare and are barely in the 'Good' range...

I'd start low and set a maximum limit when counter-offering...take a walk when the limit is countered...

 

[coinshooter]

Don't use the PCGS website for coin values they are super inflated.
Don't believe me? Check on other sites like Coin World or any other price guides you can find. I guarantee that PCGS
exagerates the heck out of their prices. For what reason I don't know unless it has something to do with dealers being able to sell their coins for higher prices to unscroupulous buyers.